Who Should Play Power Girl In The Live Action Movie?

  • 91 results
  • 1
  • 2
#51 Posted by PowerGirlFan (275 posts) - - Show Bio

#52 Edited by RandyPan (402 posts) - - Show Bio

Kat Dennings. Not only does she have the "assets", she has the personality.

#53 Edited by RageTH22 (61 posts) - - Show Bio

Alright,

@powergirlfan

you wanted size, here ya go.

Admittedly, this is largely based on looks alone, because I don't know how well she can act, and I'm too cheap to get a credit card.

Her name is Taylor Stevens. Bra size is 36HH, so she's plenty big there. She's in her twenties, and doing well as a solo porn actress. Sticks to camshows and photoshoots.

Downsides? Unknown acting ability, because I'm too cheap to find out. Also, she HAS to wear a wig because she's fighting cancer. But, hairstyles are easy to set up, and it would only take a few moments to find out what would look good.

Her face may be a little more sharply angled than needed for the part, but hey, they never get things just right for superhero movies.

Pic is an edited one from her blog site. Cropped out another person, I didn't photoshop clothes or anything. I'm just glad I didn't have to dig far.

#54 Posted by Mega_spidey01 (3080 posts) - - Show Bio

@randypan said:

Kat Dennings. Not only does she have the "assets", she has the personality.

#55 Posted by lifeofvibe (3774 posts) - - Show Bio

All I'm seeing here is who's got the boobs

#56 Posted by judasnixon (8933 posts) - - Show Bio

Gillian Jacobs (Community).....

#57 Posted by RageTH22 (61 posts) - - Show Bio

They are a signature of her character. it would be odd to cast someone with B-cups to play her role.

#58 Edited by Bruxae (16777 posts) - - Show Bio

This topic is like one big excuse for people to post chicks with big ta-ta's. :P

#60 Edited by PowerGirlFan (275 posts) - - Show Bio

@rageth22 said:

Alright,

@powergirlfan

you wanted size, here ya go.

Admittedly, this is largely based on looks alone, because I don't know how well she can act, and I'm too cheap to get a credit card.

Her name is Taylor Stevens. Bra size is 36HH, so she's plenty big there. She's in her twenties, and doing well as a solo porn actress. Sticks to camshows and photoshoots.

Downsides? Unknown acting ability, because I'm too cheap to find out. Also, she HAS to wear a wig because she's fighting cancer. But, hairstyles are easy to set up, and it would only take a few moments to find out what would look good.

Her face may be a little more sharply angled than needed for the part, but hey, they never get things just right for superhero movies.

Pic is an edited one from her blog site. Cropped out another person, I didn't photoshop clothes or anything. I'm just glad I didn't have to dig far.

So you found one girl on the internet with big boobs? LOL. How long did that take?

There are thousands of girls with boobs that big. Thousands of porn actresses/models and probably1000 times as many who are not. It's not like Taylor Stevens is the best we can do.

There are probably many regular actresses with boobs that big who we don't know about simply because most roles in popular film and TV don't allow actresses with boobs that large. Advertise a role for girls with that boob size and they would apply in droves.

Like many people on this board, you seem to be making out that big boobs are freakish and exist only in the realm of pornography (and comics).

#61 Edited by Rich_Longwalk (1 posts) - - Show Bio

How about this women?

#62 Posted by PowerGirlFan (275 posts) - - Show Bio
#63 Edited by JSAVen (128 posts) - - Show Bio

Im just bored, so ....

#64 Posted by RDClip (1739 posts) - - Show Bio

You guys know that random models and cosplayers probably don't have the acting chops to be in a big budget movie, right?

#65 Edited by Joygirl (20854 posts) - - Show Bio

@war07 said:
Gemma Atkinson

I like this one.

#66 Posted by PowerGirlFan (275 posts) - - Show Bio
#67 Posted by Joygirl (20854 posts) - - Show Bio
#68 Posted by Riot_Sqrrl (268 posts) - - Show Bio

@gwhh: who was the female lead in tucker & dale vs. evil? Anyway, her.

#70 Posted by PowerGirlFan (275 posts) - - Show Bio

@joygirl: Not enough out front for this role. That's a push-up bra she's modeling.

@riot_sqrrl: See my image above.

