Methos
Methos's last update: And god said ∇ • D = ρf ∇ • B = 0 ∇ x E = - ∂B/∂t ∇ x H = Jf + ∂D/∂t and it was good...
If you notice any bugs, please give us a shout in the forums.

Summary About Me Blog Images Wiki Subs Reviews Forum Topics Lists Guides Trivia

Oct. 22, 2009
Methos replied to the topic The Doctor's Age.... in the The Doctor board. 6:13AM
@The Baron* said: " @Moomin123 said: " He's 903 years old. "0_o you know who Doctor Who is Right? "it's a fair comment...  the 9th Doctor said himself that he was only 903 years old just after Rose' mom slapped him...  Also, his name isn't Doctor Who... his name is The Doctor... Doctor Who is the name of the franchise and a play on the way everyone asks for his ...
Methos replied to the topic Windows 7 RC released 6:10AM
Ok, i received the full version of Windows 7 Ultimate in the post this morning... and after a complete format and installation, which actually took under HALF AN HOUR to fully install the ultimate version... weee.... i'm up and running...  So here are my thoughts on the full version of 7 Ultimate  Hits A slimmer OS The best part of Windows 7 is addition by subtraction. In other words, it’s not ...
Methos replied to the topic The Doctor's Age.... in the The Doctor board. 5:36AM
@Moomin123 said: " He's 903 years old. "He's way older than that...  The Doctor has changed his age so many times it's ridiculous... even i can't keep track any more because of the changing timelines and how he lives his life...  The sixth Doctor traveled for over 50 years during and after The Trial of a Time Lord. In Time and the Rani the seventh Doctor gives his age as ...
Methos replied to the topic First look at the new TARDIS... in the Tardis board. 5:32AM
Well, we've seen the new Doctor... and we've seen the new Companion... but it's been speculated for a long time that the TARDIS interior will be getting a make over as The Doctor regenerates...  So here it is, photos from the new set work... bare in mind these images are without the 3D FX layered on top to give the added dimensions lol   Looks like we're actually going to ...
Oct. 13, 2009
Methos replied to the topic Plagiarism 8:58PM
plagiarised from where?  M
Methos commented on Methos's Topic Pages that need some serious work... 8:47PM
Ok, as most of you will have already seen... the PLAGIARISM THREAD has been revived...  i'll be checking in daily to see what pages need work on them, and editing the first page of this thread accordingly...  please help out with whatever pages you can :D  M

Methos replied to the topic Plagiarism 8:39PM
Ok, time to bring back this thread...  let me put this clearly so there is no leyway whatsoever...  PLAGIARISM IS NOT ALLOWED ON THIS SITE  It's a firm golden rule... it's not allowed, it's not going to change... if you see it, notify us here and we'll get rid of it...  Now for he fun part, if you want to find yourself in the mods / staff golden graces... you can ...
Methos replied to the topic Rate the writing skills of RP'ers on the Vine! 8:33PM
take it nobody's seen the original Robocop movie then lol  M
Methos replied to the topic Podcast: Listen Weekly! 8:31PM
ok, i've waited nearly a week now for a decision...  so i'm bringing it back to the thread...  are we allowed to post podcasts in this forum as RedLAMP said, or not...  I posted one last week with an interview with J. T. Krull in it, quite a good interview as well, but it was swiftly deleted and i was told that the Podcast forum was only for staff / ...
Methos replied to the topic Rate the writing skills of RP'ers on the Vine! 8:20PM
@Hawk said: " I can buy that.... "for a dollar?  M
Methos replied to the topic New Black Lantern Corps Ring 8:01PM
hmm... another user coming over from the GLMB...  M
Methos replied to the topic Guy's rage... =(SPOILERS)= in the Guy Gardner board. 6:06PM
doubt it...  Geoff doesn't care enough about Kyle to do anything major with him... that's why he was shunted off to the Corps book so that Geoff didn't have to write him at all  M
Methos replied to the topic Guy's rage... =(SPOILERS)= in the Guy Gardner board. 5:59PM
Hal already switched to Blue... oh, and Red... oh yeah, he did Orange as well.... oh, don't forget Yellow...  damn, he's working his way through more colors than a pack of smarties lol  M
Methos replied to the topic A crash of EPIC proportions!!! 5:57PM
@"Colossus" said: " wait. so if its seeing what happened billion of years ago the those galaxy have merged long time ago "Yup... billions of years ago...  M
Methos replied to the topic Guy's rage... =(SPOILERS)= in the Guy Gardner board. 5:56PM
  Hey all, if you haven't seen this cover already, prepare to be blown away....    Yup, it's true... Guy will soon be rockin' the Red Lantern colors...   For those that have read the solicits for this issue, GLC-43, the quote is "A horrible loos for the Green Lantern Corps" I realize that you can only trust solicits so far, but "a horrible loss for the Green Lantern Corps" ...
Methos replied to the topic A crash of EPIC proportions!!! 5:43PM
well, we won't know for a very long time lol  M
Methos replied to the topic A crash of EPIC proportions!!! 5:38PM
that's down to Theology, not science... not really my area lol  though it can see things that happened billions of years in the past... i think that's cool enough, don't you? lol  M
Methos replied to the topic Immortality, Gift or Curse? in the Quickenings board. 5:35PM
i may take it... but i would definitely see it as a curse...  M
Methos replied to the topic A crash of EPIC proportions!!! 5:34PM
it's highly unlikely.... seriously unlikely...  remember that the nearest star is Alpha Centauri, located about 4.37 light years away, or 41.5 trillion km.. just try and think about those numbers / distances for a second lol  And we are in a pretty boring region of space... literally, there's nothing here... no nebulae, no black holes, quasars, anything... it's a pretty safe and boring place to be... so there's literally no ...
Methos replied to the topic A crash of EPIC proportions!!! 5:26PM
lol, welcome to relativity... it hurts, you're gonna love it :D  M
Added by Methos on Oct. 8, 2009

