@mario_nblc said:
" its pointless to even write anything bad about Emma here because it will be spit on and turned upside down to prove my point is wrong and how much other people "win". ... so blah blah blah blah she blah blah sucks blah blah blah .... "
It is indeed pointless when what you write is solely based on your personal dislike of the character, and flies in the face of everything that actually happened in the comics. "Emma is like Paris Hilton" isn't an argument, it's a cheap shot that simply doesn't apply - unless I've missed all the instances where Paris Hilton mentored young people in her community, risked her life for others, suffered immeasurable pain as millions died around her, expended great energy to turn her life around and atone for her past, rained hell down on whoever dared to attack her children, and so on.
If you feel so negatively about Emma, then at least do us the courtesy to take the time to explain why. You can't just throw a quick jab at the character and expect everybody to go, "Oh, yeah, that's so true."
It's simple: if you want to have a discussion, you need to present arguments. The Dark Huntress and others have presented theirs in defense of Emma. All you could offer was weak criticism that doesn't hold any water when confronted with facts. If Emma is a bimbo, then Reed Richards can barely spell his own name and Bruce Wayne has the planning skills of a goldfish.
In your defense, I do think Emma is one of those characters who are particularly easy to paint with a sloppy brush, who easily lend themselves to caricature and misconceptions. It's easy to see Emma as a bitch, Batman as a dark vigilante with a perpetual frown, X-23 as nothing more than a female Wolverine or Supergirl as miniskirt-wearing jailbait for pervy nerds. It's easy... until you actually read the comics, until you read Morrison, Chris Yost, Marjorie Liu or Sterling Gates.
Bottom line: I don't think you're being willingly hateful or ignorant, but you need to at least acknowledge the possibility that maybe you don't have the complete picture when it comes to Emma Frost. I'm not saying you wouldn't still hate her if you knew her better, but it would make your criticism a better basis for discussion.
Log in to comment