Okay can we drop this "cast my favorite blonde actress" bizzo and give some genuinely large-breasted actresses a go? Perfect opportunity for them and it's been a distinguishing physical feature of the character from her creation to present day.

#71 Edited by imperiex79 (5 posts) - - Show Bio

She would be perfect as Power Girl.

#72 Posted by Joygirl (20854 posts) - - Show Bio

#73 Edited by PowerGirlFan (275 posts) - - Show Bio

@joygirl said:

She's beautiful. Who is she? She looks perfect to play PG. Boobs look padded though.

Costume looks like it's made from cotton fabric. Should be spandex for the right effect.

Boob window should be wider and placed further down. Costume should be higher.cut at legs.

It's a beautiful photo too.

#74 Posted by PowerWoman (3639 posts) - - Show Bio
#75 Posted by Joygirl (20854 posts) - - Show Bio

@joygirl said:

She's beautiful. Who is she? She looks perfect to play PG. Boobs look padded though.

Costume looks like it's made from cotton fabric. Should be spandex for the right effect.

Boob window should be wider and placed further down. Costume should be higher.cut at legs.

It's a beautiful photo too.

Her name's Aileen I guess? Managed to find her facebook page.

#76 Edited by PowerGirlFan (275 posts) - - Show Bio

@joygirl said:

@powergirlfan said:

@joygirl said:

She's beautiful. Who is she? She looks perfect to play PG. Boobs look padded though.

Costume looks like it's made from cotton fabric. Should be spandex for the right effect.

Boob window should be wider and placed further down. Costume should be higher.cut at legs.

It's a beautiful photo too.

Her name's Aileen I guess? Managed to find her facebook page.

Her name is Crystal Graziano. Aileen is apparently one of her photographers.

She's busty but she is padded for her PG cosplay so I think the part should go to another girl who's the real deal and can fill the part.

#77 Posted by achilles100 (304 posts) - - Show Bio

To revive this old thread; she's never going to be in a movie. Assuming WB ever wants a heroic female Kryptonian character, they'd go for Supergirl all the time, like DC itself mostly does.

But if by some chance she was, I think you guys are going about it all wrong. Don't cast for the boobs, you'd just get a horrible actress who couldn't do the physical stuff. Cast first for overall acting ability, looks, and the ability to handle the physical aspects of such a role, then go for whichever actress met those requirements and had the biggest rack among those candidates. And she'd have to be younger than Hendricks, quite a bit in fact.

Most probably an unknown stage or soap actress, or a Brit or Aussie or the like.

#78 Posted by PowerGirlFan (275 posts) - - Show Bio

To revive this old thread; she's never going to be in a movie. Assuming WB ever wants a heroic female Kryptonian character, they'd go for Supergirl all the time, like DC itself mostly does.

But if by some chance she was, I think you guys are going about it all wrong. Don't cast for the boobs, you'd just get a horrible actress who couldn't do the physical stuff. Cast first for overall acting ability, looks, and the ability to handle the physical aspects of such a role, then go for whichever actress met those requirements and had the biggest rack among those candidates. And she'd have to be younger than Hendricks, quite a bit in fact.

Most probably an unknown stage or soap actress, or a Brit or Aussie or the like.

A Supergirl story and character would probably be too similar to the Superman movies. I don't know why they don't do a Wonder Woman movie. That could be done very well. Assuming they could find a good actress with the boobs for it :)

I wouldn't like an actress to play PG with big boobs but not the other qualities. I bet they could find an actress with boobs for the part who is also good in the other respects. There must be a lot of frustrated, talented actresses whose boobs are way too big for most other acting parts. Cast first for boobs and pick from those the actresses with the other qualities. If the part calls for big boobs, give the big-boobed actresses the break they need :)

I don't think an actress with a Brit or Aussie accent would be best.

#79 Posted by Cloakx14 (6613 posts) - - Show Bio

Alice Eve ?

#80 Edited by achilles100 (304 posts) - - Show Bio

@achilles100 said:

To revive this old thread; she's never going to be in a movie. Assuming WB ever wants a heroic female Kryptonian character, they'd go for Supergirl all the time, like DC itself mostly does.

But if by some chance she was, I think you guys are going about it all wrong. Don't cast for the boobs, you'd just get a horrible actress who couldn't do the physical stuff. Cast first for overall acting ability, looks, and the ability to handle the physical aspects of such a role, then go for whichever actress met those requirements and had the biggest rack among those candidates. And she'd have to be younger than Hendricks, quite a bit in fact.