This is basically in response to a thread i've been reading in the Wolverine forums regarding his healing powers and how they actually work. I thought it'd be fun to actually reseach his healing factor and see if it would actually work with real world science... sort of bringing science back into comics :D
 
First off, I’d like to say a few things about Wolverine. This Marvel superhero is a well thought out character, with great powers and a great look. He’s savage, he’s mysterious, and is rough around the edges; he’s a loose cannon. Maybe that’s why everyone likes him so much. I however, feel seriously fed up with Wolverine. He’s become so popular that he makes appearances in almost every Marvel video game, television show, or toy line up. It’s kind of pissing me off now.

His mutant power; called his “healing factor,” allows him to rapidly counteract toxins, disease, and irritants. His body heals quickly from physical injury, and he is seldom afflicted by poisons. What a power to have! But what would have to happen on the cellular level for such healing abilities to occur?

Let us start with the physical injuries. Wolverine battles it out with Deadpool in an abandoned factory. As they exchange blows, Deadpool initiates a cunning attack forcing Wolverine to expose his chest. Deadpool seizes the opportunity to lunge his dagger between Wolverine’s ribcage. After withdrawing the dagger Deadpool ducks away in the shadows, assuming his enemy is incapacitated. Now this is where the healing factor kicks in. Within minutes, the wound is nowhere to be seen. It’s as though Wolverine was never stabbed in the first place. For this to occur, all of the surrounding cells would have to multiply at an alarming rate. Any organs, skin, or tissue severed would go into a state of hyper-mitosis. 
 
There would need to be a trigger in the body telling the cells to quickly make up for any loss of structure. It’s not like his cells are normally in a state of hyper-mitosis, or he would age way too rapidly. Aging is generally a process that takes place after many generations of mitosis. Wolverine would look 50 when he’s 15 if his cells were always in such a state. So these cells divide at extreme speeds when needed. Cell bodies travel through the cytoplasm at incredible rates, and DNA is read and copied without error at similar speeds. After all is said and done, Wolverine shows no sign of scarring, meaning that he heals differently than normal humans do. Scarring is a result of tissue overlap as the wound heals. Wolverine must have an internal mechanism that coordinates all cell structures to lay identical to the original layout of his body.

Let us move on to his immune system. Wolverine walks into a room, and sees a glass of wine on the table. A letter beside the glass says “drink me.” As Wolverine lifts the glass from the table, he inadvertently springs a trap that releases a vapour containing viral and bacterial organisms into the room. The organisms are lethal to humans in few numbers. Furthermore, the wine glass contained a poison strong enough to kill Sasquatch. After a few minutes of torturous pain coming from his lungs and stomach, Wolverine slashes the door with his claws; freeing him of the death trap. Another minute is all he needs for the pain to subside. His body has completely fought off both the poison and the infectious disease. How did he do this?

