ComicVine News

Grab our RSS feed which is "after the jump" free

Added by G-Man on July 3, 2009



What can we say about Superman Returns?  It seems that most people were not crazy about it.  I've seen a lot of bashing of the movie.  I, too, had some issues.  I didn't like that Superman tried breaking up Lois' relationship, especially when for all he knew, Richard White was the father of the kid.  Speaking of the kid, why would they have Lois have a kid?  Also, we can't forget that Superman was basically a deadbeat dad. 

I wouldnt say it was a horrible movie.  There have been worse Superman films.  With these issues and the lackluster box office performance, a sequel was never pushed right away.  Moviehole posted a link to a link (or something like that) of an interview with Routh.  He mentions that The Dark Knight shows that a sequel could be bigger than the previous movie.  He thinks another Superman movie could be done better and improve upon Superman Returns.

Unfortunately for Routh, he may not have the chance to prove that idea.  Apparently his contract with Warner Bros. has expired.  He is no longer the Man Of Steel.  Currently, no one is.  If another movie were to be made, casting would have to take place once again.  Routh does say that he wouldn't "think twice" about taking the role again.  There's no word on if and when another Superman movie will be made.

Did you think Routh did a good job as Superman?  Would you want to see him again or a new actor?  What about Tom Welling?  Should a new Superman movie reboot things and get rid of the superbrat?  Will Superman ever get the respect he deserves?


Filed under : Lois Lane, Superman

90 Comments

iLLituracy
on July 3, 2009
They should reboot the Superman franchise, IMO. Sucks that WB didn't get to put out that next movie with Routh, Returns wasn't awful, there are just things that annoyed me about it--like the fact that Lois would do Superman in costume [kinda disgusting] and Superman leaving and whatnot, no real super-villain...mountain of Kryptonite...

Makes me mad all over again.

But, yes, they need a reboot.

G'bandit is online
on July 3, 2009
WROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONG!!!!

The dude is a great Superman! is not his fault Warner bros decided to break the cond-- never mind

I think the dude was great as Sups and would like to see him again as Sups just reboot it but leave the dude as Sups because I think he did great... Oh and the dialog, please no more crying "I'm still Superman!" Why would he cry that, really?

Luthor was also great in the movie and funny.



MoonKnightFan123
on July 3, 2009
oh no...

DorianOtten
on July 3, 2009
It'd probably be better to reboot. there was a fair bit wrong about returns, it was ok but .....etc. I have to admit though that i thought he did a decent job in the role  so i wouldn't mind them casting him again but they probably wouldn't to try and distance it from returns

Deo Wade
on July 3, 2009
He sucked as Superman....Mediocreman is what he was. Maybe that's just me not being able to get the image of Christopher Reeves as Superman out of my head, but the WB wrote a check that Routh couldn't cash. The Superman franchise needs a proper reboot in the worst way.

johnny spam is online
on July 3, 2009

If Brad Meltzer Mark Waid Grant Morrison where all interested in writing a Superman movie then the studios should listen http://splashpage.mtv.com/2008/08/11/how-to-reboot-the-superman-movie-franchise-comic-writers-chime-in/, as for Brandon Routh on one hand they already have a Superman actor they just need to resign him on the other he wasn't given the proper story to exhale at so who knows if he had a good story and couldn't sell it (no Tom Welling if the jerk is to scared of the costume and doesn't research Superman properly). I just hope it's settled soon I don't want to wait 20 years for another Superman like older fans did, If Marvel is giving all their heroes even the barely imagined heroes movies and other comic books are being sold as movies the minute they are printed then hopefully the biggest will get his due. What Superman movies really need is a producer who loves Superman just like the Batman films have Michael Uslan who is also a Comic book historian and is a huge Batman fan.


Fortified_Hooligan is online
on July 3, 2009
I don't think that Routh was the problem with this movie.

They need to put him in a moview where he has to freaking dodge some punches! No matter what the problem, just wait till superman shows up and he will fix it lickety split. Where's the suspense?

Let him get in a fight that you might ACTUALLY believe he could lose and things will turn around for this franchise.

also, they shot themselves in the foot with the superman kid. that has to go.

