@convenientlie: Well this would seem to work in theory, I think the question is how it would work in practice. With morals off, the Scarab would take over, he tends to go for the kill, so I don't think anti radiation would be his go-to method of attack. The other issue is how fast does it work? Could Hulk avoid it? If it didn't work immediately, could Hulk go and smash Blue Beetle before it totally depowered him? I have been unable to locate these scans over google, and it seems like other people are having trouble too. If you know what they are, might it be a little easier if you looked them up and posted them? It doesn't seem like anyone else can locate them.
I only see Blue Beetle being a problem in this fight, but with morals off he's a huge threat. Close fight but I say team 6/10. Also to address the argument from earlier, about red tornado being able to take the JL, and therefore he could take Hulk. This ABC logic is addressed in the Battles Bible sticky. According to that, "The very same applies to high end feats as well. Don't spam "Spidey beat Firelord, therefore he beats anyone less than Firelord!" You'll get no respect with that silliness."
Does anyone know of a feat where Stargirl made an anti-grav field so large? I know she can make the fields, but has she ever been shown to make one strong/large enough to carry someone into space?
@ghostravage: Well, here's what I'm unsure about. I agree that Stargirl needs to be conscious to use the rod, but if she uses it, and than is knocked unconscious, does Hulks gravity return? Additionally, if she used the rod immediately (which I'm also not sure she would, since it's not really something she does often), would Hulk be angry and powerful enough to KO her in one shot? Whether Stargirl could BFR is contingent on that I think. If it doesn't work, it makes for a much more interesting fight.
Even if Hulk thunderclaps after the star rod is used, he's still floating into outer space. At best that makes it a draw. Additionally, unless we're assuming he starts at his most angry and powerful, I'm not sure his thunderclap would kill. He could start by thunderclapping Stargirl immediately, but I doubt he does that most of the time, since he should be busy in melee with Cheetah and the other heavy hitters, and has no knowledge of Stargirls capabilities. I say Team wins 6 or 7/10. Please correct me if any of that is off, I'm not extremely knowledgeable about Hulk.
When I have issues mailed to me, I order from http://www.midtowncomics.com/. Very affordable, and they have a huge stock of old and current singles. No subscription required.
Log in to comment