cyclops4president's Justice League #21 - Shazam! Conclusion review

Justice League 21 Shazam conclusion - not magical

Cover: 4.5/5

Gary Frank does a GREAT JOB on this cover, drawing us in with the anticipation of a battle extraordinaire. I can almost feel Black Atoms headlock! I would buy this just based on the cover, no back story needed, unfortunately, that's about all I liked from this book.

Story art: 3/5

What can I say, I am not totally a Gary Frank fan. I am a big "art" guy, and I tend to go through a book quickly at first, just looking at the art, not reading the story, to see if

1. The art does a good job telling the story without the narrative (eh, I guess so)

2. Does the art....move me, inspire me, did it create something new that I haven't seen before or haven't seen in a long time. (no,no,no,no)

For an "epic" conclusion to almost 2 years of story in the making, I would have thought Gary Frank would have gone for the knockout in this book, but it seems he may have pulled his punches.

Story line: 3/5 This story is all about the "switcharoo"

Black Atom holds Billy's friends ransom to get Billy's powers. Billy instead gives powers to his friends who each take a piece of the S.H.A.Z.A.M. (Strength of Hercules..etc) Billy's newly powered friends wrangle up the civilians as well as the 7 deadly sins while Billy tends to Black Atom. There are a couple good "scuffles" between them when Billy realizes he can't beat Atom as Shazam. That is when tricky little Billy pulls of the ol' "switcharoo"! Atom stated earlier to Billy that he has been Black Atom for centuries and that Billy is only a mere child! Billy decides to revert back to his child form, call Atom a Big Bully, and challenge him to a real fight as a "real man"! Well, dumb ol' Atom falls for the switcharoo, changes back to his man self, and proceeds to crumble to dust because his man self is old as dirt, before he can even utter Shazam once more to turn himself back into Black Atom. The friends loose their powers back to billy, and Christmas is saved everyone! Yeahhhhhhhh!

Overall: 2/5 I feel this WHOLE thing has been a "switcharoo". I know this is an "epic" conclusion but the title of the book is still Justice League. I got no justice League. Switcharoo. I was promised epic battle royale based on the cover! Nope! Switcharoo. The final battle WAS a switcharoo by Billy, and felt more like Bugs Bunny taking advantage of poor old Elmer Fudd than a serious conclusion to a story I have been religiously following for 2 years. I am just, disappointed, that's all. I will still recommend this book but it just fell from what I was expecting. Maybe my expectations were too high. I don't want to totally hate on Geoff Johns because I really love his writing, well, except for this anyway.

4 Comments Refresh
Edited by johnkmccubbin91

Great review, and although I liked this a lot more than you, you give your reasons for marking so low, and although I may slightly disagree, I can see where your coming from, and it's a shame that you didn't enjoy it as much. It was however a well written review, and I have seen a slight improvement in the quality with this one, although I like your reviews in general anyway : )

Edited by Cyclops4President
Posted by johnkmccubbin91
Posted by Raw_Material

Loved this issue! I'm thinking about writing one myself. The page when Shazam shares his powers with his foster family was incredible!

Other reviews for Justice League #21 - Shazam! Conclusion

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.