Poisons are varied from those that simply eat away at bio-matter, to those that shut down integral cellular functions; forcing the cell to become incapacitated. Toxins are similar in its destruction. It is possible to explain the healing process with the hyper-mitosis theory, where the cells just keep dividing until the entire toxin or poison is used up. Once there is no more poison or antigen, the body can return to its normal state. But what will become of the viruses or bacteria? Such organisms multiply endlessly until expunged by the immune system. 
 
A normal humans immune system takes anywhere from 5 days to weeks when responding to foreign bodies. By the time the immune system recognizes the foreign body and makes the proper antibodies, the person can be in serious trouble. Wolverine’s immune system would not only need to recognize foreign bodies really quickly, but it would need to replicate the proper amount of antibodies almost instantaneously. Such antibodies would also need to circulate through the body at an incredible rate. So does Wolverine have some kind of speed-up mechanism throughout his body? Does the Flash from DC comics have the same ability?

Lastly, his aging. Aging is often due to errors in DNA replication, causing wrinkles, liver spots, disease, and lack of pigment. But it is almost as if there is an internal countdown in our cells. DNA has a tail end with many added proteins (aka Guanine, Tyrosine, Adenine, Cytosine) that do absolutely nothing; however each time a cell replicates, one of those proteins is lost. This means that eventually (after so much replication) the cells will stop cutting out useless proteins that don't code for anything, and will begin to cut out useful proteins that are important to our genetic makeup. 
 
Remember what I said about Logan's aging? I mentioned that he would look 50 when he was 15, because his cells divide much more rapidly than that of a normal human's cells. But in order for Wolverine's age to be slowed to a crawl (because I think he does still age, if only at a fraction of the rate of everyone else. Mainly because if he didn’t age at some level, then he would still be at the age he was when his healing factor first kicked in), he must have some kind of internal mechanism that either replenishes those proteins at the tail of the DNA strand, or he has way more unused proteins than the average man.
 
Well, this blog was mostly dedicated to trying to make Wolvey’s powers of healing plausible, rather than seeing if it could actually be possible in the real world. Though the perspective was off, it still pretty much proves that a “healing factor” is not currently explainable with real world science. Sorry Logan.
 
M
 


Related to: Wolverine


Added by Methos on July 20, 2009

In Brightest Day, In Blackest Night...

Here is the review... Green Lantern: First Flight!!!


Ok, cheesy opening line out of the way, on to the real meat...

We have a truly amazing movie here ladies and gentlemen, one that actually stays true to the original comic, with a few bits borrowed from retcons here and there, but in all honesty, if the current Green Lantern run was written like this, then Green Lantern would take over Superman and Batman for the lead in DC comics.

Chris Meloni has done an outstanding job here as Hal Jordan... For those of you who read my review of "Final Frontier", you'll know that i loved David Boreanaz as Hal, but Chris absolutely shatteres that, in all honesty, i'll be hearing Chris Meloni as Hal in the future now, he's the only voice i can actually picture properly.

The writing was awesome, we have OA, the Guardians of the Universe, the entire Green Lantern Corps and quite a few familier faces and 'tip of the hat' moments to prior Green Lantern stories...

Ok, time for the obligatory nitpicking part of the review...

So OA wasn't exactly like it was in the comics, neither was Abin Sur or the Centeral Power Battery... but truth be told, these changes don't actually stand out until you actually take a close look at them, and when you're watching the movie, you don't even realise that they have been altered.

The Plot


You did good Poozer
You did good Poozer
Ok, the plot was good... it's basically meshing Emerald Dawn together with a bit of the Sinestro Corps origins... though thankfully there isn't a Geoffcon in sight... literally... the Centeral Power Battery, Hal Jordan, Sinestro... all of the characters are how they were written prior to Rebirth... this literally goes back to Silver Age Green Lantern and takes it's run from there...

There are no "Will Whales" or "Fear Bugs", not a hint towards anything remotely connected to the Emotional Spectrum... in fact, the only thing in the entire movie that actually had even a remote link to Geoff Johns was Sinestro's costume and logo... that's it... praise the lord!!!

So we start out with Abin Sur crashing to earth, literally taking a page from Emerald Dawn, or Secret Origins... Handing the ring over to Hal, insert amazingly cool transformation sequence here, and then it's time to start training... with Sinestro as his Master...

