Shaded.
Writing: I did like the writing in this issue. I thought it was entertaining.
Characters: This is where I have a problem. In this first issue of the Dark Things arc in JSA, JSA had the JSA as a guest appearance and some JSA characters were used a lot, but in this issue the JSA characters barely got any parts.
Dialogue: This dialogue really didn't interest me because it was coming from characters I don't really care about.
Art: The art is okay.
Cover: Well I can tell that the Dark Things issues are all gonna make one cover so I do like that.
Penciling: I really don't like the character penciling. Some times it lacks a lot of detail.
Colors: I do really like the coloring though.
Favorite pages and why.
4-9: The whole Obsidian scene was really cool.
20: Seeing Miss Martian turn into a White Martian was really cool.
Reasons to and not to pick up.
Reasons to pick up: If you want to see what's happening. If you are a very big fan of the JSA then I think this is the perfect issue for that. I think the story was pretty good in this issue as well.
Reasons not to pick up: The cross over was not handled properly because the JLA did not get enough parts. Also I am not too crazy about this art.
Verdict: BARELY Pick it up. 3.5 out of 5.