Equonox

Scenario:

Gotham city, at night - Scarecrow's exact location is unknown to team 2 and has a ton of fear gas he's going to release.  Sinestro happens to be chilling there too, and seeks to capitalize.

This thread is hilarious.

" Robocop gets an explosive batarang between the eyes before he can blink. "

Damn, thought the thread was referring to spartans a la Halo.  In THIS case, clearly Cap...spears, swords, and regular humans have nothing on a super soldier w/ an adamantium shield.

Team 2 - combat XP being a key factor.
Batman is not the weak link - DP is certainly the weak link, in terms of combat XP and actual feats (he was also knocked out by a woman with a giant hot dog, mind you...).

The only arguments in favor of team 1 so far are "these two have super powers, one of team 2 has none".  Not very compelling, IMO.  Bruce has not only shown himself to be on par than many heroes/villains with powers, but has bested TONS of super powered individuals and groups throughout his history, even where heroes far more powerful than either of team 1 have failed (White Martians, Darkseid, Amazo, etc.).  Batman has prepared gear and multi-tiered combat strategies (Plan A, Plan B, Plan C...) for literally EVERY super hero and villain in the DCU via the Brother Eye project.  This includes not only metahumans with regenerative capabilities, but some that are just purely invulnerable.  This makes me think that KO'ing DP for him would be relatively easy, probably with some sort of gas or electric batarangs.

As for Spiderman, I think both of team 2 would be necessary to take him down...Bruce would probably need to use some gear to create a distraction for/disable his spidey-sense, while the combination of Wolverine and Bruce's knowledge of martial arts and combat tactics would probably overpower spidey, despite his strength/speed advantage.

KO or to the death?  If KO, team 2 - in fact, DS may solo if that's the case; far superior fighter to either of team 1.  Better tactician, FAR more intelligent, equivalent tech.

If it's death, team 1 easy - can't kill Deadpool.

Gandolf solo'd a Balrog "in the movies".  That's a solid feat.

Yea, but Batman isn't that pathetic/dumb.

Batman wins.  Batman is clearly peak human as well - master strategist, knows every combat style (master level), technological genius, etc.  Cap, while excelling in H2H combat (SS serum obviously accounts for something), he has nowhere near the intellect Batman does.  At best, he is a marginally better fighter, but EVERYTHING else Batman has available to him gives him a clear edge. Heat seeking, exploding battarangs anyone?