She's a fairy. She has fairy wings, her powers are magical like her mother's......I think if they really wanted her to be a mutant, they should've made her mother a human woman. I don't care that her dad is Mastermind and that her hallucinatory dust is an allusion to his illusion casting. It's fairy dust and nothing will convince me that she's a mutant.

" @Thunderscream: She is a Mutant but her Mother Is a Fairy Her father Is Matermind that is where she gets her illusion powers "Pixie Dust" from Her Mother is what gives her latent Magical abiltiy But Illyana took a piece of her soul which allowed her to use Dark magic as well Her Wings im not sure about Them Her Mother hasn't Got wings so they may very well be another Mutant power of hers  So she is Half Mutant Half Fairy Cerebra/Cerebro identified her as a Mutant so she is one  Btw Just because she has Fairy wings doesn't Make her a Fairy  Angel has Angelic wings does than mean he comes from heaven.........No NightCrawler Looks like a deamon Does it make him one............No "

" @The Umbra Sorcerer said:

" @Thunderscream: She is a Mutant but her Mother Is a Fairy Her father Is Matermind that is where she gets her illusion powers "Pixie Dust" from Her Mother is what gives her latent Magical abiltiy But Illyana took a piece of her soul which allowed her to use Dark magic as well Her Wings im not sure about Them Her Mother hasn't Got wings so they may very well be another Mutant power of hers  So she is Half Mutant Half Fairy Cerebra/Cerebro identified her as a Mutant so she is one  Btw Just because she has Fairy wings doesn't Make her a Fairy  Angel has Angelic wings does than mean he comes from heaven.........No NightCrawler Looks like a deamon Does it make him one............No "

Technically.....Nightcrawler's father is the biblical "Satan" (although I despise that storyline)  I'm saying that from my perspective, her powers and her origin weigh so much more heavily on the Faerie side.....that discounting the idea that her wings and dust come from her Faerie heritage rather than her "mutancy" just seems silly to me. Yes, her father is a mutant, but that alone doesn't make her a mutant. To me, she is simply a faerie caught up in the mutant agenda, and that doesn't make her any less interesting as a character.  Not hating, just speculating. "

I can't see the purpose of this thread if nothing is going to convince you otherwise.

" Something to consider Does she have the X-Gene, then she is a mutant. "

" @jordama said:

" Something to consider Does she have the X-Gene, then she is a mutant. "

I know she's been cataloged as a mutant by Cerebro, Sentinels and the whole lot, i'm just looking at her life story as it's been presented to me. In my opinion, her status as a fairy and the powers she possesses as a mutant are too conveniently/coincidentally aligned.......in short, what's to distinguish her mutant from her fairy powers? "

" @Thunderscream: Wait....NIGHTCRALWER'S FATHER IS MEPHISTO?! WHAT THE F-----  Tell me EVERYTHING you know about this and how the hell mephisto got laid..... "

" @Thunderscream: Wait....NIGHTCRALWER'S FATHER IS MEPHISTO?! WHAT THE F-----  Tell me EVERYTHING you know about this and how the hell mephisto got laid..... "

Really, the whole concept of mutants being regarded differently from other supranormal characters in the Marvel Universe, is the main reason I'm not a huge fan of X-stories. Too me the only difference between Luke Cage and Cyclops is that the latter was born with his powers. All that matters is that she has abilities that ordinary human beings don't have.

You would think they would ask Dr Strange for assistance for mutant with magic powers. How many students does Dr strange have any way? This would be good chance for him to have more funding for his school.

Mutant with magic that I know so far include:

Scarlet Witch (obviously)

Spidergirl (is she consider a mutant yet)

Madame Webb

Wiccan    

"Really, the whole concept of mutants being regarded differently from other supranormal characters in the Marvel Universe, is the main reason I'm not a huge fan of X-stories. Too me the only difference between Luke Cage and Cyclops is that the latter was born with his powers. All that matters is that she has abilities that ordinary human beings don't have. "

"

You would think they would ask Dr Strange for assistance for mutant with magic powers. How many students does Dr strange have any way? This would be good chance for him to have more funding for his school.

