I think this issue deserved a 4. Your criticisms seem a little bit off, G-Man. That is an awfully short "bad" paragraph for a 3, and you really don't go very in depth in your critiques. I'd like to know what specifically felt "off" about the story. Just saying that it felt off and that it might not be a necessary story to tell doesn't really seem like grounds for that low of a rating. And I don't think it's fair to judge a story based on it's necessity- whether it's necessary or not, we're getting it, so let's judge the story on how well it's told, not whether it needs to be told.
All in all, I don't think this rating is entirely fair.
This was great. should be 5 or 4 stars.
I agree with these. That issue was amazing. That part where you see the lizards eating the kids *shiver*.
Log in to comment