To be honest, i wasn't sure what to expect from First Flight... not only was it an Origin story, but it tried to mash together other storylines as well, like the betrayel of Sinestro and the origins of the Sinestro Corps... but in all honesty, it was amazingly well written and acted out, the plot line was solid and the acting was well above par for an Animated Feature.

The Corps


Ok, where to start here...

We have Kilowog, Hal Jordan, Sinestro, C'hip, Arisia, Bodikka, Ganthet, Abin Sur, Tomar Ra, The Green Man... hell, if i listed all the Corps members that i recognised in the movie then i'd be here all day, and that alone should tell you that this movie is not only sticking faithfully to the comics, but the artists and writers actually took some time to look into the comics and use existing and well loved characters.

The Guardians were perfect, hell, they were just as i'd imagined them prior to Rebirth... imperfect, stuck in their ways, arrogant and aloof... the voicing was perfect for them and they were drawn literally as if they had floated out of the comics onto the screen.

The Art


Ok, this is the only part where i feel the movie was let down... it wasn't bad by any stretch of the imagination... it just felt a bit off in places, like it was trying to bridge the gap between American cartoon style and Japanese anime... you could even look in some frames and swear that it was a frame ripped straight out of Dragon Ball Z, especially prominant when Hal sticks his hand into the Centeral Power Battery.

Overall the art has to be given a solid 7/10, it was good, but just let down in some places... as i said, it just felt a bit off while keeping with a style that fit the storyline.

Overall


A solid 9/10

A damn good movie that really felt like we had gone back to Hal Jordan's glory days prior to Rebirth... the entire Corps were there, along with some guest mentions of Weaponers and Qward, a slight retcon there to the original but nothing major... the storyline was engrossing and flawlessly pulled off, and the acting was damn near perfect for the story.

9/10, a little room for improvement, but just shy of damn near perfect.

M


Added by Methos on June 25, 2009


Not only did he succeed in taking over the world, but he actually heald it for over a year before anyone opposed him...

M


Added by Methos on June 17, 2009

All hell breaks loose at Washington's Smithsonian Institute in this follow-up to the family-friendly smash starring Ben Stiller. Also featuring Ricky Gervais, Robin Williams and Owen Wilson

Ex-museum guard Larry (Stiller) is now a successful inventor, The film opens with a tacky infomercial plugging a new invention. One of the now very well off Larry Daley, and the ever crazy George Foreman. Larry has made it big and is about to make it bigger due to Walmart being interested in his inventions.

We come to realize that even though Larry looks like he has moved on with his new spot as CEO, he hasn’t. His monthly trips back to the museum prove to be a side of him he can’t let go of. This is where the story takes form and really starts to grow on you.but misses his friends among the exhibits at the Museum Of Natural History. When they’re shipped to the Smithsonian, he must follow before all hell breaks loose, which of course it does. The plot's not all too dissimilar from the original but does however benefit from having a tangible villain in the form of evil Egyptian pharaoh Kamunrah (Hank Azaria), which puts it a step above its predecessor, but you won't be paying your money for the story in this case, the jokes are the main attraction and you may feel slightly disappointed.

Looking at face value, this should be one of the funniest films ever made considering the pedigree. The sheer amount of comedy actors all in the cooking pot is astonishing. Add Zoolander to Drillbit Taylor with a dash of Mrs.Doubtfire, Andy Millman, Tom Saxondale and it certainly you should make for a delicious comedic soufflé but instead of the tasty treat you all see in the shop window, what’s left is just a plain ordinary ham sandwich with a little bit of filling.

However, there is filling to be had here *cough* entertainment to be had here. The jokes come quick and in their groups, there's some actually quite good historical gags like taking pops at Napoleon and if The Pink Panther 2 proved anything, the French accent is till funny. The Heat/Grazia oriented among you may also enjoy cameo spotting in the film as there are a huge amount of blink and you'll miss another comedic star moments and repeated viewing would defiantly be warranted to see them all.

Although the kicker comes in the variety of the jokes and the pedigree of them, the all important seasoning on the ham sandwich of a prior metaphor and in the end it doesn't supply what you came to see. Sure, you will most defiantly chuckle throughout but the sheer amount of fart jokes and slapstick humour gets a little noticeable, it keep schizophrenically switching between supplying the Basil brush humour for the kids and then expecting them to know them know about General Custer.

