Morbid Much? Buffy Remake is just the WB Robbing a Fresh Grave

Posted by HexThis (951 posts) - - Show Bio

When I was young, like pre-teen young, as a Buffy fan with limited internet access and quite little understanding of how a television show works I still knew the name Joss Whedon. As a matter in fact, knowing his name and appreciating who he is lead me to appreciate Marti Noxon, Doug Petrie, Jane Espenson, Drew Z. Greenberg, David Fury, David Greenwalt, and many of the writers and producers who contributed to Buffy. In what other franchise could material resonate so much with fans to a point where the creators and writers are just as much stars as the actors? Hardly any. I credit Joss Whedon a lot for inspiring me throughout my youth to want to write and create new mythologies, new ideas which is why I absolutely cannot abide by this Buffy remake nonsense. 
Hollywood right now is so despicable and repugnant in a way it hasn't been for a very long time which has been sealed for me personally with news of this remake. In the future I feel as though people will look back at this time in cinema as being only monumental from a technological standpoint, otherwise it's bound to look depressing and 

barren. Yes, as cool as it may seem to some, 3D will become old hat much like technicolor and oh yeah, 3D when it came around the first time. These huge special effects people fawn over will pass this innovation period and they'll be produced at a rapid rate, the impact of earlier explorations will be dulled as it will be commonplace. And these totally unnecessary sequels and remakes will mark an absolute absence of originality and emotional dimension in cinema. That the industry would take something a good person like Joss Whedon made from the ground-up and do whatever they please with it is really a show of the times. 
Now, I'm not going to be the hobo on a soapbox and claim the end of the world is near or anything like that but too see something like Buffy be subject to this is just too shameful to not say something about, even if it's just to 10 people. The Buffy comic, which has been selling well, is actually one of the only comics I consistently buy and though it's all far less overtly displayed, everything Buffy that I could get my hands on I still own, I still remember every episode name, a whole sea of quotes, and even if it doesn't consume as much time as it used to in my life, I'm really grateful to have been there for the ride and enjoyed it the way I have. I know that a lot of the people I've met through Buffy have a similar sentimental regard for it and though it's quite peripheral in conversation now I really, really hope a lot of other people hang on to Joss' creation and are not swayed to see this movie. 
Did I ever think this may happen? Of course. Was I okay with it? Sure. Because in my mind, theoretically, I imagined anyone in their right mind would do this in 10 or 20 years from now. But this I could've never imagined especially given that a lot of the actors are only in their 30's and the show hasn't even been off the air for a decade yet. Joss
Whedon and the writers aside, this is a horrible insult to Sarah Michelle Gellar who even to this day still has approval over Buffy's image and has shown the utmost devotion to
Buffy. Her portrayal of Buffy is so fresh in my mind and her vitality is so present it just seems almost cruel to try and plow over the endless hours of hard work she put into to making that character along with her fellow actors who gave performances that were ridiculously underrated. You look at an episode like "The Body" and it's clear that there was a sharp, intense dynamic between everyone who worked on that set. To impede on that and to try to create a new canon entirely so soon after is just plain disrespectful to all of them and I really hope that anyone attached to show has the pride to not even accept a cameo. 
What's even worse? There are new slayers all the time these days! If these studio executives knew anything about Buffy at all, they could've realized this and created a spin-off with a totally different character which I imagine Joss would've been up for writing but the fact they don't even want to bother with meticulously woven storyline just goes to show you they really don't care about Buffy. By not caring about Buffy they, in turn, obviously don't care very much for the fans and are obviously just trying to capitalize on the familiarity of the name to make a buck which just really, truly makes my blood boil.  
So really, seriously, I wouldn't normally do this but I just want to say to all Buffy fans- don't even consider seeing this. Look back on those 122 hours of television Joss and the cast and crew gave us and really think about whether or not you want to throw a few bucks at people who just completely undermines all of that. Also, if anyone knows any petition or open letter or whatever that's being put together please let me know. 

#1 Posted by Baron_Emo (3562 posts) - - Show Bio

I wish they could have had the motivation to produce this film back in '03 or '04 and included the cast and Joss as part of it. This whole business of a remake is just silly.  
I anticipate the day where reboots and remakes come within the span of 6 months. TV shows where, if an episode has low ratings, they retcon the season midway through. 

#2 Posted by EnSabahNurX (2294 posts) - - Show Bio

If I do watch it simply out of curiosity, I would just watch it free online XD I wouldn't support it financially 
Oh For the most part buffy ended in the season 5 finale, and I liked most of 6 but 7 wasn't a fav for me

#3 Posted by kuchiku (4075 posts) - - Show Bio

OMG WTF WHY WOULD THEY DO THIS! Its bad enough that some Dum@ss is taking over joss's idea, I mean come on, COME UP WITH YOUR OWN STUFF! DONT take someone elses Brilliant idea that spanned for 7 seasons and then make a movie that will suck and just piss fans off, WHY BUFFY! Why not start it with a new character! And now there gonna deface buffys name by casting some bimbo as her.......i mean they couldnt even get sarah michelle geller and she even stated in an interview if they ever wanted to bring back buffy, she'd be up for it if the scripts went with the storyline AND DIDNT PISS THE FANS OFF.....and now shes not in
And we all know how brilliant Joss is just by watching Buffy, NO ONE ELSE SHOULD WRITE BUFFY! And Now were stuck with no Sarah and no Joss..........This should not be happening....remind me to castrate who ever came up with this foolish idea......

#4 Posted by Cervantes (601 posts) - - Show Bio

I agree completely. Is it true, BTW, that SMG has say over her image - is that with Joss, do you mean?

Was honestly hoping for a TV movie on the tenth anniversay of the show ending, but now when they do this movie and it FLOPS, that will probably not happen!

Actually, if Avengers does great, Joss will have the pull that it would take to do the TV movie! Or a Buffy reboot - something that wouldn't diss Buffy, though, so like "Slayer" or something, where a teen today finds that she is the Slayer and SMG cameos as Buffy. (I'm such a geek that I would LOVE to have Buffy be the Watcher for this Slayer! She could act like a stuffy librarian like Giles, and would no longer have Slayer strength, but every now and then would kick butt, showing her Reaper side...)

In short, buy Avengers tix, skip the new (sarcastic quotemarks) Buffy movie.

#5 Posted by SimmosFace (9 posts) - - Show Bio

I do not want the new movie to succeed, but I am too much of a Buffy fan to miss it, must...resist......watching...........MOVIE!!!

#6 Posted by HexThis (951 posts) - - Show Bio

@SimmosFace said:

I do not want the new movie to succeed, but I am too much of a Buffy fan to miss it, must...resist......watching...........MOVIE!!!

Because you're a fan, you shouldn't see it. No one should.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.