38 Comments
Posted by dondave

Superman

Posted by New_World_Order

Superman

Posted by son_of_tomorrow

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

Posted by isaac_clarke

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

What comic did you read where Superman one-shotted Thor? He was muttering on how it was the toughest fight he's ever had and Thor exhausted him to the point he gets KOed by Iron Man, She Hulk and Hercules ganging up on him.

It still amazes me that he was able to catch Mjolnir with the palm of his hand without breaking given Thor's hammer strikes have hurt more durable characters; everything from sky-fathers to abstracts. But feel free to consider that canon, given it's canon for DC (or at least was) - but certainly not Marvel.

In regards to the thread:

Undetermined, Superman has pulled off one insane feat since his retcon that his pre-flashpoint counterpart wouldn't have been capable of, but outside that we don't have many stunning feats for Clark to work with and a particular vulnerability to magical lightning that suggest Thor on hit might actually really do some damage.

Posted by sommyt

Thor destroys him if fighting to best of ability ..

Posted by sommyt

@dondave: no

Posted by guttridgeb

When fighting to the best of their ability, Thor will be able to drain the solar energy from Superman's cells. Thor takes this.

Posted by dondave

@sommyt: why no?

Posted by Floopay

Thor for me.

Thanks for reading,

Floopay

Posted by Dextersinister

@guttridgeb said:

When fighting to the best of their ability, Thor will be able to drain the solar energy from Superman's cells. Thor takes this.

Even if Thor could do that I doubt it's a matter of simply willing it to happen.

As always it will end in Thor being blitzed.

Online
Posted by The_Lunact_And_Manic

Thor.

Posted by SHARKBEARAGATOR

@guttridgeb: Before he gets speed blitzed to death doubt it.

Edited by guttridgeb

@Dextersinister said:

@guttridgeb said:

When fighting to the best of their ability, Thor will be able to drain the solar energy from Superman's cells. Thor takes this.

Even if Thor could do that I doubt it's a matter of simply willing it to happen.

As always it will end in Thor being blitzed.

I'm pretty sure he can do that, Mjolnir has a lot of uses that Thor never bothers with. Presumably it works like by willing it happen just like most other applications.

Posted by sommyt

@guttridgeb: dude Thor fighting to the best of his ability superman better get out of here Thor when he gets serious has hurt abstracts ...just his lightning hurt a god that had absorbed 98% of the multiuniverse ...

Posted by AllStarSuperman

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

@ThunderGodsWrath

said:

Superman

@dondave

said:

Superman

Superman wins. hes faster stronger smarter and more durable

Posted by guttridgeb

@sommyt said:

@guttridgeb: dude Thor fighting to the best of his ability superman better get out of here Thor when he gets serious has hurt abstracts ...just his lightning hurt a god that had absorbed 98% of the multiuniverse ...

Fair enough, I'm not aware of all of his high-end feats so I went for the option I was almost certain would work :)

Posted by sommyt

@guttridgeb: yea they dont like showing Thors high end feats that much with him using full power ..look at an instance with just wind alone .. wind of a thousand worlds

Posted by New_World_Order

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

Superman would beat Thor maybe. It's debatable. Also if anyone's getting one-shotted. It would be Superman.

Posted by son_of_tomorrow

@ThunderGodsWrath said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

Superman would beat Thor maybe. It's debatable. Also if anyone's getting one-shotted. It would be Superman.

Superman has beaten Thor in the cross-over with a one shot. DC accepted it as canon,while marvel does not.So basically he has beaten him,and made it look pretty dang easy. Even though he said it was his toughest opponent, which I don't believe since the battle lasted like 3 panels.And Thor didn't really even touch superman like that.

Edited by GypRosetti

Given Superman's invulnerability to magic and the fact he has been tanked by lightning Thor wins this easily.

Superman v Catpatin Marvel 001
Superman v Catpatin Marvel 002
Superman v Catpatin Marvel 005
Superman v Catpatin Marvel 006
Superman v Livewire 001
Superman v Livewire 002
Superman v Viking 001
Superman v Viking 002
Posted by New_World_Order

@son_of_tomorrow said:

@ThunderGodsWrath said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

Superman would beat Thor maybe. It's debatable. Also if anyone's getting one-shotted. It would be Superman.

Superman has beaten Thor in the cross-over with a one shot. DC accepted it as canon,while marvel does not.So basically he has beaten him,and made it look pretty dang easy. Even though he said it was his toughest opponent, which I don't believe since the battle lasted like 3 panels.And Thor didn't really even touch superman like that.