All in all, if you have a particular soft spot for your celebrities, can't get enough of the natural history channel or simply love an old fashioned burp gag, there will be something there for you and you will be hard pressed to find something you don't enjoy in the film. Stiller, Adams, Williams and the encore cast put in a performance much better than in the first film. The acting is better, the jokes are better, the plot, the stage, the sites, the sounds…all better. As my interview with writer Robert Ben Garant pointed out, it needed to be better, Rob had said “Ben Stiller is the boss, and he said make it funnier, so we did our best”. Well they did just that. The action, the sequences between Azaria and Stiller, the exchanges between Adams and Stiller were all great.

Night at the Museum 2 or Night at the Museum: Battle for the Smithsonian, is nothing but true fun. If you enjoyed the first film, you will enjoy this one even more! Personally, all through the movie i couldn't take my eyes of Amy Adams as Angie Everheart... A simply amazing role and a stunningly beautiful actress to boot.

9/10 for this one

I highly reccomend giving this movie a run, you'll love it :D

M


Added by Methos on June 16, 2009

The Future Begins... Again


J.J. Abrams knows how to stir up controversy, doesn’t he? Every single aspect of the latest film in the Star Trek franchise has been picked apart by die-hard Trekkies the world over. A snapshot of the new USS Enterprise NCC-1701 released? “Oh, the nacelles are all wrong and the deflector is awful!” The first trailer with skydiving and classic cars gets shown? “They’re turning it into a summer popcorn flick!”

Well, now that new Enterprise is out of Spacedock and showing alongside all that skydiving and driving and flashbang. The media hype almost ensures a generous box office return for Star Trek so the question of success isn’t really on the cards... no, what has everybody worried is the future of the franchise. What J.J. Abrams is really responsible for is the message and spirit of Gene Roddenberry’s original show, for his characters and their journeys to the final frontier. Can a reboot really do this? Can casting new actors and starting a new timeline really work? Can it be critically successful with the fans?

I can’t speak for the entire fandom, but I can speak for me. I’ve been following Star Trek since before I can remember. I grew up watching Jean-Luc Picard make moral speeches to defend the social issues of the day. I’m sad enough to write my own Star Trek stories and what-have-you, buy all the DVDs, etc. So, to be blunt, has J.J. Abrams pleased me? Has his new film still made me proud to stand up and be counted a Trekkie?

My answer is yes... but it isn’t emphatic.

The phrase that seems almost overused in the film is “alternate universe”. When a certain cameo performance begins at the halfway point, it works overtime to deliver the message that the events of Star Trek are separated from the events of the previously-established universe: rightly so, as one film cannot hope to compete against ten films, five television shows and a whole plethora of novels, games and comics. While this message does feel like a grudging addition on the part of the script, in order to satisfy the continuity of the Star Trek universe overall, it allows one to relax. It makes you shift focus: with the exception of one important character (who crosses over to deliver the “alternate universe” news) this is just as the publicity has been yelling for months: this is not your father’s Star Trek. This is a Star Trek caused by a chain reaction instigated by the film’s villain, Nero. He’s a Romulan, played by Eric Bana with plenty of sneering and hissing and screaming. He’s no Khan or Borg Queen, but he’s no pathetic weakling either. He does the job. Not only does he get plenty of mileage out of the aforementioned sneering and hissing and screaming, he causes some pretty big shockwaves in this new universe. Naturally, that’s thanks to his specially patented Science Fiction Plot Device Superweapon. This time it carries the brand label “red matter” and has some pretty explosive results.

But the franchise is safe. Nero can do what he likes with “red matter”. This is a new beginning that doesn’t give the original series a long golden shower. With that panic over for the fandom, and that panic over for myself, I was free to settle down and enjoy what is simply another interpretation of Gene Roddenberry’s classic cult series. This being a 21st Century summer, however, and this being a major blockbuster motion picture, it has to have extremely large scope. This, apparently, means it has to have “lots of action sequences”, and so the trailers weren’t lying. There’s orbital skydiving. There’s a shootout on the Romulan mining vessel Narada. There’s an apocalyptic finale.

