Say Jean and Phoenix were separated and Phoenix had a choice between Jean or Rachel.

I say Jean. She fully accesses the Phoenix and Phoenix has this obession with her.It won't let her die!!!!!!!!!

Rachel. She is a much better character and i'm sick of Jean. Let her stay dead.

i would hope that it would choose rachel.

The Phoenix would probaly be doing Jean a favor if it chose Rachel!

I wish that Jean could just have some peace!!!!!

Firechild says:

"But now there is no separation.Jean has to gather "her" pieces.I think she would have to after that whole thing with Emma and Scott and Scott doesn't love her and BLA BLA BLAlol"

this is why she needs to stay dead

But now there is no separation.

Jean has to gather "her" pieces.

I think she would have to after that whole thing with Emma and Scott and Scott doesn't love her and BLA BLA BLA

lol

iSHADOW says:

"Firechild says:

"But now there is no separation.Jean has to gather "her" pieces.I think she would have to after that whole thing with Emma and Scott and Scott doesn't love her and BLA BLA BLAlol"

this is why she needs to stay dead"

And also why that crap needs to be retconned asap.

Rachel is a hot mess....let the phoenix have her if she finds some sytle and a hot comb

fesak says:

"Rachel. She is a much better character and i'm sick of Jean. Let her stay dead."

The Phoenix would definetly pick Jean over Rachel anytime. The Phoenix was in Jean the longest and stays in her. The Phoenix simply loves Jean much more than Rachel.

Djinn says:

"The Phoenix would definetly pick Jean over Rachel anytime. The Phoenix was in Jean the longest and stays in her. The Phoenix simply loves Jean much more than Rachel."

Rachel is the daughter of the Phoenix... the storyline is not much explored but it has a bearing to the person of Rachel... she is the only one with no true identical person in any Marvel Universe as claimed by her creator and Marvel.

So, I guess, I will go with Rachel.

Rachel doesnt but in almost every universe we see in marvel the Phoenix is drawn to Jean Grey.

Jean. Rachel is too impetuous and immature to wield so much power, IMO.

Rachel.

Jean. Rachel wildly abused the power of the Phoenix for a personal vendetta. Her character was interesting in the 80s, but since then all she's done is prove that she's a pale reflection of Jean. She has all this power and does virtually nothing with it. I wish they would kill her off and leave the whole of the Phoenix Force thing dead for about a decade.

I'd rather see Rachel with it. Jean is stale as hell.

now i think about it they should just let the phoenix thing go
I mean im seriously confused about the whole story
let phoenix have some peace 

"Jean. Rachel wildly abused the power of the Phoenix for a personal vendetta. Her character was interesting in the 80s, but since then all she's done is prove that she's a pale reflection of Jean. She has all this power and does virtually nothing with it. I wish they would kill her off and leave the whole of the Phoenix Force thing dead for about a decade."

i agree, jean is the best, and your wrong jan is stronger than rachel & prettier inside and out, thats the reason why the phoenix force is obsessed with her cause she is the most powerful not rachel duh! look it up in different sites jean is the most powerful! with telepathic powers, telekinesis, and cosmic powers. with her telepathic ability she can do anything any psychic can do, read minds, brainwash, mind control, create realistic illusions, possess you or a mutant and use thier powers, hypnosis, create psionic-based constructs(which with her telekinesis can do both mental and physical damage, precognition, post cognition, control your bodily functions ( through this she can jumpstart your abilities and even your mutant abilities, she can let the mind heal the body, and even disable you of your senses, ability to walk, or even your mutant ability) ,she can play mind games in your head, can form her astral form to phase through physical objects and can attack you mentally or if combined with her telekinesis attack you physically like a ghost, Turn your emotions against you, especially inducing great fear on you. and her psychic power when she switched powers with psylocke and lost her telekinesis for a while, her psychic powers were honed to the sharpest edge, meaning they could damage the physical world (how awesome is that!!!) , she can percieve things like hidden information that not a normal human can, as the saying goes the mind infuences the physical world maybe for jean her psychic powers are deadly alright. rachel is just a sick copier who thinks she is better than her mom but really jean can defeat her anytime again and again and again! what? you know i'm right!!!!

they both suck

Jean Grey.

Jean Grey IS Phoenix.  Rachel is second best.

None

maybe Giraud though