@jnr6lil: hey i think you might have a few issues and i'm really starting to worry about you. Remember when i said Oracle might indeed be a relatable character. Do you remember when i said i imagine dcs characters are probably more relatable now? I never said being in a wheelchair was a cause and you seem so furious that someone might offend your favorite make-believe characters that i think its messing up you cognitive reasoning. How can i simplify what i'm saying for a fifth grade level? Let me see...
Ok. What defines Batman in your mind? Is it that he is a kid who's parents were murdered? Or...is it how he dealt with that? Answer...? What defines batman is how he dealt with the murder of his parents.
Oracle. What defines Oracle? Is it her being in a wheelchair, as you seem to think, or is it how she deals with being in a wheelchair? Answer? And you better get this one right because people in wheelchairs hate being defined by their disability. Answer? Its how she deals with being in a wheelchair.
I'm doubting even this will be clear to you so let's see if i can make it even simpler.
Let's say Oracle is in a wheelchair, but in writing Oracle the writer writes her as someone who doesn't care about being in a wheelchair and just says her legs were crap anyway and she's happy they don't work. Now not only would this be bad writing, but it would not be relatable to anyone, especially people who are wheelchair bound.
Do you understand?
Is this clear?
I'm really spoon feeding now.
Being in a wheelchair doesn't automatically make her relatable if she isn't written like a person in a wheelchair would really be. Same with Batman. His parents being murdered doesn't make him relatable if the audience can't see truth and realism in how he reacted and reacts to it. Batman's writers admit he's nuts. Listen to Kevin Smith's podcast Fatman on Batman. He interviews batman writers and creators all the time and they often say he's a paychopath.
Now i know what part of your next post will be, so let me just make something painfully clear AGAIN!!!
I believe DC has made many of their characters more relatable, thereby negating (that means ending) this debate. My above comment about oracle is hypothetical (that means an imagines scenario) and not based at all on how the character is written. I'm sure she is written quite well and is relatable because of how she is written as a character, not simply because she's in a wheelchair. That is a patronising assumption to make and you shouldn't say things like that. Its saying that people in wheelchairs must like her because she's like them. Can you see how disgusting that is? Thats no different than saying all Asians relate to all asian characters just because they are asian. Its soooooo patronising.
I agree that a person might relate to the situation of being in a wheelchair, but we're talking about stories and characters, and its just not enough to base a character's relatability on. Its how she reacts to it that makes a wheelchair bound character relatable or not in story.
I'm not trying to dazzle you with any kind of psychology. This is pretty basic stuff.
Just think about what it is about a character that makes you keep buying a book every month. Say you were born on a farm. Do you say, "i totally get Superman, because i was born on a farm!" That's obviously stupid right? Of course it is. I grew up in a country town. Most of the guys in my town became alcoholics at 18. None of them ever went out and changed the world and the fact that Superman also grew up on a farm doesn't make him relatable to me. Its other things that make him and other characters relatable. Its how they react to what life throws them. Do you get that? Why do you think they've depowered Superman? To try and bring him down from being a god and make him more relatable.
I'll remind you about the fact that i believe DC is making its characters more relatable these day in a moment, but first let me comment on your hulk comment. I might have to simplify this a bit like my other points...
Hulk is not relatable because of a disorder he might have, just like Oracle is not simply relatable because of a wheelchair. Again, this is condescending and an afront to anyone with a mental disorder, which by the way is a growing problem. Google the stats on people with bipolar disorder in the U.S. Its scarey how many people have it and it makes people who have it do violent and nasty things that they wouldn't normally do.
But look, the disorder is just a tiny piece of what makes hulk a relatable character to a lot of people (not all perhaps, but a lot) is the way Banner handles what happens ro him ( although to be honest i think Marvel has screwed Hulk up a bit and made him rather unrelatable recently, but then i'm sure you'll remember the times i've said the differences between the companies don't really exist anymore? Oh no wait, thats one of the bits you keep missing. I'm sure you'll miss it again but i'll just keep going anyway.)
Actually if you take away Banner and ignore his struggle, hulk is more like what Batman and Superman used to be like.
Its like this. Batman, Superman and many of the other original flagship characters of DC were made to be characters audiences would aspire to be. They were an ideal, how we should be. Marvel tried to make their characters more like how we are and thereby more relatable to the average person. Read any book on the history of comics and let someone else tell you if you won't believe me. Its historical fact.
You seem to find this a bad thing and i want you to answer me this question. If you don't i'm going to have to just take it that you're not capable of any clever thoughts and give up on you. The question is this: why do you think making a relatable character is more important than making a character that is beyond us, someone we should aspire to be instead of who we already are?
I ask this question because its the crux of this whole debate. This is what DC fans are so angry about and fearful of.
Captain America isn't relatable to most of us. He's just so good and perfect and noble, but like Superman he is someone we aspire to be like. I'm interested to know why you are so horrified by this idea.
Anyway i'm bored of repeating myself and am disappointed your arguments haven't been more of a challenge, so i probably won't reply again. I'll only do so if you try a bit harder. Otherwise...try to lighten up a bit mate. Its only comics.
Log in to comment