There’s also the much-publicised fate of the USS Kelvin NCC-0514. This is what opens the film. In the space of ten minutes, much like a James Bond pre-title sequence, it tells a little story of its own that later provides some backstory to the central plot. What surprises is the raw emotion of the moment. Without wanting to give too much away, it doesn’t just tug at the heartstrings... it grabs them and pulls them like a set of church bells. Before long, though, we’re thrown forward across several jumps in time: suddenly Kirk is a child behind the wheel of that red convertible, and then he’s a barfly trying to seduce Cadet Uhura, and then he’s a cadet himself. The pace is quick, no doubts there.

What of the characters that inhabit this fast-paced world? Is James Tiberius Kirk still James Tiberius Kirk, or does Chris Pine simply prove it was all tied up in William Shatner’s unique method of delivery? Opinion will probably be divided. I, however, thought he did well. One particularly good scene was finally getting to see the infamous cheat on the Kobayashi Maru test. Everything’s done with such a cocky edge that you cannot help but laugh. The image of the man, draped in the simulator’s centre seat, eating an apple as Klingons attack is somehow just as you’ve always imagined it (despite absence of Shatner). Indeed, as the film progresses and we’re introduced to more and more of the classic characters, you realise that J.J. Abrams has mostly hit the mark: Leonard McCoy (Karl Urban), Montgomery Scott (Simon Pegg) and Hikaru Sulu (John Cho) are all refreshed with great energy and skill. The slight twinge of regret, the fan inside of me missing DeForest Kelley and James Doohan, is quickly swamped with clever dialogue and great presentation. Christopher Pike (the ever-reliable Bruce Greenwood) is also re-energised quite well, so well in fact that you’re left not caring about the lingering question of “whatever happened to Robert April?”

The biggest surprise: Karl Urban as Leonard McCoy. He's amazing... a true scene stealer, the lines are delivered perfectly and his screen presence is unmistakable.

The biggest letdown: Zoe Saldana as Uhura. She’s not terrible, but she’s not good either.

Her involvement with Kirk’s story arc is a relatively minor, jokey one. The same cannot be said for Spock. Played with accuracy and skill by Zachary Quinto, his struggle between his human and Vulcan ancestry is arguably the most important aspect of Star Trek’s story. It does come across at times, however, to be the sole lynchpin of the script’s efforts. In trying to capture the internal conflict of Spock, the film discovers some great lines and great moments but perhaps to the detriment of the other plot elements. Nero, for example, lacks that special villain magic because he’s underdeveloped and given little actual screentime. Overall, too, the Spock character arc isn’t something we haven’t seen before. I guess, as a reintroduction to these classic characters, it sets up the final scenes (which are begging, as expected, for a sequel or possibly new franchise launch). I think, however, I’d have done it a little differently and weighted the various strands somewhat more balanced.

The only other character left to mention, I guess, is the USS Enterprise NCC-1701. Yes, she’s a character in her own right. Just ask the legions of Trekkies who admit to getting all misty-eyed at her death in Star Trek III: The Search for Spock. It has to be said, I was never a huge supporter of the redesign. It looked a little strange, the nacelles overweighted and the deflector dish that sticks out like a crooked tooth... but having seen her in motion, seen her presented by the wizards at ILM, seen her from various angles during her launch sequence, yes: I’ll hold my hands up. I was wrong. She’s beautiful. There are several shots that just take your breath away. Seriously, watch as she emerges from Saturn’s gas surface towards the conclusion of the picture. If your jaw doesn’t drop, you’re not human.

Ah, what it means to be human... Gene Roddenberry often sought to answer that question through his series, didn’t he? Both on television and on the big screen, Star Trek was always three important things. It was an action/adventure. Does the new film have that? Check, absolutely check. It was also an optimistic vision of the future. It gave hope in the face of dystopian science fiction and showed a version of humanity bound together in common cause. Does the new film have that? Well, the Federation’s still there. Starfleet’s still there, putting the best and brightest on starships, equal opportunities for all... so check, yes, it is an optimistic vision of the future. Now, what of the third important criteria? What of the intelligent weight, what of the social commentary? What of the big questions being asked, what of the exploration of humanity? Does the new film have that?

Unfortunately, it has very little. It seems to be buried in Spock’s storyline. Again, this is a case of the film’s flaw: it throws everything onto the shoulders of a few, despite also unquestionably being an ensemble piece. This caused me to do some serious head-scratching on my way home. Is J.J. Abrams’ Star Trek also Gene Roddenberry’s Star Trek? Can I, like Jean-Luc Picard in “The Measure of a Man” (TNG), stand here and bellow “you see, the film’s met two of your three criteria, so what if it meets the third?”

