durakken's Justice League Dark #1 - In The Dark, Part One: Imaginary Women review

    Avatar image for durakken
    • Score:
    • durakken wrote this review on .
    • 3 out of 9 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
    • durakken has written a total of 200 reviews. The last one was for ...Must Come Down
    • This review received 24 comments

    If anyone is in the dark its this writer

    I am not impressed by this title at all. The concept and starting point is there, but the character writing and art are off putting, dull, wooden, and really the characters don't quite act as they would while some of the art doesn't pay attention to the writing... In particular we have Superman talking like a robot, Wonder Woman saying things similar to what Batman would say, Cyborg just there for a punchline. Batman smiles... for some reason. When Zatanna uses a spell for binding feet it binds the entire body, and none of the characters are really introduced... and most of these characters are relatively unknown.

    Xanadu's back story is in Demon Knights

    Shade is from I don't know where and his origins aren't told anywhere I know of

    Deadman you have to pick up DC Presents

    John Constantine is a little known DC character that I have no clue about

    Zatanna's backstory is not given

    June Moon/Enchantress Only if you've read other things do you know they're linked otherwise June Moon is just out of place.

    So we're expected to know these characters from other books so this should be a team origin story, but the story meanders and in general doesn't go anywhere or tell us anything...

    Further the cast of characters and name for this book is just out of place. They should have named this something else, something like one of those magic groups I can't think of right now and/or included better characters such as Doctor Fate, Spectre, Black Alice, Misfit, Captain Marvel, Mary Marvel, Etrigan (which even though the profile says is in the book I didn't see), Traci 13, Empress, Donna Troy, Shining Knight, pick a pantheon and draw from them considering all the gods exist in DC. All of these characters would have been much better for a JLD book than the characters we do have for it (Other than Zatanna and maybe Xanadu).

    These aren't bad characters mind you, just they aren't good for team books and definitely not good for a book called JUSTICE LEAGUE Dark.

    Other reviews for Justice League Dark #1 - In The Dark, Part One: Imaginary Women

      "Enter freely - unafraid." when entering Madness 0

      What the normal Justice League of America is to the main DCU, the Justice League Dark seems to be the spine for the "Dark" books.  The Dark books were all aces in my opinion when looking at the 52.  Most of the Dark books had Vertigo writers or characters and that is why they have a very Vertigo feel to them.  When Superheroes moved to Vertigo, the series tend to have short life since the support was not there, since most people support the mainstream.  With the 52 it seems the classic Vertigo v...

      16 out of 16 found this review helpful.

      The M Now Stands for Meta, but the Changing Man's Still Mad! 0

      The Enchantress has gone mad (as she's want to do) and poor June Moone's life's been turned inside out as a result (as tends to happen). Madame Xandu summons Shade the Changing Man to bring together a team of the DCU's most powerful but problematic supernatural experts to bring down the insane sorceress before she turns the world (further) inside out.The GoodI've been waiting for this book ever since it was announced and I can't say enough how pleased I am with it!!!Ryan Sook's cover looks amazi...

      7 out of 7 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.