Exmaster3000

I can see him killing Glaurung, but I am kind of iffy with the balrog tbh. I think 1-4 is easy, balrog 50/50 and Glaurung 60/40 in favour of Gotrek. Ancalagon is too much by size alone.

Felix can occupy one for a while, and Gotrek with his axe cleaves the other in little bits. Team Warhammer wins with both of them alive in the end.

Gotrek has this in the bag. Even for a WHF Dwarf his strength is supercharged. And as mentioned before, this is what he does.

I just can’t see geralt taking this. The witchers whole thing is to study and exploit the monsters individual weaknesses and use the most effective weapons against them. If they were alle to beat them...

I think Talions immortality and time altering/control abilities would give him the edge

@cheth: Agreed on every assesment except Ungrim vs Grom part. I see no way of Grom winning against Ungrim in any scenario.

Wow, this is alot to unpack.First I think that Gotrek vs Tyrion is going to last forever and ultimately after a hard, grueling and beiond close fight Gotrek edges the slight win.Thorgrim vs eltharion ...

@the_wspanialy: I’d say so yes. In pretty much every encounter the axe has bit through everything it has been used against to even when enchanted. Even when something has been able to stop the axe it ...

I say Gotrek. Tyrion is top tier but I see Gotrek as a just a wrecking ball of martial might. I think that as Gotrek wears no armor that it would be actually a positive thing in this fight, as he woul...

@cheth: throgg doesn’t have many feats but id say that as a troll he has more tools in combat than gorfang. Mostly what comes to ming is that throgg heals and has his vomit to use. Also gorfang can’t ...

Yea Ungrim is in general at the level of Gotrek but Gotrek is just that tiny bit better. So a super close and great fight but Gotrek takes the win.

I think Guilles for the slight majority. He does not have many quantifiable feats but I personally rate him comparable to louen. Considering the grail knights as whole, I would actually give the speed...

@starbreaker: You could try Fulgrim or mortarion vs Valdor. Or perhaps even Magnus or lorgar.

@cheth: Ok, memory does not serve, I guess :D

@cheth: True. In shaman Slayer I think he did fight against both a ghorgon and a doombull I believe.

@cheth: Agreed but as I recall Gotrek fought the bloodthirster severely winded did he not? It has meen a long time when I last read the books but I seen to recall him mining through a tunnel and fight...

@cheth: Greasus as an Ogre is superior to Grom in every way. The Scepter of titans is up there with gotrek’s axe in power and guality and the overtyrants crown makes greasus way smarter than Grom.And ...

Greasus stomps all rounds all ways. Greasus is a top tier warhammer combatant where grom is maby mid tier, even if his waagh was the greatest ever assembled, excluding end times.PS:Greasus eats Grom a...

@cheth: Well he is an Orc wearing armor so his toughness exeeds both snaga and his mount. He is also way stronger.Only way for snaga to win is to try and poison Borgut and wear him out that way.

I’d say Borgut wins the slight majority or a draw because of the mount.