44 Comments
Posted by TheGoldenOne
Uncle Ben
Gwen Stacey
Superman Prime should die and stay dead >_>
Darkseid
Posted by Dracade102

Uncle Ben

Johnny Storm (To keep what impact of his death is left)
Psycho Pirate
Gwen Stacy
Victor von Doom's Mother 
Martha & Thomas Wayne
Rorschach
Johnathan Kent
Alexander Luthor
Posted by Primmaster64

Everyone who dies.

Posted by cattlebattle
@Primmaster64 said:
Everyone who dies.
this is correct
Posted by Caligula
@cattlebattle said:
@Primmaster64 said:
Everyone who dies.
this is correct
I agree third. (if you kill a character, DO NOT UNDO IT).
Posted by Adnan
@Primmaster64 said:
Everyone who dies.
Apart from Resurrection Man, I agree lol.
Posted by moviegeek17

the jackal and kraven (though admittedly the gauntlet/grim hunt were amazing stories!)

Posted by Billy Batson

Everyone who dies...

Online
Posted by War Killer

Steve Rogers should have stayed dead....

Posted by DalekDoctor2011
@War KillerWHAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by Aronmorales
@Billy Batson said:

Everyone who dies...

Edited by saturnssailor
At least 80% of the people that die should stay dead, but a few should come back every now and then(not at the frequency that they do now). If a character dies and comes back the next time they die they should stay dead.  
 
You know the quote " The only people who stay dead in comics, are Bucky, Jason Todd, and Uncle Ben." Now even that's only true for Uncle Ben.

As for specific characters: 
Uncle Ben 
Jean Grey (Doesn't her gravestone even say "She will rise again"?)
Blue Beetle  
Posted by Kallarkz
@Billy Batson said:

Everyone who dies...

This. 
Making characters stay dead would force writers to come up with better ways to improve some stories where they believe that killing someone to just later bring them back is going to make things better. 
Take Uncle Ben for example. His death stood for something and writers have been able to continue to honor that death for years. 
If you kill a character allow them to rest. Recycling characters is not what most readers are looking for nowadays. 
Posted by Doctor!!!!!

Me!!! .....and the Daleks...
Posted by Kal'smahboi
Edited by DalekDoctor2011

@Kallarkz
My opinion is:

  • Characters who die should stay dead for seven years minimum to ten years maximum if there are popular.  

  • If they are brought back don't kill them off again for at least twenty years (Steven Moffat STOP killing Rory!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)

  • If they aren't popular (don't you dare bring Adric back Moffat) like Toad, Pyro, Frog-Man, Porcupine and any character who has taken up the mantle of a great hero (Yes, that was directed at you and your fans Bucky) don't bring them back EVER!!!!!!

Posted by Mutant God

every good character/hero
Posted by Benzo

The Sentry!!!!!!! But knowing Marvel he will probably return in a surprise comeback....

Posted by mewmdude77
@Dracade102 said:
Uncle Ben
Johnny Storm (To keep what impact of his death is left)
Psycho Pirate
Gwen Stacy
Victor von Doom's Mother 
Martha & Thomas Wayne
Rorschach
Johnathan Kent
Alexander Luthor
I wanna add: 
Jean Grey 
Sentry 
Jackal 
Kraven the Hunter 
Ultimate Peter Parker 
Reed Richards 
and any character who's death represents something important or leaves a big impact!!!

Posted by Dracade102
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
Uncle Ben
Johnny Storm (To keep what impact of his death is left)
Psycho Pirate
Gwen Stacy
Victor von Doom's Mother 
Martha & Thomas Wayne
Rorschach
Johnathan Kent
Alexander Luthor
I wanna add: 
Jean Grey 
Sentry 
Jackal 
Kraven the Hunter 
Ultimate Peter Parker 
Reed Richards 
and any character who's death represents something important or leaves a big impact!!!

He's dead?!

HE MUST STAY THIS WAY!!!

