Buckshot
Buckshot's last update: Buckshot is having a Wildstorm Workday
If you notice any bugs, please give us a shout in the forums.

Summary About Me Blog Images Wiki Subs Reviews Forum Topics Lists Guides Trivia
Buckshot's Reviews
Your Review Stats
Total Reviews Written 3 Reviews Your Average Review Score
Community Votes 0 out of 1 users recommended your reviews Total Comments On Your Reviews 1 Comments
Reviewed by Buckshot
July 25, 2008
That was incredible. I don't know what I was expecting, but I got so much more. The biggest thing was the explanation. It was all explained here. Not just what's going on with this miniseries, not just what happened to Jack that made him what he is, but almost a whole universe based around what Jack is, was revealed in this issue. I can't really explain it without messing it up or just not saying everything. You should read it to find out. It's great though. More than I could ever have imagined. (I realize I'm really gushing and I was about to say maybe I'm biased because I like Jack, but no, I refuse to qualify my statements. It's really good.) Anyway, as for how they did it (not what it was, but how they revealed it) they really played with my emotions. I didn't know it would all be explained but then they started to do it and I got excited, but then it looked like they weren't going to explain it and I felt teased, cheated and a little angry. But THEN they changed it so how they presented it was even better than it would have been before. Those 3 panels were a roller coaster ride and that's before the good stuff even started. Then they did the whole explanation thing and that was great if I haven't said that enough. That wasn't all that happened, it's just the part I liked the best. The rest of the issue was great stuff too. There were a couple twists in there, one of which was about the character Sal. I saw that one coming from when he first showed up and I felt rewarded for that, but it was still dramatic and its own little moment when it came. There was another twist which I thought was great since I love triple-crosses. (I think it may actually have been a quadruple-cross, might have lost track.) Between this issue and the previous one (and a little from the one before that I guess) I've really started to like one of the bad guys. He's not just some lame villain, he's got a personality that really added to his character, but I think everyone did so no big surprise there. I just love the way this is written. And illustrated. It's been good the whole way through (a little different from normal stuff, but it worked in this book) but I thought the art was especially good in this issue when it switched to the explanation of Jack and his whole deal. The ending was also well done. Without getting into specifics, Jack cleaned things up so the last issue can be dedicated to the real problem, the man behind the curtain, the guy pulling the strings, without stupid distractions. And the entrance of the final boss? Also great. The location is familiar, got a couple ideas on what that could mean, but I'll wait and see. There's a big middle chunk that I didn't really talk about, but I want to read that again.

So, all in all, great. The origin that's here (built off SHotA: Jenny Sparks) is not quite the same as Ellis' original idea. Ellis had aliens do it and SHotA:JS made it future humans. Not really a big deal to me (future humans could be a lot like aliens), but some people care. In a Hawksmoor short that came after SHotA:JS, Ellis kind of addressed that and gave his opinion on the change (he made it aliens again). This story doesn't work without the future humans though so I'm glad that idea is what is being used. The future and the gods of cities were just great concepts. I'm interested to see how much the stuff in this series gets used in future books.


Reviewed by Buckshot
June 27, 2007

Gage's Midnighter isn't the walking slaughterhouse (at first) that we've come to know and love, but that's not a bad thing. I loved the way everything went. Even when Midnighter is being shown in a different light, he retains all the dark humor and ultraviolence that he's known for. When Jack Hawksmoor sends Midnighter to get in touch with his human side and act like a normal hero for once, he gives it a genuine effort, but the world he lives in takes over and a simple errand turns into a fight against cyborgs and a mad scientist with drops of We 3 thrown in for good measure. Even adopting a pet like a normal person is done in the most bizarre way possible. The writing, both the dialog and the plot itself, were excellent. The art was a little weird but I didn't mind. I like the self-contained stories that have been in this series and I think this one is the best so far.



Reviewed by Buckshot
May 7, 2007

No, it's not stapled wrong. Thats what I thought when I first got Midnighter #7. I opened it up and I'm greeted with "The End." I read a few more pages and figured out what was going on. I had to really stop and think, do I want to read backwards like they wanted me to, or should I read it in order? I chickened out and flipped to the end. At the end/beginning I read, "Hi, I'm Midnighter. I already know exactly how this story ends." With that I was forced to go back to the beginning and read it from finish to start. It was a little bit of a challenge, mostly because even though it's backwards, you still read down. It felt more like I was reading it out of order than just reading it backwards; reversing the order of the panels on the page would have helped, but whatever, I got through it and got what they were trying to do. The layout and transitions even got better at the end, probably because there was more dialogue there so it was necessary to make it so it could be read easily both ways.

The story wasn't great. In fact, without the reverse-order thing, this is probably the worst story I've ever read. An antagonist so simple that not only can her entire scheme be summed up in two word balloons, but she doesn't even get a name. That's perfectly okay though, because it's not about the story. It's all about the gimmick. The purpose of this issue is to explain Midnighter's powers, his ability to predict what his opponent is going to do. I think that's done very well. He sees all the possible outcomes, picks the one he wants, then works backwards to get there from where he is now. It was interesting being along for the ride as the process happened. It was almost like "A Day in the Mind of Midnighter," but this was only one of the many possible scenarios. I think I might start reading more stories backwards.

Or maybe not.