After just one viewing, I’m still not entirely sure. That said, the intentions of this film are entirely noble. Regardless of your opinions towards the publicity campaign, a campaign filled with punches and overdriven guitars, this is certainly something I don’t have any serious objection to carrying the Star Trek title. If the “alternate universe” aspect of the plot was completely ignored, I might have more serious problems. As it stands, however, what we’ve been given here is simply another branch of an ever-expanding franchise. With strong box office returns, a couple more films from J.J. Abrams will explore to see where this branch leads. The beauty of it is that it doesn’t stop other branches from growing. All it has done is taken the franchise tree and given it a quick shake. Okay, so some of the jokes are a little weak and some of the twists and turns will make you frown, but on reflection?

This ain’t half bad. It ain’t half bad at all.


Final Score
Eight out of Ten

Filled with all the right lines pointing you in the right directions, there’s no denying that J.J. Abrams is paying respect to the essence of James T. Kirk, Spock and Leonard McCoy. Whether he shows the same respect to Gene Roddenberry’s ideals and human message is a question perhaps left to the inevitable sequel. For now, this just lays groundwork. Don’t worry, though: it’s groundwork with serious potential.
Related to: McCoy, Uhura, Spock, Captain Kirk


Methos's Reviews
Reviewed by Methos
Sept. 23, 2007

I can only say one thing about this issue... ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!!

Tommy Monaghan makes a triumphant return in this issue, set before his untimely death at the end of Hitman it's a breath of fresh air for the DCU.

Firstly a warning, read the Hitman series first or most of the jokes will be lost on you, such as the previous Hitman / Green Lantern team up or the hilarious issue with Hitman throwing up on Batman... or the issue which should have won an award for the best portrayal of Superman where Hitman managed to convince Superman that he was doing the right thing, and there was still good in the world.

This issue was a nice change from the JLA at the moment, going back to when Kyle was still in his old uniform as Green Lantern. It's riddled with the usual humor normally found in Hitman with cameo's from all the regulars from Noonan's bar.

Overall, if you you're a fan of Hitman, or just looking for some hilarious reading at the JLA's expense pick up this book :D

M



Reviewed by Methos
May 19, 2007

ok... for the past few issues we have been treated to the storyline about the crystals in Kara Zor-El, and the fact that she is 'supposed' to kill Superman.

now everything has finally been tipped on it's head, but i'm getting ahead of myself.

this issue actually felt right for once, the artwork and script actually fit together, which is something that has been sadly lacking from the Supergirl series so far. is all i finally felt some 'hope' for the series at last.

The artwork done by Garza, Alquiza and Lanning actually really worked for the storyline, their renditions of Kara, Cassie and Robin actually felt right, though the rensition of Superman felt a little too 'Dark Knight Returns' for my taste, but again, it fit in with the story.

The Martian Manhunter is one of the others that has had a 'redesign' in this issue, i've never been the niggest fan of the character, but the look given to him here actually looked more 'alien' than before and gave a bit more mystery to the character.

overall i was left a little confused over the storyline again, the earths sun going red while the phantasms are coming through and Robin claiming over and over to be Batman's Son.

the end of the storyline is getting darker and darker, with Kara explaining to Kal that her only choice to save Earth is to kill him, and he accepts this. he accepts his death with the simple words...

"Do it... and please tell lois... we had no choice"

at this point we are shown yet another Supergirl... something the writers have had a penchant for for some time now...

now we're left with the questions who is this new supergirl? who is out supergirl?

the new supergirl looks more like the Kara Zor-El of old, and i for one am hoping that she will stay around... but another part of me is saying this will be the return of Linda Danvers...

so many question's and so few answers...

all in all a nice read and a fitting close to the storyline, i'm hoping this will be closed up soon so we can head on to brighter and better things for the Supergirl series, but if not i can hope and prey that this is Kara Zor-El returning at last to remove the pretender.