Mutant with magic that I know so far include:

Scarlet Witch (obviously)

Spidergirl (is she consider a mutant yet)

Madame Webb

Wiccan    

"

"

You would think they would ask Dr Strange for assistance for mutant with magic powers. How many students does Dr strange have any way? This would be good chance for him to have more funding for his school.

Mutant with magic that I know so far include:

Scarlet Witch (obviously)

Spidergirl (is she consider a mutant yet)

Madame Webb

Wiccan    

"

" @The Umbra Sorcerer said:  "Storm also has Magical Powers(even though there not tapped in to yet) SpiderGirl isn't a mutant Wiccan i believe is a Mutant " Storm was a sorceress in a few alternate realities, but i don't believe they've carried that over to 616. "

" I can't see the purpose of this thread if nothing is going to convince you otherwise. "

"Pixie will always be cool no matter what crazy retcon ideas they dream up  <3 "

How can spider girl not be a mutant, her father was a mutate. That means she got her powers from birth and therefore she has an X-gene.

"

You would think they would ask Dr Strange for assistance for mutant with magic powers. How many students does Dr strange have any way? This would be good chance for him to have more funding for his school.

Mutant with magic that I know so far include:

Scarlet Witch (obviously)

Spidergirl (is she consider a mutant yet)

Madame Webb

Wiccan    

"

" @bleedingheart said:

" I can't see the purpose of this thread if nothing is going to convince you otherwise. "

Exactly. This moron just needs attention :P "

" @The Umbra Sorcerer said:

" @Thunderscream: She is a Mutant but her Mother Is a Fairy Her father Is Matermind that is where she gets her illusion powers "Pixie Dust" from Her Mother is what gives her latent Magical abiltiy But Illyana took a piece of her soul which allowed her to use Dark magic as well Her Wings im not sure about Them Her Mother hasn't Got wings so they may very well be another Mutant power of hers  So she is Half Mutant Half Fairy Cerebra/Cerebro identified her as a Mutant so she is one  Btw Just because she has Fairy wings doesn't Make her a Fairy  Angel has Angelic wings does than mean he comes from heaven.........No NightCrawler Looks like a deamon Does it make him one............No "

Technically.....Nightcrawler's father is the biblical "Satan" (although I despise that storyline)  I'm saying that from my perspective, her powers and her origin weigh so much more heavily on the Faerie side.....that discounting the idea that her wings and dust come from her Faerie heritage rather than her "mutancy" just seems silly to me. Yes, her father is a mutant, but that alone doesn't make her a mutant. To me, she is simply a faerie caught up in the mutant agenda, and that doesn't make her any less interesting as a character.  Not hating, just speculating. "

" I can't see the purpose of this thread if nothing is going to convince you otherwise. "

" @AMS said:

"Pixie will always be cool no matter what crazy retcon ideas they dream up  <3 "

^ Well stated :D "

" @The Umbra Sorcerer:  The idea the X-Gene is carry in the human genome mean that any being that were to reproduce with a human could possibly carry an X-Gene granting it an alternative source of power including the one it original possess. If so Pexie is in such a way, both magic by birth and mutant which is by genetic the human-side "

to all that responded, i've accepted Megan as a mutant, just didn't like the initial idea.

@Thunderscream: She is a Mutant but her Mother Is a Fairy Her father Is Matermind that is where she gets her illusion powers "Pixie Dust" from Her Mother is what gives her latent Magical abiltiy But Illyana took a piece of her soul which allowed her to use Dark magic as well Her Wings im not sure about Them Her Mother hasn't Got wings so they may very well be another Mutant power of hers  So she is Half Mutant Half Fairy Cerebra/Cerebro identified her as a Mutant so she is one  Btw Just because she has Fairy wings doesn't Make her a Fairy  Angel has Angelic wings does than mean he comes from heaven.........No NightCrawler Looks like a deamon Does it make him one............No