eisforextinction's Justice League #1 - Justice League, Part One review

    Avatar image for eisforextinction

    This is not what I ordered

    If Flashpoint has taught me anything is that Geoff Johns will sometimes write comics that aren't great. I was really disappointed with how Flashpoint worked as a whole and especially how Johns writes Batman (Thomas/Bruce). This leads into my review of Justice League #1. I still don't like the way Johns writes Batman (to me it's seems too Frank Millar) and although he's written all of the other members of the League separately in varying amounts I'm not confident that he's a good fit for a book that kicks off the relaunch.

    My other problem is that I don't know if this book is a great way to start the relaunch. While I agree that Justice League is an important DC staple I wonder if some of the characters should have been introduced in their own books before meeting up. That way we would already know about Batman's revamped character and we could focus more on the actual meeting of the characters instead of introducing them and showing how they interact (that Cyborg scene was out of no where and didn't seem necessarily). I also found it dumb when I wanted a preview of how my favourite characters would appear after the relaunch and was given a story set five years before current continuity so it's almost moot.

    I had a lot of friends tell me they bought this issue and they hadn't bought comics for a very long time which I suppose is good but on the other hand I thought this is a farcry from what we were advertised. It seems like this issue tried to please everyone and as a result ended up being average. Flashpoint did a bad job of answering questions and Justice League doesn't try and help it any. Ultimately this is less than 2% of the relaunch so this book could have been terrible (which although it isn't great it's not bad) and it wouldn't have been indicative of the stories to follow.

    This a definitely a book to read regardless of how good it is. This is building block of the DCU relaunch... despite is being not very good.

    Other reviews for Justice League #1 - Justice League, Part One

      Does the Justice League have a Battlecry? 0

      Batman is chasing an alien or a monster. Green Lantern, a cocky, self-absorbed hero, helps him. Together, they investigate this seemingly intergalactic mystery and they decide to go ask other aliens on Earth.  The Good Adventure: The book finally has a sense of adventure again. It's not just a bunch of heroes who have known each other for what seems millennia and just sit about in their big tower or satellite or cave and wait for the next alien so that they may go and punch it in the face. So wh...

      15 out of 16 found this review helpful.

      A Perfect Start 0

      As a disclaimer, I am one of the hardcore DC fanboys. I make no secret of the fact that I am a reader that would follow Geoff Johns wherever he goes. My excitement for the New 52 is palpable.  With that in mind, my expectations for this issue were naturally rather high, and despite this I was pointedly impressed by this first outing. From that first panel, the visual element of the artistic team drew me in and reminded me of my first days as a comic book reader, awestruck in the wonder that thes...

      7 out of 7 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.