Posted by mewmdude77
@Dracade102 said:
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
Uncle Ben
Johnny Storm (To keep what impact of his death is left)
Psycho Pirate
Gwen Stacy
Victor von Doom's Mother 
Martha & Thomas Wayne
Rorschach
Johnathan Kent
Alexander Luthor
I wanna add: 
Jean Grey 
Sentry 
Jackal 
Kraven the Hunter 
Ultimate Peter Parker 
Reed Richards 
and any character who's death represents something important or leaves a big impact!!!

He's dead?!

HE MUST STAY THIS WAY!!!

he's not dead, I wish he was though. He's been dead before and thats why I put him on my list. If they ever kill him again, IT BETTER BE PERMANENT OR I"M GONNA FIRE MY LAZER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by Dracade102
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
Uncle Ben
Johnny Storm (To keep what impact of his death is left)
Psycho Pirate
Gwen Stacy
Victor von Doom's Mother 
Martha & Thomas Wayne
Rorschach
Johnathan Kent
Alexander Luthor
I wanna add: 
Jean Grey 
Sentry 
Jackal 
Kraven the Hunter 
Ultimate Peter Parker 
Reed Richards 
and any character who's death represents something important or leaves a big impact!!!

He's dead?!

HE MUST STAY THIS WAY!!!

he's not dead, I wish he was though. He's been dead before and thats why I put him on my list. If they ever kill him again, IT BETTER BE PERMANENT OR I"M GONNA FIRE MY LAZER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  
If Dr Doom fails in killing him there's always DOCTOR OCTAGONAPUS.
Posted by mewmdude77
@Dracade102 said:
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
Uncle Ben
Johnny Storm (To keep what impact of his death is left)
Psycho Pirate
Gwen Stacy
Victor von Doom's Mother 
Martha & Thomas Wayne
Rorschach
Johnathan Kent
Alexander Luthor
I wanna add: 
Jean Grey 
Sentry 
Jackal 
Kraven the Hunter 
Ultimate Peter Parker 
Reed Richards 
and any character who's death represents something important or leaves a big impact!!!

He's dead?!

HE MUST STAY THIS WAY!!!

he's not dead, I wish he was though. He's been dead before and thats why I put him on my list. If they ever kill him again, IT BETTER BE PERMANENT OR I"M GONNA FIRE MY LAZER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  
If Dr Doom fails in killing him there's always DOCTOR OCTAGONAPUS.
Doctor Octagonapus? 
Posted by Dracade102
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
Uncle Ben
Johnny Storm (To keep what impact of his death is left)
Psycho Pirate
Gwen Stacy
Victor von Doom's Mother 
Martha & Thomas Wayne
Rorschach
Johnathan Kent
Alexander Luthor
I wanna add: 
Jean Grey 
Sentry 
Jackal 
Kraven the Hunter 
Ultimate Peter Parker 
Reed Richards 
and any character who's death represents something important or leaves a big impact!!!

He's dead?!

HE MUST STAY THIS WAY!!!

he's not dead, I wish he was though. He's been dead before and thats why I put him on my list. If they ever kill him again, IT BETTER BE PERMANENT OR I"M GONNA FIRE MY LAZER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  
If Dr Doom fails in killing him there's always DOCTOR OCTAGONAPUS.
Doctor Octagonapus? 
The mastermind behind THE LAZER. 
 
  
Posted by mewmdude77
@Dracade102 said:
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
Uncle Ben
Johnny Storm (To keep what impact of his death is left)
Psycho Pirate
Gwen Stacy
Victor von Doom's Mother 
Martha & Thomas Wayne
Rorschach
Johnathan Kent
Alexander Luthor
I wanna add: 
Jean Grey 
Sentry 
Jackal 
Kraven the Hunter 
Ultimate Peter Parker 
Reed Richards 
and any character who's death represents something important or leaves a big impact!!!

He's dead?!

HE MUST STAY THIS WAY!!!

he's not dead, I wish he was though. He's been dead before and thats why I put him on my list. If they ever kill him again, IT BETTER BE PERMANENT OR I"M GONNA FIRE MY LAZER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  
If Dr Doom fails in killing him there's always DOCTOR OCTAGONAPUS.
Doctor Octagonapus? 
The mastermind behind THE LAZER. 
 
