Pretty simple really. State which members you would like to see in a future Justice League film if DC ever get round to doing it. Oh couple of rules:
 
1. No Superman or Batman. I learnt in a forum here couple months ago that Batman's off limits due to the fact Nolan doesn't see his version of Batman mixing well with the superpowered JLA whereas apparently Superman is not going to be included in the future Justice League film as he would steal the show from the other characters.
2. No more than 7 members in the JLA film
3. State which heroes you would first include in their own feature length film and which heroes you would only include in the actual JLA film. I know this is similar to the Avengers route but imo it's a good tactic.
 
You can go into further details if you wish. Feel free to comment away!

My ideal movie Justice League would be:
 
1. Green Lantern - Hal Jordan (Already has own film)
2. The Flash - Barry Allen (Possibly will have own film in the future)
3. Wonder Woman (Feature in own film first)
4. Martian Manhunter - Superman replacement (Feature in own film first)
5. Hawkman - Batman replacement to keep this superpowered team grounded, similar to Hawkeye in Avengers (JL film only)
6. The Atom - Brings some intelligence to the team (JL Only)  
7. Black Canary - Adds a woman's touch to the team and brings spunk as well (Appears first in JLA film)

Green Lantern (as others have said, got his own film) 
Flash (Barry) - possibly get his own film
Martian Manhunter - more than just a "green Superman" - would be good to see him use his invisibility powers, for example. 
Wonder Woman - increased popularity / awareness of the character due to upcoming TV series 
Zatanna 
Black Canary 
Hawkman 
 
I would also include another female character to make the team gender equal - possibly Batgirl or Huntress

    
Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern (John Stewart), Flash (Barry Allen), Martian Manhunter, Aquaman. 
 
I don't see how this can work any other way, quite frankly. The Justice League of America finally showing up on the silver screen with less than their best is a death sentence in my opinion. Superman and Batman are above and beyond. Snyder and Nolan's work on them respectively can be viewed as prestige and definitive and does not need to fit in to the world of the Justice League (like All-Star Superman to the rest of the DC Universe). Besides, Nolan's Batman work ends soon, so he will eventually have no say. 
 
If Green Lantern is any good, this movie should fit into that continuity. I already heard that John Stewart will make a cameo appearance in the film. The League should face something big. I'm thinking so big that it takes the Green Lanterns out of commission for the duration of the film causing the Oans to scamper for replacements. John is Hal's stand-in who realizes that the cosmic threat is centered on Earth and requires the attention of the world's most powerful heroes. 
 
Flash and Wonder Woman should be featured in their solo movies before this. Furthermore, This movie should be the first of a thematic trilogy.

My JLA:

• Superman
• Batman
• Wonder Woman
• Green Lantern (I'd personal love to have Kyle though...)
• Flash
• Zatanna
• Atom

The main 7 of the DCnU JL.

• Wonder Woman
• Zatanna
• Green Lantern
• Batman
• Aquaman
• Hawkgirl

@OutlawRenegade said:

@KJPPPimp said:

I don't know if anyone remembers Wizard's Ultimate DC article from way back but I thought it would be the perfect set up for a JL movie. Set up Superman, Batman, Green Lantern (John Stewart), Flash (Barry Allen) and Wonder Woman in their own franchises then Martian Manhunter can bring them all together in a League movie to face a world threatening villain (I think they used Despero).

OR

But no (permanent) faceplate on Cyborg

yes

@Superdork said:

@OutlawRenegade said:

@KJPPPimp said:

I don't know if anyone remembers Wizard's Ultimate DC article from way back but I thought it would be the perfect set up for a JL movie. Set up Superman, Batman, Green Lantern (John Stewart), Flash (Barry Allen) and Wonder Woman in their own franchises then Martian Manhunter can bring them all together in a League movie to face a world threatening villain (I think they used Despero).

OR

But no (permanent) faceplate on Cyborg

yes

Huh forgot I made this thread. I've been finding a few old threads of mine recently. I wonder if there are any others?

