Would you rather...?
By Amegashita 12 Comments
Everyone has a favorite character. Some people's favorite characters aren't well known while others are mainstream to the point where a vast majority at least know who the character is. As a fan of your favorite character you take the time to learn about your character and to understand him/her. Each character is created differently and they live their comic lives differently to another character and that difference is what attracts you to those characters. Now depending on who your favorite character is and their importance to the comic world that they are a part of that character will have more appearances over a variety of varying media productions. They may appear in cross comic events, comic universe events, cartoons, TV shows, and then movies.
On to the question I want to present. With the variety of chances for your character to make an appearance it's undeniable that different writers will portray your favorite character differently and because of the different portrayals your favorite character will come off a different way just because a different writer sees that character in a certain light, if you will. So my question is, as a fan of a character are you happier when your favorite character simply appears in a story or are you happier when your character is portrayed correctly. As an offset to that question, would you rather have your character appear in a story but not be written true to character or would you rather them not appear at all.
Now last week I was reading the 12 part series "Justice", which, might I say, was amazing but that is moot in what I want to say. As I was reading that story I was constantly asking, Where is Captain Marvel? Where is Captain Marvel? In a story like that with so many characters getting some focus in the story I was really disappointed to not see Billy appear in the story... until issue 12 where Billy does in fact make an appearance. As a big fan of Captain Marvel, I was extremely happy. Through the story I was happy to see Billy's character remain true to who the Captain is. That in itself was enough reason to cheer.
During the Rise and Fall story arc this year and the Cry for Justice one as well, I was happy to see Green Arrow play an important role in the story, but as I read it I wasn't happy with how he was being portrayed. In fact, I despised how the writers were making him out to be and to say the list my anger was near limitless. Not only that, but about two years ago Oliver and Dinah finally married and that was a great moment, a moment that was about two decades late. (Really? It took that long? Should have been happened.) As a result of their marriage we got the Green Arrow and Black Canary series. One problem though, the story was supposed to focus in on both Black Canary and Green Arrow but somehow Green Arrow was the focal point of the story, which goes against the point of having the two headline the series.
When I read a story with any of my favorite characters I enjoy seeing them being written true to their actual natures and to what I know as a fan of the character. But when those characters are written completely against everything I know about them I can't help but feel angry and disappointed. Not at the characters but at the writers. As fans of certain characters we can't help but be excited when we get to see our favorite characters in a story but what I want to know is, would you sacrifice seeing your favorite character in a story if he was written horribly to not seeing him at all?
Log in to comment