My personal choice is Punisher because he is more constructive and honorable. 

Man, this is not a choice since it appeals to personal taste. You like the Punisher for that, I like Deadpool because while the laughs he creates are funny, they are a mental barrier to hide a truly shattered individual. The guy hears voices for chrissakes, he was tortured in ways that the word pain cannot describe, he is actually cursed with life. I find a flawed action hero in Deadpool, and that's why I like him .

Punisher

Deadpool

Deadpool. No need to be serious all the time.

Punisher

Both

deadpool 
he is effective and his banter is excellent 

Deadpool

deadpool for me , punisher is cool but i love deadpool especially the older stuff

" My personal choice is Punisher because he is more constructive and honorable.  "

Punisher is a serial killer, point and simple.
 
That said I find Punisher more interesting as a character then Deadpool.

deadpool. he breaks the fourth wall and is an overall cooler looking character. also i bet deadpool could murder the punisher in a fight

" @Violet-Eyed Dragon said:

" My personal choice is Punisher because he is more constructive and honorable.  "

you call cutting a woman's, arms and legs off honorable? and how is what he does Constructive, he is no better than the people he kills. "

" Punisher is a serial killer, point and simple.  That said I find Punisher more interesting as a character then Deadpool. "

" deadpool. he breaks the fourth wall and is an overall cooler looking character. also i bet deadpool could murder the punisher in a fight "

Deadpool could be written brilliantly but it hasnt been as of late, so his character has been stinking. So i pick Punisher, but if a good writer ever makes Deadpool cool again, i pick Deadpool.

" @Violet-Eyed Dragon: never said Deadpool was a nice guy, and yes he is a worse person than Punisher. But Punisher is not honorable, nor heroic, he is a sick and twisted serial killer psycho just like deadpool, neither are heros. "

Old school Deadpool for the win.

I don't know about the Punisher really. All I know is Megadeth done a song about him and a few other things. But if what ya'll are sayin' is true (about cutting people up and stuff) -- then he's no better than Deadpool. Deadpool just kills and leaves. Leaving the people to die with dignity instead of chopping their limbs off, exposed to those who find it.

" @Caligula: Obviously you know nothing of Frank.  Frank kills not for himself but for others. He's a man devoted to the eradication of the thing that leeches society. Now you tell me, what is more honerable?  Killing for the safety of others?  Or killing whoever as long as you get rich?  And plus, Frank doesn't do it for pay, for his enjoyment, for anything. Frank does it because no one else would. "

" I don't know about the Punisher really. All I know is Megadeth done a song about him and a few other things. But if what ya'll are sayin' is true (about cutting people up and stuff) -- then he's no better than Deadpool. Deadpool just kills and leaves. Leaving the people to die with dignity instead of chopping their limbs off, exposed to those who find it. "

I like both but in different ways but choosing one over the other can't happen .

" @Violet-Eyed Dragon: That's a Skrull. They're not exactly classed as human beings. I know Deadpool as much as the next guy, hell, even more... Deadpool's better in the sense that he's trying to make a livin' from it. He has a reason to it. Punisher just seems to do it for funsies. He can stop at anytime. "