Gottheit says:

"Nope. You'll just never know."

LOL!

I would love to see the Phantom Stranger to rejoin their ranks.

avengpymhawk says:

"I would love to see the Phantom Stranger to rejoin their ranks."

when was the phantom stranger part of the league?

Nighthunter says:

"avengpymhawk says:

"I would love to see the Phantom Stranger to rejoin their ranks."

when was the phantom stranger part of the league?"

Waaaaaaaaaaaaay back in the seventies.

OK, we've talked about a lot of heroes so far. For the sake of me keeping track of votes, would everyone post the name of 1 hero that they are voting for. Thank you.

White Phantom says:

"OK, we've talked about a lot of heroes so far. For the sake of me keeping track of votes, would everyone post the name of 1 hero that they are voting for. Thank you."

Or not.

Let's try to stay on topic here.

White Phantom says:

"White Phantom says:

"OK, we've talked about a lot of heroes so far. For the sake of me keeping track of votes, would everyone post the name of 1 hero that they are voting for. Thank you."

Or not.

"

I'm not giving up on this topic yet.

Black Canary and Zatanna

you know it makes sense

M

It sounds like I should know that guy, but I don't. Fill me in.

Methos says:

"http://i128.photobucket.com/albums/p171/methosivanhoe/3D%20renderings/JLA-HITMAN1COLOR.jpg you know it makes sense M"

Great Choice,Methos=)

As to the duplication of powers debate, don't forget that Martian Manhunter has the power to make himself invisible - which is one thing Superman can't do.

White Phantom says:

"It sounds like I should know that guy, but I don't. Fill me in."

Who is that guy?!

Post Deleted.

it's Hitman... Tommy Monaghan

M

Methos says:

"it's Hitman... Tommy MonaghanM"

OK, and just for the sake of it, would everyone who has posted and listed or expressed interest in more then one character, please post again the one hero they are voting for. Thank you.

OK, guess not.

Already voted. Lobo.

Zauriel.

1. Captain Atom

2. Zatanna

3. Plastic Man

The main ones that I remember coming up were Zatanna, Plastic Man, and Black Canary so maybe try to pick between them. Just to narrow things down.

ok so I can use character on their current incarnation or their status in the silver age (the era you put in the first post)

Nighthunter says:

"ok so I can use character on their current incarnation or their status in the silver age (the era you put in the first post)"

Errrr, let's go with SA.

White Phantom says:

"Nighthunter says:

"ok so I can use character on their current incarnation or their status in the silver age (the era you put in the first post)"

Errrr, let's go with SA.

"

ugg...

then:

Black Canary, Firestorm and Elongated Man

Which one is choice number one?

White Phantom says:

"Which one is choice number one?"

they are in order

Nighthunter says:

"White Phantom says:

"Which one is choice number one?"

they are in order"

Great, thanks.

The Flash

Barry Flash says:

"The Flash"

flash is already there

White Phantom says:

"The current roster is Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern, Flash, Aquaman, Martian Manhunter, Green Arrow, and Atom. Pretend you're a member and vote for a new Leaguer!"

For the benefit of everyone who's suggesting characters here's the roster I'm using so you can't vote for any of them.

OK, well to try to get things up to speed, I'm voting for Plastic Man. I think his powers are different enough to make him a valuable member, he'd bring some humor to the team, and I just like him.

White Phantom says:

"OK, well to try to get things up to speed, I'm voting for Plastic Man. I think his powers are different enough to make him a valuable member, he'd bring some humor to the team, and I just like him."

Plastic Man is also very powerfull....then again I prefer Elongated Man

Nighthunter says:

"White Phantom says:

"OK, well to try to get things up to speed, I'm voting for Plastic Man. I think his powers are different enough to make him a valuable member, he'd bring some humor to the team, and I just like him."

Plastic Man is also very powerfull....then again I prefer Elongated Man"

But doesn't he just have elasticity like Mr. Fantastic?

Kyle Rayner

i think he finally deserves it after the Corps War

M

I know this is way out there, but I would love to see a darker character on the JLA, like maybe Lobo or Black Adam, or maybe a turned Dr. Light. Something like that in my opinion would interesting.

I still wnat nightwing and I want him as Chairman of the league!

Its the position that he was built for.

Umm guys this is SA. Kyle wasn't a GL in Silver Age at this time. And Nightwing was still Robin. He's in the Titans.

White Phantom says:

"Nighthunter says:

"ok so I can use character on their current incarnation or their status in the silver age (the era you put in the first post)"

Errrr, let's go with SA.

"

I kinda assumed people would get the message.

White Phantom says:

"Umm guys this is SA. Kyle wasn't a GL in Silver Age at this time. And Nightwing was still Robin. He's in the Titans."

you didn't state the character had to be Silver Age

M

White Phantom says:

"White Phantom says:

"Nighthunter says:

"ok so I can use character on their current incarnation or their status in the silver age (the era you put in the first post)"

Errrr, let's go with SA.

"

I kinda assumed people would get the message."

I got it but I would have prefered it to be in the modern age with the current characters in the league

Nighthunter says:

"White Phantom says:

"White Phantom says:

"Nighthunter says:

"ok so I can use character on their current incarnation or their status in the silver age (the era you put in the first post)"

Errrr, let's go with SA.

"

I kinda assumed people would get the message."

I got it but I would have prefered it to be in the modern age with the current characters in the league"

Sorry, that's just the one I'm familiar with. But characters like Black Canary are in the current League, right.

yup

Superman

Batman

Wonder Woman

John Stewart

Red Tornado

Vixen

Red Arrow

Black Lightning

Black Canary

Firestorm (haven't seen him after the Injustice League arc so he may not be)

Hawkgirl

Thought so.

OK, time to jump start this thread again. For something worthwhile, don't vote for Hawkman, he was the member elected after Atom was first elected, which is the time I'm using, that way it's something different.

beast boy or nightwing they would be crazy (in a good way) on the team.

I just really needed to say this, but AQUAMAN NEEDS TO COME BACK. IT SEEMS HE'D BE MORE DESERVING OF A SPOT ON THE TEAM RATHER THAN SOME OF THE CURRENT MEMBERS.

black lightning

i want nwing but he hate it but reasonable would be plastice man since hes got whats needed or and martian manhunter even though nighthunter forgot about him