  

HELL YES!!!! WE NEED DR. OCTOGANAPUS AND HIS SON!!!!!!!!!!!!! WHERE DO THEY LIVE??????????? Also link the adress of that video to me please 
Posted by Dracade102
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
@mewmdude77 said:
@Dracade102 said:
Uncle Ben
Johnny Storm (To keep what impact of his death is left)
Psycho Pirate
Gwen Stacy
Victor von Doom's Mother 
Martha & Thomas Wayne
Rorschach
Johnathan Kent
Alexander Luthor
I wanna add: 
Jean Grey 
Sentry 
Jackal 
Kraven the Hunter 
Ultimate Peter Parker 
Reed Richards 
and any character who's death represents something important or leaves a big impact!!!

He's dead?!

HE MUST STAY THIS WAY!!!

he's not dead, I wish he was though. He's been dead before and thats why I put him on my list. If they ever kill him again, IT BETTER BE PERMANENT OR I"M GONNA FIRE MY LAZER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  
If Dr Doom fails in killing him there's always DOCTOR OCTAGONAPUS.
Doctor Octagonapus? 
The mastermind behind THE LAZER. 
 
  
HELL YES!!!! WE NEED DR. OCTOGANAPUS AND HIS SON!!!!!!!!!!!!! WHERE DO THEY LIVE??????????? Also link the adress of that video to me please 
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjRjqOL5IBA&feature=player_embedded
Posted by mewmdude77

thanks! 

Posted by Nefarious

Everyone that died.

Posted by TheRedRobin

Ted Kord 
Ultimate Spiderman

Edited by DalekDoctor2011

Update: 

  • Ultimate Spider-Man and every character that died during Ultimatum

  • Wasp

  • Human Torch (for about 7 years then bring him back)

  • any clone (bar Scarlet Spider) that dies

  • Jason Todd

  • Adric (from Doctor Who)

Posted by Misterkyle91

Cable
Posted by noj

Its cool for all you guys to say "dont bring any dead character back EVAR!!!!' but think of it realistically. If no one in comics ever came back to life when they died there would be no one left! No Superman, Batman, Spider-Man, Capt America, Green Lantern, Flash, ect. How exactly do you write comics without anyone to write them about?

Posted by Chaos Burn

Uncle Ben
Bruce Waynes Parents
Jason Todd

Posted by Mega_spidey01

ultimate peter parker 
goliath 
everyone that died during ultimate universe wave   
gwen stacy 
kraven the hunter 
jason todd 
captain america  
bruce wayne  

Posted by Primmaster64

....What is Superman had stayed dead?

Posted by HombreMan

H.E.R.B.I.E

Snarf

Orko

Princess Python

Danny Chase

Posted by ArturoCalaKayVee

If people stayed dead in comics then it would take away from the fantasy factor. It could create loss, despair, and anger that people don't want to feel in reality. Comics are an escape from the horrors of real world which is why it's a much more "perfect" version of ours. I mean, yeah, there's loss and destruction in every issue but that all is resolved in the end some how. That's how i see it, at least. I read comics for the escape, it's different for others.

Posted by Soulstealer

@noj said:

Its cool for all you guys to say "dont bring any dead character back EVAR!!!!' but think of it realistically. If no one in comics ever came back to life when they died there would be no one left! No Superman, Batman, Spider-Man, Capt America, Green Lantern, Flash, ect. How exactly do you write comics without anyone to write them about?

Not kill them off frivolously in the first place? I know it sounds hard-line, but shock value death is stupid and I for one believe that death shouldn't be a light decision in comics.

Posted by TheCannon

I don't think they should of ever brought Bucky back. But it's too late for that.

Posted by Video_Martian

Uncle Ben & Gwen Stacy.

Posted by KidKhaos21

I agree with your choice but why Jesse Bedlam? To me, he would have been a great character to X-World if writers knew what they was doing to him. But I do think he alive though.....

Posted by DraketheSlaughter

1. Jason 2. Todd 3. Sentry 4. Gwen Stacy 5. Uncle Ben

Posted by Baberaham_Lincoln

Genis Vell should come back... he should be used more, Sane version..

Posted by Cap10nate

I'm all for bringing people back as long as there is a good story to tell since that is why i read comics