@Vance Astro: It should totally be filmed in America, especially the WW2 Nazi German bits. Film that shit in Florida for a real authentic feel.
Maybe if there was a REAL Captain America then yeah he should probably be American.. But a film, a portrayal of a fictional character, fuck it an actor who can act will do the job fine. But you know I think it's good to try out new things..
@Vance Astro: Right, I get you, I get what you're saying.. But on screen, what makes someone American? I'm just saying that if they get an actor who can act, why can't they be from wherever? What difference does it make..?
@Son_of_Magnus: Hey man, if the German can do a good Winston Churchill impression I'm not going to knock it..
Hmm, I'm still unconvinced, if an actor can portray a character well enough I'll go with it, regardless of their heritage, background and accent.. if the acting is bad though - yeah, it'll be a total fail.