Reviewed by Methos
May 10, 2007

at first i was a bit aprehensive about the comic, the books are amazing and i didn't see how the comics would be able to live up to them.

putting that thought aside i stepped in...

first impressions of the artwork... ok, i try and play it cool but my jaw hit the floor... the artwork isn't subtle by any standard, but it's absolutely perfect for the story they are telling.

the script was taken pretty much word for word out of the first book (Currently they are on book 14 with more to come), it was just as funny/sad/scary as the book.

the characters are drawn pretty much as i imagined them, right down to Anita's penguin collection ;)

all in all this series kept me entertained for ages, if they keep making it (Please, please please...) i will defninitely keep reading it, at least up untill they do Obsidian Butterfly... after that it will kinda turn into Hentai lol

seriously though, if you haven't read the comic, even if you haven't read the books, pick up an issue, read it. i can pretty much promise you'll love it.

M



Reviewed by Methos
April 6, 2007

Overall I was quite impressed with this run of Supergirl, this new issue however didn't seem to live up to the beginning of her 'reign'.

The artwork was ok; to be honest I don't think it works well for Supergirl. Alé Garza is a good artist, don't get me wrong but I don't feel that his artworks works well for the story or for the characters involved in this plotline.

As for this new plotline involving 'Phantom Zoner's'... I’m not too sure what to think about it at the moment, on the one hand is has stopped the 'powerboy' nonsense that had been going on; I’m just not too sure where they are heading with this. They seem to be rewriting a part of the history of superman with Kara's parents, hoping to bring some more 'action' into the book. I think this could be better accomplished by bring the Supergirl character into the limelight a bit more.

Again, the one thing that I keep coming back to when I think about this issue is the artwork. Admittedly Michael Turner is a hard act to follow after his run on the introduction and the first few issues but Alé Garza's art is just lacking something for the character in my eyes. Supergirl in his artwork seems more childlike, a more innocent naive Kara. Now while I’m not against bringing this side of Supergirl out into the open, I don't think that it is right for the storyline at present with the end of the issue telling Kara that she must kill Superman.

Overall I’ll keep reading Supergirl, but out of this run I will rank this issue quite low down on the scale.

Just rereading the issue now I was left with more questions than answers... The phantom zone is supposed to be a dimension away from our own, where nothing can affect anything in this dimension. if this is true and that Jor-El created the 'Zone' to house criminals, I’m not too sure that he would have knowingly used it to house the Super criminals which Superman met later on in his life.

Another thing I did have a slight problem with, this is really minor but it niggled at my brain through the entire read. Superman's father was Jor-El, and so Superman, his son was named Kal-El. different 'first name', same surname. Now in this issue, Supergirl's father was named as Zor-El, Jor-El's brother. So why is Supergirl named as Kara Zor-El, following what I can of Kryptonion names shouldn't it just be Kara-El?

Anyway, that aside the plotline was reasonably well done. I still had a few niggling doubts about the story surrounding the Sunstones and 'ghosts' that came out of the phantom zone to possess people.

So, if you’re a diehard Supergirl fan like me pick it up if only for your collection. If you’re just looking to get into the books and the Supergirl mythology I recommend going back and starting at the beginning of this run. It’ll probably leave you with a better taste for the character than the last few issues have.

M





Date Joined: March 19, 2007
City:
Gender: Male
Alignment: Good
Points: 53,471 Points
Ranked: Ranked #32 of 51,064
53,471 points you are ranked
32 of 51,064 users

Guy Gardner
character - 9,082 points
The Doctor
character - 6,876 points
Faith
character - 6,006 points
Kyle Rayner
character - 5,136 points
Black Canary
character - 3,063 points
Green Lantern Corps
team - 2,921 points
Wonder Woman
character - 2,806 points
Methos
character - 2,410 points

Your Favorites List
a list of 38 items by Methos
Your Pull List
a list of 16 items by Methos
Ferro Vida 19 hours, 17 minutes ago
Ferro Vida ran alongside the Olympic torch
aztek the lost 1 day, 4 hours ago
is currently on forced vacation...*sighs*...only 9 more months and I will be free!
Red L.A.M.P. 1 day, 4 hours ago
Red L.A.M.P. is listen to the ComicVine Podcast cause it's FUNNY!
Platinumwarrior 2 days, 2 hours ago
Last name Ever first name Greatest.
xerox-kitty 2 days, 6 hours ago
needs to get 365 Samurai And A Few Bowls Of Rice
DeadPool a.k.a Wade Wilson 3 days, 7 hours ago
I'm Used To Having A Crowd Up There
Shadow Huntress 3 days, 14 hours ago
Shadow Huntress is really sick. And super tired.
The Hunter 3 days, 21 hours ago
invented BAD-ASS-ANTIUM!