Most probably an unknown stage or soap actress, or a Brit or Aussie or the like.

A Supergirl story and character would probably be too similar to the Superman movies. I don't know why they don't do a Wonder Woman movie. That could be done very well. Assuming they could find a good actress with the boobs for it :)

I wouldn't like an actress to play PG with big boobs but not the other qualities. I bet they could find an actress with boobs for the part who is also good in the other respects. There must be a lot of frustrated, talented actresses whose boobs are way too big for most other acting parts. Cast first for boobs and pick from those the actresses with the other qualities. If the part calls for big boobs, give the big-boobed actresses the break they need :)

I don't think an actress with a Brit or Aussie accent would be best.

Most of those actors and actresses can lose the accent quite easily. Karl Urban. Chris Hemsworth and brothers. Hell, Xena herself. Doesn't seem to be a problem for them to go American.

As for the boobs, well Marvel has done quite well casting for acting first, then physique. Chris Evans for example would have to be about 100 pounds of pure muscle heavier to look like Cap in the comics. Which is probably impossible for him, and would really restrict his movement. Instead, they went for the best they could get out of him, (which is impressive enough), and got a guy who could act and do the action stuff. Ditto for Hemsworth. Fact is, comic book physiques just don't exist in the real world, at least not those sorts of builds that still allow the person to move in action hero ways.

Would a "C" or "D" cup really make such a huge difference that you wouldn't forget it the first few minutes into a movie? Especially if the actress could own the role like RDJ?

Or would you rather have an actress with giant boobs who couldn't act her way out of a paper bag, or couldn't move in an action heroine way?

Like I said before, however, it's a moot point, Power Girl will never be in a WB/DC movie, at least not as long as TPTB at those companies remain in charge.

And not in any animated stuff either; that's now all post reboot.

Probably her only hope is a guest spot on either Arrow or The Flash. And I don't see those coming either, though she'd fit in nicely in either show, and her effect are easy by now to do.

#81 Posted by PowerGirlFan (275 posts) - - Show Bio

@powergirlfan said:

@achilles100 said:

To revive this old thread; she's never going to be in a movie. Assuming WB ever wants a heroic female Kryptonian character, they'd go for Supergirl all the time, like DC itself mostly does.

But if by some chance she was, I think you guys are going about it all wrong. Don't cast for the boobs, you'd just get a horrible actress who couldn't do the physical stuff. Cast first for overall acting ability, looks, and the ability to handle the physical aspects of such a role, then go for whichever actress met those requirements and had the biggest rack among those candidates. And she'd have to be younger than Hendricks, quite a bit in fact.

Most probably an unknown stage or soap actress, or a Brit or Aussie or the like.

A Supergirl story and character would probably be too similar to the Superman movies. I don't know why they don't do a Wonder Woman movie. That could be done very well. Assuming they could find a good actress with the boobs for it :)

I wouldn't like an actress to play PG with big boobs but not the other qualities. I bet they could find an actress with boobs for the part who is also good in the other respects. There must be a lot of frustrated, talented actresses whose boobs are way too big for most other acting parts. Cast first for boobs and pick from those the actresses with the other qualities. If the part calls for big boobs, give the big-boobed actresses the break they need :)

I don't think an actress with a Brit or Aussie accent would be best.

Most of those actors and actresses can lose the accent quite easily. Karl Urban. Chris Hemsworth and brothers. Hell, Xena herself. Doesn't seem to be a problem for them to go American.

As for the boobs, well Marvel has done quite well casting for acting first, then physique. Chris Evans for example would have to be about 100 pounds of pure muscle heavier to look like Cap in the comics. Which is probably impossible for him, and would really restrict his movement. Instead, they went for the best they could get out of him, (which is impressive enough), and got a guy who could act and do the action stuff. Ditto for Hemsworth. Fact is, comic book physiques just don't exist in the real world, at least not those sorts of builds that still allow the person to move in action hero ways.

Would a "C" or "D" cup really make such a huge difference that you wouldn't forget it the first few minutes into a movie? Especially if the actress could own the role like RDJ?

