24 Comments
Posted by IcePrince_X

I think this the fight that Emma can win. She knows how Bobby thinks and how his powers work...she has been inside him and pushed all his powers to its extreme levels.

Bobby's weakness really are psionic attacks...which Emma specializes.

Posted by CellphoneGirl

Emma would easily  win..

Posted by DH69

psychic wins escecially when she can turn into a diamond when she needs to.

Posted by The Psyentist

My view of the battle:
Emma Frost vs. Iceman
Starts on the Golden Gate bridge.
Emma wins via telepathy and fight ends on the Golden Gate bridge.
The end.

Posted by Caligula

emma

Posted by pixelized

EMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM-uhhhhhhhhhhhh

Moderator
Posted by Kataklysmo
Iceman just dies from sheer shyness at seeing Emma's hot bod
Posted by White Mage

If Iceman had Ororo-level willpower after the body swap, then I would be voting for him.  However, he's still weak and immature.  He's fodder for Emmas telepathy. 

Posted by Edamame

Jean couldn't even detect Iceman when he was in mist form. That shows that Iceman is not vulnerable to telepathy. 

Posted by DedmanWalkin

This is less a battle of power and more a battle of reaction time because if Iceman gets his attack first then he win while if Emma attacks first she wins. This is essentially the cold war.

Posted by JediXMan

Emma wins.

Posted by Korg

Emma wins. She's far more ruthless, and already knows her way around Iceman's brain. She helped him unlock his full potential, ffs.

Edited by Edamame
@Korg: Even Jean couldn't detect Iceman in mist form.  Iceman in immune to TP. 
 
@DedmanWalkin said:
" This is less a battle of power and more a battle of reaction time because if Iceman gets his attack first then he win while if Emma attacks first she wins. This is essentially the cold war. "

How does Emma win anyway?
Edited by Korg
@Edamame said:

" @Korg: Even Jean couldn't detect Iceman in mist form.  Iceman in immune to TP.  "

Emma possessed him for an extended period of time. He is most definitely not immune to TP. Iceman also does not just hang out in "mist form". 
Posted by Edamame
The instance with Emma was before Jean wasn't able to detect Iceman in mist form.  Iceman has become more powerful now.  Also, the instance with Jean proves that he is indeed immune to telepathy, especially considering the fact that Jean is one of the most powerful and skilled telepaths in the X-Men Universe.  
 
No. Iceman does not always hang around in "mist form," but he can if he wants to.  And if he can't be telepathically detected in mist form, then how would he be detected in any other form?
Posted by Korg
 @Edamame said:
" Also, the instance with Jean proves that he is indeed immune to telepathy,"
No, it doesn't. Bobby has had Emma inside his head since. She restored his access to his powers after Decimation.
 
@Edamame said:
" No. Iceman does not always hang around in "mist form," but he can if he wants to. "
Proof? It is extremely taxing for Bobby to transition from mist to water to ice. Even if he did do it, what use would it be in this battle? To try to stalemate Emma? He will have to become corporeal again at some point, or he will lose by KO.
Edited by Edamame
@Korg said:

"  @Edamame said:

" Also, the instance with Jean proves that he is indeed immune to telepathy,"

No, it doesn't. Bobby has had Emma inside his head since. She restored his access to his powers after Decimation.
 
@Edamame said:

" No. Iceman does not always hang around in "mist form," but he can if he wants to. "

Proof? It is extremely taxing for Bobby to transition from mist to water to ice. Even if he did do it, what use would it be in this battle? To try to stalemate Emma? He will have to become corporeal again at some point, or he will lose by KO. "

 I already said that the instance with Emma was before the encounter with Jean.  
 
It is no longer extremely taxing for Iceman to do such a thing because he has become more powerful, which includes his new immunity to TP.  
Why would it be a stalemate? 
Iceman in his mist form could simply enter Emma's body, freeze her water molecules, completely destroy her body, and then reform himself.  He does not have to stay corporeal. 
 
Losing by KO was not specifically stated in the OP.
Posted by Korg
@Edamame said:
"  I already said that the instance with Emma was before the encounter with Jean.   "
You're wrong, as Jean was dead during Decimation. 
 
@Edamame said:
"It is no longer extremely taxing for Iceman to do such a thing"
Proof? 
 
@Edamame said:
" Iceman in his mist form could simply enter Emma's body, freeze her water molecules"
Emma can transform into organic diamond, which doesn't contain any water.
Posted by Edamame
@Korg said:
" @Edamame said:
"  I already said that the instance with Emma was before the encounter with Jean.   "
You're wrong, as Jean was dead during Decimation. 
 
@Edamame said:
"It is no longer extremely taxing for Iceman to do such a thing"
Proof? 
 
@Edamame said:
" Iceman in his mist form could simply enter Emma's body, freeze her water molecules"
Emma can transform into organic diamond, which doesn't contain any water. "

1. The incident between Jean and Iceman occurred after Decimation. Also, was Iceman willing to let Emma telepathically control him?
 
2. Because he has done so in the comics and showed no tire.  I will get sources to exemplify this.  Even if it is taxing, he will still do it.  It is not like he can be killed or KOed; at least not anymore.  
 
3. Good point. But what is the difference between diamond and organic diamond? Does it contain any form of heat or energy or particles that are in motion?  
Posted by PrinceIMC

Emma wins. Even if Bobby showed some kind of resistance to telepathy in a mist form (I never saw this happen, not saying it didn't but even if it did doesn't mean its a common thing for him to do) I still think Emma will nab him with her mind.
Posted by Edamame
@PrinceIMC: Right now, Iceman can do these things with ease. I will try to get the source for the Jean encounter.
Posted by Korg
@Edamame said:
" 1. The incident between Jean and Iceman occurred after Decimation. Also, was Iceman willing to let Emma telepathically control him?  2. Because he has done so in the comics and showed no tire.  I will get sources to exemplify this.  Even if it is taxing, he will still do it.  It is not like he can be killed or KOed; at least not anymore.    3. Good point. But what is the difference between diamond and organic diamond? Does it contain any form of heat or energy or particles that are in motion?   "
  1. What instance are you talking about? Jean has been dead since well before Decimation. Iceman was repressing his own powers, Emma had to fight his subconscious. She forced his brain to do things it did not want to do.
  2. I'll wait on the sources, but Bobby can be KO'd. Mystique got him more than once in recent memory.
  3. I have no idea, it's never been thoroughly explained.
Posted by Bo88gdan

my wote goes on iceman

Edited by THUNDERBOLT30

Emma wins easily.