Well... in my opinion there both right to a specific existent. But cyclops has more of my vote... hears why

Hes VERY hard on his mutants treats them like solders instead of family & hes cold and calculating. but if you lost as many friends , family & most of your species as he has lost you would probably be the same way.

In one of the newer x books wolvie mentions... (spoilers)

He believes scott has them brainwashed to think there solders in the the fight for mutant survival.

''all he talks about is how were targets & how we gotta be ready for war''

well logan... hes kinda right

between the sententials , hellfire club

Friends of humanity , leper queen , bastion , the purifiers , Graydon creed the list goes on & ON & ON (not to mention most regular people dont like them and have tried to kill them)

mutant kind has been attacks numerous times. all through out the x men's story with in the x force arc mutants were being once again demonized by the public , killed , captured drugged & being turned into bombs , then there was operation zero tolerance , the slaughter fest that happened during the incident in genosha & most recently the giant sentential with the magnetized core that attacked during scizim

time to time they attempt to be just like regular hero's like the time during fear itself when they had to stop juggernaut from causing a rampage they risked there lives to stop him & they did... but guess what happened? the government saw that most of them were no longer on utopia to defend it. so they decided to try and nuke the island... until cyclops intervened.

They ALWAYS get attacked & its not the last time ether. & to add to all this there are currently only 200 of them left. they are currently an endangered species they do have to be ready for war at all times. its the only logical way to be if your a mutant... of course cyclops isnt COMPLETELY right

yes there in a fight for there race. that true.. however they arent just your solders the x men are your family.

wolverine is right to an extent the kids should have a school they should be able to have so type of release from being a solder all the time. & they shouldnt so easily be sacrificed (as cyclops does to so many of his ''solders'')

But what do you think? which ones ideal sounds best?

I believe both are right. & should embrace both of there ideas solders & students that way there not to soft but not to hard at the same time. & they need to stick together. because there is always something that is headed there way. like a sentential or a villain or perhaps another superhero group led by a guy wearing the American flag... just sayin