Or would you rather have an actress with giant boobs who couldn't act her way out of a paper bag, or couldn't move in an action heroine way?

Like I said before, however, it's a moot point, Power Girl will never be in a WB/DC movie, at least not as long as TPTB at those companies remain in charge.

And not in any animated stuff either; that's now all post reboot.

Probably her only hope is a guest spot on either Arrow or The Flash. And I don't see those coming either, though she'd fit in nicely in either show, and her effect are easy by now to do.

Comic muscles don't exist in real world. Comic boobs do. At least, they go way above D.

Boob size doesn't affect acting ability. We can have both.

#82 Posted by achilles100 (304 posts) - - Show Bio

@achilles100 said:

@powergirlfan said:

@achilles100 said:

To revive this old thread; she's never going to be in a movie. Assuming WB ever wants a heroic female Kryptonian character, they'd go for Supergirl all the time, like DC itself mostly does.

But if by some chance she was, I think you guys are going about it all wrong. Don't cast for the boobs, you'd just get a horrible actress who couldn't do the physical stuff. Cast first for overall acting ability, looks, and the ability to handle the physical aspects of such a role, then go for whichever actress met those requirements and had the biggest rack among those candidates. And she'd have to be younger than Hendricks, quite a bit in fact.

Most probably an unknown stage or soap actress, or a Brit or Aussie or the like.

A Supergirl story and character would probably be too similar to the Superman movies. I don't know why they don't do a Wonder Woman movie. That could be done very well. Assuming they could find a good actress with the boobs for it :)

I wouldn't like an actress to play PG with big boobs but not the other qualities. I bet they could find an actress with boobs for the part who is also good in the other respects. There must be a lot of frustrated, talented actresses whose boobs are way too big for most other acting parts. Cast first for boobs and pick from those the actresses with the other qualities. If the part calls for big boobs, give the big-boobed actresses the break they need :)

I don't think an actress with a Brit or Aussie accent would be best.

Most of those actors and actresses can lose the accent quite easily. Karl Urban. Chris Hemsworth and brothers. Hell, Xena herself. Doesn't seem to be a problem for them to go American.

As for the boobs, well Marvel has done quite well casting for acting first, then physique. Chris Evans for example would have to be about 100 pounds of pure muscle heavier to look like Cap in the comics. Which is probably impossible for him, and would really restrict his movement. Instead, they went for the best they could get out of him, (which is impressive enough), and got a guy who could act and do the action stuff. Ditto for Hemsworth. Fact is, comic book physiques just don't exist in the real world, at least not those sorts of builds that still allow the person to move in action hero ways.

Would a "C" or "D" cup really make such a huge difference that you wouldn't forget it the first few minutes into a movie? Especially if the actress could own the role like RDJ?

Or would you rather have an actress with giant boobs who couldn't act her way out of a paper bag, or couldn't move in an action heroine way?

Like I said before, however, it's a moot point, Power Girl will never be in a WB/DC movie, at least not as long as TPTB at those companies remain in charge.

And not in any animated stuff either; that's now all post reboot.

Probably her only hope is a guest spot on either Arrow or The Flash. And I don't see those coming either, though she'd fit in nicely in either show, and her effect are easy by now to do.

Comic muscles don't exist in real world. Comic boobs do. At least, they go way above D.

Boob size doesn't affect acting ability. We can have both.

Well, comic book muscles do kind of exist in the real world, with the help of steroids. But those guy are too slow to move well, and frankly very few of them can act. As for the boobs, sure they exist, but again, that runs into the problem of an action hero(ine). Can someone with that sort of rack really move like that? And frankly, how many ladies with boobs like say the Connor version of PG have really devoted themselves to acting outside the adult field?

Probably not that many, because there just aren't that many roles for them, in much the same way there aren't that many roles for say a 7 foot tall guy.

If there ever actually WAS a Power Girl in a live action production, I can pretty much guarantee a couple of things about the actress.

The first is that she'll likely be a twenty-something unknown or little known actress. The second is that her bust will probably be no more than a C or D cup.

#83 Edited by PowerGirlFan (275 posts) - - Show Bio

@achilles100: We should at least look before writing off the possibility. Include in the casting call something like "preferably with very large boobs" along with all the other requirements and see who shows up.

Perhaps the actress's boobs can be held in place by heavy-duty spandex for actions scenes. PG-size boobs should not be as big a problem as Captain America-size muscles as far as movement is concerned.