AngelFrost
on July 3, 2009
Nooo ):

Brandon is perfect for Routh!
The Superman Returns movie was aweful!
I hated Lois having his child ... it was just too far too soon without filing any of the blanks in.

But they should go a revamp and keep Brandon as Superman.

johnny spam is online
on July 3, 2009
They could keep the kid if he's revealed to be Superman Secundus when he gets older and starts the Superman Dynasty like in All Star Superman.

xerox-kitty
on July 3, 2009
He shouldn't compare it to the insane popularity of Dark Knight, since Batman Begins was a bloody good film to start with.  Superman Returns was nothing like Batman Begins, and certainly nowhere near as good!  

Fluke-buddha
on July 3, 2009
Lets face it he didn't have the stature for Superman, looked more like Superboy IMO. If they do another they need to amp up the villian.  Spacey was a great Lex, but Lex was about the easiest villian they could have done.

MadOmegaMan
on July 3, 2009
Why don't they just bring in Doomsday (Who is AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!) so they never have to make another supes movie again?

Nahero is online
on July 3, 2009
you maniac you messed it all up, darn you Brandon Routh darn you all to heck

Sidney
on July 3, 2009
Reboot! Get Henry Cravill as Superman.

elessar
on July 3, 2009
Reboot is a must for this franchise . Anyway the last movie was TERRIBLE,so so so so Terrible and I have to disagree with those of u that say Brandon was good ,,,because I didn't like him at all....he can't carry a leading a role ,especially someone so important as Superman , we need somebody more Prestigious for this Role .....enough said !!!

TheBug
on July 3, 2009

I would rather have Routh than Welling.


Nobody is online
on July 3, 2009
You know Superman Returns did suck, but I don't blame Routh for that. He did a decent job.

ARMIV
on July 3, 2009
Don't know who I'd like to see as Superman,but I did enjoy Kevin Spacey's Luthor...
It was Spacey right?
Want to be 100% on that.

Jamiracles
on July 3, 2009

Spacey did really well as Lex, but i'd like the next Superman movie to be without Lex.


Reaper 13
on July 3, 2009
Routh did a decent job as Sups and you can't blame him for a crappy plot.  Hell its as much Spacey's fault as it is Routh's.  The new Batman's would suck just as much if it had a poor script.


  • You must enter the following information to sign up and leave a comment.
  • Type the words above including the space. Get new words?
Errors will go here

Post Reply

Processing....
What? Someone's Saying "I Am A Secret Avenger"
I knew there couldn't just be one Avengers title.
No Surprise, Fox Plans Daredevil Reboot
It's either reboot or lose the franchise.
Logan Lerman 'Very Interested' In Upcoming Spidey Film
Move Over Zac Efron, Logan Lerman wants to wear spandex!
DC Entertainment To Make Big Announcement!
What are my best guesses? Well, you'll have to read to find out.
Another "I Am An Avenger" Promo: Hawkeye!
I have two words to say about this, "Woo" and "Hoo!"
Red Skull Will Be The Villain In The First Avenger: Captain America
This makes the most sense.
Another "I Am A Secret Avenger" Image
This one is definitely wearing a cape.
Thor Also Says, "I Am An Avenger"
Another team member revealed.
What? Someone's Saying "I Am A Secret Avenger"
I knew there couldn't just be one Avengers title.
No Surprise, Fox Plans Daredevil Reboot
It's either reboot or lose the franchise.
Red Skull Will Be The Villain In The First Avenger: Captain America
This makes the most sense.
Logan Lerman 'Very Interested' In Upcoming Spidey Film
Move Over Zac Efron, Logan Lerman wants to wear spandex!
Another "I Am A Secret Avenger" Image
This one is definitely wearing a cape.
There's Going To Be A Sacrifice In "Second Coming"
These poor mutants never get a break.
DC Entertainment To Make Big Announcement!
What are my best guesses? Well, you'll have to read to find out.
'Watchmen' Movie Part Deux? "Not A Chance!"
At least that's the rumor...