ComicVine News
Grab our RSS feed which is "after the jump" free
Added by G-Man on March 31, 2009
Is Black Canary right to be angry? Does she "suck"? Is Hal right? Is he being too harsh? Can there only be one Justice League team?
Filed under :
Justice League Of America,
Dwayne McDuffie,
Black Canary,
Hal Jordan,
Green Arrow,
Roy Harper
31 Comments
does this mean that the big 3 were wrong?
Did they choose the wrong leader?
Should they have taken more thought in to it?
Did they choose the wrong leader?
Should they have taken more thought in to it?
Tough call with Canary. She just got through dealing with the Big-3s fancy rec-room. And even though she hasn't been one of the Birds for a while, I imagine she's not too pleased about Barbara taking that team apart.
League members come and go, that's really how its always been. Why Canary thinks her league should be different, or that she can keep people in against their better judgment is beyond me. Hal is a little out of line, though. For him to think that Canary's league isn't good enough for him is just foolish. Furthermore, for him to think he can start another team called 'Justice League' and somehow exclude the current chairperson is even more foolish.
Gorilla Grodd must be up to his old mind games again.
League members come and go, that's really how its always been. Why Canary thinks her league should be different, or that she can keep people in against their better judgment is beyond me. Hal is a little out of line, though. For him to think that Canary's league isn't good enough for him is just foolish. Furthermore, for him to think he can start another team called 'Justice League' and somehow exclude the current chairperson is even more foolish.
Gorilla Grodd must be up to his old mind games again.
That was pretty interesting. I can't wait till July to see what's going to happen.
I must say, I'm on Team Black Canary with this one. Overreacting, or out of character, her husband is leaving her to run around the universe with another man. I took it as he told himself Dinah's team wasn't working out, so he was going to jump ship and go to Hal's. It's like he betrayed her. And all throughout the issue everyone just kept running off on her, Poor D ]=
I'm a big fan of Dinah or Ollie peacing out and leaving for greener pastures. Either or. They're both bumouts.
Hal is a great hero, but he is no leader. He is only good at taking care of things himself, but I could see John Stewart running the team. As for the book its self it just felt like bunch kids trying to deal with their father passing away. Hal just wants to punch something, Canary tries to keep thing the way they were, while Superman and Wonder Woman reminisce and wish they had a chance to say goodbye.
mattydee007 said:
"are or aren't?I'm a big fan of Dinah or Ollie peacing out and leaving for greener pastures. Either or. They're both bumouts.
"
Hahah, G-Man your voices are getting better and better. Im just not gonna read a comic again and have you read them to me from now on. :)
well I am a hughe JLA fan but ever since McDuffle started writing this book I have not cared does anyone like him? no for real I wanna know from the vine
do you all think McDuffie is worth anything?
I think he should stick to cartoons and be FIRED for comics. his jokes suck and hes got a lot sex overtones in all his stuff. I think hes just some horny punk who makes the jla suck!
this issue was not that bad though I think that yeah the JLA HAS to be lead by the trinity and BC was not the best choice of leader but hey she didnt do that bad. Hal's proactive team is a good idea but didnt DC already do that whole proactive thing when the outsiders were lead by Nightwing and Roy?
do you all think McDuffie is worth anything?
I think he should stick to cartoons and be FIRED for comics. his jokes suck and hes got a lot sex overtones in all his stuff. I think hes just some horny punk who makes the jla suck!
this issue was not that bad though I think that yeah the JLA HAS to be lead by the trinity and BC was not the best choice of leader but hey she didnt do that bad. Hal's proactive team is a good idea but didnt DC already do that whole proactive thing when the outsiders were lead by Nightwing and Roy?
I give this issue 5 / 5... just for this one image...
Now that is how Hal should be written... standing up for his beliefs and willing to fix things that noone else on the league is willing to do...
that's the Hal i know and respect... now this half assed whipped version i'm reading in GL lately
M
Now that is how Hal should be written... standing up for his beliefs and willing to fix things that noone else on the league is willing to do...
that's the Hal i know and respect... now this half assed whipped version i'm reading in GL lately
M
Methos said:
"I give this issue 5 / 5... just for this one image...i would love if hal was more like this.
Now that is how Hal should be written... standing up for his beliefs and willing to fix things that noone else on the league is willing to do...that's the Hal i know and respect... now this half assed whipped version i'm reading in GL latelyM"
i think that piece o dialogue on roys part was really stupid.
i agree with ya G~man and i get where those guys are coming from i guess batmans death has really gotten to them
i agree with ya G~man and i get where those guys are coming from i guess batmans death has really gotten to them
|
Who Is Norman Osborn's Secret Weapon In Siege?
Will we soon find out who that mysterious shadowy person was?
|
|
|
'Psylocke' #1 of 4
Oh, heavens to Betsy!
|
|
|
The New Comic Vine (And Anime Vice) Office Tour
Here's a little look at our new work place.
|
|
|
Rob Liefeld Shares A Look At Lady Deadpool's Intro
Are you getting ready for all the coming Deadpools?
|
|
|
The New Avengers Have To Rescue Clint From The Dark Avengers
After Clint Barton went after Norman, things didn't end too well.
|
|
|
"V Is For Vendetta"
In celebration of Guy Fawkes Day and one of the greatest graphic novels of all time...
|
|
|
Dark Reign: The List - The Punisher Reviewed, Frank Falls To Pieces
If you've ever read the Punisher, you'll want to see what happens here.
|
|
|
Another Marvel SIEGE Teaser: Wolverine Vs Daken
Sometimes a father needs to step things up...
|
|
|
Who Is Norman Osborn's Secret Weapon In Siege?
Will we soon find out who that mysterious shadowy person was?
|
|
|
Rob Liefeld Shares A Look At Lady Deadpool's Intro
Are you getting ready for all the coming Deadpools?
|
|
|
The New Comic Vine (And Anime Vice) Office Tour
Here's a little look at our new work place.
|
|
|
The New Avengers Have To Rescue Clint From The Dark Avengers
After Clint Barton went after Norman, things didn't end too well.
|
|
|
'Psylocke' #1 of 4
Oh, heavens to Betsy!
|
|
|
Have You Seen The Wolfman Teaser Posters?
Will this be a new twist on the character or more of what we've seen many times?
|
|
|
Want To See The Wonder Twins On Smallville?
Here they are...
|
|
|
"V Is For Vendetta"
In celebration of Guy Fawkes Day and one of the greatest graphic novels of all time...
|
|
Comic Vine is Whiskey Powered with Django
on March 31, 2009