imperiousrix's Power Girl #16 - Snow Job: Part 1 review

    Avatar image for imperiousrix

    Dynamic Duo

    After four issues, Power Girl has me smitten.  I assure you it has nothing to do with her rather *ahem*... ample assets (to which I assure you, the title of this review has nothing to do with but rather is referring to a plot development in this issue.  TRUST ME), but rather that her book continually manages to walk the line between being comedic, action-oriented, light and frothy, dark and gritty, girly, and manly.  It might seem like this means Power Girl has a bit of an identity issue and while it's true the story could use a more laser-guided focus, that doesn't stop it from being a series worth checking out.  Issue 16 only exemplifies that fact.
     

    Enough Entendre

    For those not in the loop, the new Power Girl story arc (written by Judd Winick and penciled by Sami Basri) has Karen's company going bankrupt, the result of an inside embezzling scheme.  So, not only is Power Girl still fighting shadowy and super-powered villains and dealing with the return of Maxwell Lord (whom the first issue shows she no longer remembers due to sinister means), but she's also having to deal with the impending death of the company she worked so hard to get off the ground.  To top it all off, her friend and former employee, Nicholas Cho, has discovered that she's Power Girl.  The issue deals with most of these sub-plots, including Karen discovering what happened to Donna, the woman whom she trusted with her company's money and supposedly stole it, as well as a resolution to Nicco's little discovery.
     
    It's all handled with an efficient grace and tact by writer Judd Winick.  Nobody can ever accuse Winick of over-writing, and he really does interaction between people really well.  He mixes in humor, but doesn't force it, and gets plot points across without seeming like he's writing for the benefit of the audience.  The problem is that he sometimes doesn't seem to know when to let the pictures tell the story in terms of super-hero fights.  Some of his banter is just... eh, and while I did really like Karen's humorous quips about constantly getting her ass kicked (which has been happening an awful lot lately, which she points out), I could have done without some of the talking during fights.

    Art Shines Again

    What I could do with a lot MORE of, however, is Sami Basri's art.  I'd describe it as being "soft" and expressive, as opposed to some artists that quite frankly have a style that's a bit harsh to look at.  His faces look great, and he draws each scene dynamically, whether it's supers duking it out or it's just two people arguing.  Also, although it shouldn't surprise those following the story, the cover is actually an actual thing that happens in this issue, and it's even more starkly grim in the book than it is on the cover, and it shows Basri's versatility to draw both light and comedic happenings as well as... not so comedic events.  It's all punctuated once again by the bright and vibrant colors of Sunny Gho. 

     

    You Could Do a lot Worse

    Overall, Power Girl has just been an extremely solid series so far and #16 is just more evidence to that.  If you're not necessarily pre-disposed to liking PG, the great writing and art may be enough to draw you in.  I can't say it's the BEST series out there right now, but it definitely is worth a look if you're at least a tad interested in Karen Starr and her continuing adventures.

    Power Girl #16 gets 4 stars out of 5.

    Other reviews for Power Girl #16 - Snow Job: Part 1

      The beginning of something new 0

      Cover The cover is cool because it actually happened like that in the issue. Story Power girl is fighting a villain and at first is losing but, then wins in the end. Back at her office Nicco has figured out that she is Power Girl and all she does is deny the fact. He threatens her with something that looks like a gun. He counts down in till he is going to shoot. Before he got to pull the trigger she changed into Power Girl and disarmed him. When Power Girl had it in her hand she found out all ...

      8 out of 8 found this review helpful.

      Even Power Girl need some help sometime 0

      Someone knows who Power Girl is, and the the situation with Donna takes an unfortunate turn of events.  Pros:  Besides the opening, the two things that made this issue strong was Power Girl and Nicco Cho's relationship and what happened to Donna and her involvement of stealing money out of Karen's company. The situation between Karen and Nicco Cho was both awkward and funny at the same time, as Karen tries to play off that she's not Power Girl. Cho plays an interesting bluff on Karen to make h...

      5 out of 5 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.