If the actress has only a C or D cup I will not recognise it as a PG movie, so it would be like there never was one anyway. For me an important thing about PG is that she is doesn't represent the typical female comic superhero physique - or personality either. Having her played by a C or D cup actress would just make her Supergirl with a different colored costume.

#84 Posted by achilles100 (304 posts) - - Show Bio

@powergirlfan: I'm sure that would be one consideration any casting director took. But I'm almost positive they wouldn't be able to find anyone like that who fit the bill for acting and action talents. So they'd move on to find someone as close physically as they can, that still is a very good actress.

Also, let's face it, for a character like Power Girl, they'd also want someone cheap.

For me, PG was never about the rack, but more about the personality. Her cup size was fun, but not an absolute necessity for me.

#85 Edited by PowerGirlFan (275 posts) - - Show Bio

@achilles100:

They'd want a cheap actress who is also a very good actress? If they want a cheap actress, it means they want to make a cheap movie, which means I could make a better one myself with six friends and a film graduate.

#86 Posted by achilles100 (304 posts) - - Show Bio

@achilles100:

They'd want a cheap actress who is also a very good actress? If they want a cheap actress, it means they want to make a cheap movie, which means I could make a better one myself with six friends and a film graduate.

Well, WB has shown they can spend a ton on a movie and still put together something you and your friend can do better than, even without the film graduate.

But I mean someone like Chris Hemsworth or Chris Evans. They weren't terribly expensive for Paramount as these things go, yet they each own their roles now. But then neither of them, especially Hemsworth, was anything like an established star. And Chris Reeve wasn't exactly as household name before Superman, and probably wasn't paid a whole lot for the role---I imagine they spent the bulk on Brando, Hackman, and the effects and sets.

#87 Posted by PowerGirlFan (275 posts) - - Show Bio

@achilles100:

Interesting point.

If they can make Chris Evans look skinny by CGIing his head onto a skinny actor, could they CGI another girl's rack onto the actress who plays PG?

BTW, if Chris Evans has played two Marvel characters, what happens when Fantastic Four show up in an Avengers film? Has anyone else asked this?

#88 Posted by bjchit (15 posts) - - Show Bio

@achilles100:

Interesting point.

If they can make Chris Evans look skinny by CGIing his head onto a skinny actor, could they CGI another girl's rack onto the actress who plays PG?

BTW, if Chris Evans has played two Marvel characters, what happens when Fantastic Four show up in an Avengers film? Has anyone else asked this?

Chris Evans didn't have his head put on another actor's body, his body was given the CGI treatment. It doesn't matter, since the Fantastic Four are being rebooted, with a black guy as Johnny Storm apparently. And even if it weren't, the movies are owned by a different studio than the ones that own the Avengers.

As for the topic question, 20 years ago I would have said Raye Hollitt, but now I think Gina Carano would make a perfect Karen Starr.

#89 Edited by MrAugen (40 posts) - - Show Bio

Much of casting is what you are going for. A set of skills such as fighting, a body type (height and dimensions), acting prowess and price, etc.

I think with effects and all these days they can adjust appearance enough that do not have to shoehorn in an actress due to looking exactly like Power Girl. Bruce Banner has been played by three actors in the past 15 years that have very different looks and could see fans of Hulk being annoyed by aspects of all three appearances.

I honestly cannot say as any sort of expertise, but I'd look to those with action film experience for stunt work.

Ali Larter of "Heroes" and the "Resident Evil" films seems a possible option as would not demand a hefty price and has experience in action genre. She could pull off the look as Kara as well if people are okay with her measurements.

#90 Edited by RandyPan (402 posts) - - Show Bio

Not only does she have the look(apart from the hair, but that can be dyed), and the, uh, assets, she also has the personality.

#91 Posted by GWHH (725 posts) - - Show Bio

Julia Benson

#92 Edited by Guyver1 (1 posts) - - Show Bio

Sorry I'm late to this party, but my pick for Power Girl would have to be Sarah Jones. She might not be overly stacked, nor is she a well know actress, but she is a good actor and looks hot with a pixie hair cut.

#93 Posted by Justthatkid (6052 posts) - - Show Bio

@guyver1: You lost me at "not overly stacked"...

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.