Solo films:

• Green Lantern- A reboot to replace that green piece of garbage. Starring Kyle Rayner as Hal's protege. Hal goes bad as Paralax, and is the film's main antagonist. At the end credits, it's revealed that Hal is now the Spectre, and is quietly observing Earth's champions, and is anticipating the arrival of the Apokolips. He's seen in every other solo film, but not saying a word. Just attending.
• Flash- He'd get two films, much like Iron Man did prior to the Avengers. Barry Allen used to be the Flash, but passed the mantle onto his nephew Wally, while he stays at home and concentrates on raising a family. The first film's main antagonist is Mirror Master, and the second film's is Zoom.
• Wonder Woman- Have it set entirely in Themyscara (sp?) and Hell (or wherever Ares is, because he's the villain.). Introduce the concept of her even thinking about going to "the man's world" at the very end. This film would introduce Felix Foust at the end credits, who is a worshiper of Darkseid. He arrives on Themyscara to obtain a bible-like book that summons the Apokolips.

Justice League movie:

Plot-

Felix Foust summons Darkseid for him to conquer the planet. Darkseid has dealt with many planets before (including Mars way back when), but Earth has an essence that he yearns. So he gathers a multitude of creatures and pretty much begins hell on Earth. From the oceans, he releases the Starros (the little starfish-looking things). From the skies, he releases the Parademons (or whatever they're called). Wonder Woman, Flash, Green Lantern, Aquaman, and the Martian Manhunter not only fend Darkseid off, but they liberate many of the prisoners on Apocolyps (who are later revealed as the New Gods, Mr. Miracle and Barda).

• Aquaman- When the big city is in the middle of the fight that establishes the mini-villains (in this case, Starro), have Aquaman say that these creatures have been pouring out of the deepest ocean trenches and have been leveling Atlantis. He knows the air-breathers are too simple-minded to know what this is about, so it must be the doing of something else. Atlantean prophecies read that such creatures would bring about the "end of days," and that "the five champions will destroy the dark one." This is the King Arthur-type Aquaman. He's strongly attracted to WW, the leader.
• Martian Manhunter- He's a prisoner on Apokolips. Long ago, upon the slaughter of the Green Martians, the White Martians captured him and they struck a deal with Darseid. Darkseid later destroys Mars, leaving it as the barren wasteland it is today. Darkseid uses MM as the telepathic link to direct the Parademons and Starros to pretty much raise hell on Earth. He's liberated by Kyle and Wally, who've just been transported in via boom tube (which Spectre was responsible for).

At the end, the Justice League are the best superhero team ever, and the government gives them the Watchtower, and all that other cool stuff. Specter is having one of those meetings with all those really powerful people, like the wizard Shazam, Ganthet, Phantom Stranger, and the leader of the New Gods. That meeting will set up the next JLA threat, a Captain Marvel movie, the sequel to GL, and a New Gods film.

@Supermansito: Although I'm not sure now whether what I've said in the OP still applies, I do feel Superman and Batman would kind of steal the show from the other heroes. Imagine if Spider-Man and Wolverine were in the Avengers. One is the amongst the most well known superheroes of all time whereas all of the X-Men films were taken up by Wolverine. I wouldn't want that happening in a Justice League movie.

@Gambit1024: Wow. Just wow. Awesome ideas as usual. If I were working for Warner Bros, you'd be hired instantly. But if guys like us can come up with good ideas for a Justice League movie why can't Warner Bros?

Full JLA:

1. Wonder Woman
2. Cyborg
3. Booster Gold
4. Miss Martian
5. John Stewart
6. Wally West
7. Mera

The goal is for a pan-generational mix of characters from the Silver Age forward, as well as a more even split of genders. If 7 slots is too much, start cutting characters from the bottom up. Solo titles for the first four spinning off of the JL film.

@TheCannon said:

@fodigg IT already said in the OP no Supes or Bats.

Okay, I'll cut them from my team and add in Booster Gold.

Can't believe this thread of mine is still going strong.

@Wboy Firstly this thread was made at a time when it was rumoured Superman and batman were not going to be in the JLA film. Secondly it adds more variation and choices to other characters who may never have a film of their own. It's just the rules of this thread, no need to make a fuss.