You were saying?

Posted by UltraSuperTrooper

my vote is for Thor

Posted by FiMFTW

It all comes down to whether Superman can kill Thor before he uses Mjolnir to BFR or drain him.

Posted by ULTRAstarkiller

@ThunderGodsWrath: PIS

Posted by GypRosetti

@ThunderGodsWrath: Marvel's revenge for Batman beating Hulk.

Posted by Freefa11

@son_of_tomorrow said:

@ThunderGodsWrath said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

Superman would beat Thor maybe. It's debatable. Also if anyone's getting one-shotted. It would be Superman.

Superman has beaten Thor in the cross-over with a one shot. DC accepted it as canon,while marvel does not.So basically he has beaten him,and made it look pretty dang easy. Even though he said it was his toughest opponent, which I don't believe since the battle lasted like 3 panels.And Thor didn't really even touch superman like that.

You need to re-read that if that's what you think. Their fight was about 12 panels, and Thor hit him at least twice (not counting Superman catching his hammer). Superman punched him at least 3 times, plus a full dose of heat vision. He also got beat down by the rest of the Avengers almost immediately afterwards, and without much difficulty.

Posted by New_World_Order

@ULTRAstarkiller: Superman one-shotting Thor is PIS

@GypRosetti said:

@ThunderGodsWrath: Marvel's revenge for Batman beating Hulk.

Lol that happened?

Posted by New_World_Order

@Freefa11 said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

@ThunderGodsWrath said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

Superman would beat Thor maybe. It's debatable. Also if anyone's getting one-shotted. It would be Superman.

Superman has beaten Thor in the cross-over with a one shot. DC accepted it as canon,while marvel does not.So basically he has beaten him,and made it look pretty dang easy. Even though he said it was his toughest opponent, which I don't believe since the battle lasted like 3 panels.And Thor didn't really even touch superman like that.

You need to re-read that if that's what you think. Their fight was about 12 panels, and Thor hit him at least twice (not counting Superman catching his hammer). Superman punched him at least 3 times, plus a full dose of heat vision. He also got beat down by the rest of the Avengers almost immediately afterwards, and without much difficulty.

Yep

Posted by GypRosetti

@ThunderGodsWrath: If Disney ever buys DC from Time Warner they'll get revenge for this and job Superman to Hulk:)

Posted by New_World_Order

@GypRosetti said:

@ThunderGodsWrath: If Disney ever buys DC from Time Warner they'll get revenge for this and job Superman to Hulk:)

LOL, oh man..

Posted by son_of_tomorrow

@ThunderGodsWrath said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

@ThunderGodsWrath said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

Superman would beat Thor maybe. It's debatable. Also if anyone's getting one-shotted. It would be Superman.

Superman has beaten Thor in the cross-over with a one shot. DC accepted it as canon,while marvel does not.So basically he has beaten him,and made it look pretty dang easy. Even though he said it was his toughest opponent, which I don't believe since the battle lasted like 3 panels.And Thor didn't really even touch superman like that.

You were saying?

Not that cross over the jla/avengers cross over is canon not these comics.so yea.....

Edited by son_of_tomorrow

@Freefa11 said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

@ThunderGodsWrath said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

Superman would beat Thor maybe. It's debatable. Also if anyone's getting one-shotted. It would be Superman.

Superman has beaten Thor in the cross-over with a one shot. DC accepted it as canon,while marvel does not.So basically he has beaten him,and made it look pretty dang easy. Even though he said it was his toughest opponent, which I don't believe since the battle lasted like 3 panels.And Thor didn't really even touch superman like that.

You need to re-read that if that's what you think. Their fight was about 12 panels, and Thor hit him at least twice (not counting Superman catching his hammer). Superman punched him at least 3 times, plus a full dose of heat vision. He also got beat down by the rest of the Avengers almost immediately afterwards, and without much difficulty.

Post these 12 scans then,because I remember their fight not lasting no more than 3 panels.Unless your talking about all the teams fighting in 12 scans.Because they didn't even make the superman and thor fight that long. And I remember just one hit from superman that laid him out,catching the hammer,and hitting him with heat vision. And so what if he got jumped by the avengers? Thor got jumped by a bunch of nobodies in siege and was blasted to near death/@ThunderGodsWrath said:

@Freefa11 said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

@ThunderGodsWrath said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

Superman would beat Thor maybe. It's debatable. Also if anyone's getting one-shotted. It would be Superman.

Superman has beaten Thor in the cross-over with a one shot. DC accepted it as canon,while marvel does not.So basically he has beaten him,and made it look pretty dang easy. Even though he said it was his toughest opponent, which I don't believe since the battle lasted like 3 panels.And Thor didn't really even touch superman like that.

You need to re-read that if that's what you think. Their fight was about 12 panels, and Thor hit him at least twice (not counting Superman catching his hammer). Superman punched him at least 3 times, plus a full dose of heat vision. He also got beat down by the rest of the Avengers almost immediately afterwards, and without much difficulty.

Yep

Above.

@GypRosetti: All those scans are cis and pis

Posted by Freefa11

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Post these 12 scans then,because I remember their fight not lasting no more than 3 panels.Unless your talking about all the teams fighting in 12 scans.Because they didn't even make the superman and thor fight that long. And I remember just one hit from superman that laid him out,catching the hammer,and hitting him with heat vision.

I didn't say 12 scans, I said 12 panels. You said 3 panels. You also said he got 1-shotted. Getting punched multiple times and shot with heat vision is not 1 shot.

And so what if he got jumped by the avengers? Thor got jumped by a bunch of nobodies in siege and was blasted to near death

Thor was the heaviest hitter on his team. Superman going down easily immediately after their fight is a pretty obvious indicator the fight was not that easy for him.

Which "nobodies" nearly killed Thor in Siege?

Posted by thanosii

wasnt that match fan voted? To the best of thier abilities Thor just uses lightning then takes supermans soul.

Posted by Freefa11

@thanosii: No, only the "Marvel vs. DC" crossover in the 90's was fan-voted, and in that one Superman fought (and defeated) the Hulk. Thor fought (and defeated) Captain Marvel. That's also the one with the infamous instance of Wolverine defeating Lobo (also Storm defeating Wonder Woman was pretty bad).

All the other Marvel/DC crossovers were just written by the writers, including JLA/Avengers. I'm sure there was no small amount of editorial politicking going on, but there was no fan input involved.

Posted by thanosii

well soul steal shud still win does supes hav resistance

Posted by New_World_Order

@son_of_tomorrow said:

@Freefa11 said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

@ThunderGodsWrath said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

Superman would beat Thor maybe. It's debatable. Also if anyone's getting one-shotted. It would be Superman.

Superman has beaten Thor in the cross-over with a one shot. DC accepted it as canon,while marvel does not.So basically he has beaten him,and made it look pretty dang easy. Even though he said it was his toughest opponent, which I don't believe since the battle lasted like 3 panels.And Thor didn't really even touch superman like that.

You need to re-read that if that's what you think. Their fight was about 12 panels, and Thor hit him at least twice (not counting Superman catching his hammer). Superman punched him at least 3 times, plus a full dose of heat vision. He also got beat down by the rest of the Avengers almost immediately afterwards, and without much difficulty.

Post these 12 scans then,because I remember their fight not lasting no more than 3 panels.Unless your talking about all the teams fighting in 12 scans.Because they didn't even make the superman and thor fight that long. And I remember just one hit from superman that laid him out,catching the hammer,and hitting him with heat vision. And so what if he got jumped by the avengers? Thor got jumped by a bunch of nobodies in siege and was blasted to near death/@ThunderGodsWrath said:

@Freefa11 said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

@ThunderGodsWrath said:

@son_of_tomorrow said:

Superman,already been done in comics.Superman one shot him.

Superman would beat Thor maybe. It's debatable. Also if anyone's getting one-shotted. It would be Superman.

Superman has beaten Thor in the cross-over with a one shot. DC accepted it as canon,while marvel does not.So basically he has beaten him,and made it look pretty dang easy. Even though he said it was his toughest opponent, which I don't believe since the battle lasted like 3 panels.And Thor didn't really even touch superman like that.

You need to re-read that if that's what you think. Their fight was about 12 panels, and Thor hit him at least twice (not counting Superman catching his hammer). Superman punched him at least 3 times, plus a full dose of heat vision. He also got beat down by the rest of the Avengers almost immediately afterwards, and without much difficulty.

Yep

Above.

@GypRosetti: All those scans are cis and pis

LOL, i'm not even going to counter this..

Posted by InnerSuperman

bump haha this is going to be good