I don't think that's going to happen, at least not now.

If he changes his methods and the way he does everything only then will he be allowed to come back, as for now there is no chance he's coming back.

"I don't think that's going to happen, at least not now. "

Not until he burns that pill head suit

"I don't think that's going to happen, at least not now. "

"@Primmaster64 said:

"I don't think that's going to happen, at least not now. "

If it does then he becomes another generic dick grayson clone/ripoff. "

"The Batfamily needs someone that can kill if necessary and take out/down the bad guys in ways that the rest of them can't. "

" Not until he burns that pill head suit "

I would prefer if Jason ever took the Hero route again that he start over elsewhere, and if Bruce ever approached him asking him to be one of his "Batmen" he would reply, "Fuck off".

"I would prefer if Jason ever took the Hero route again that he start over elsewhere, and if Bruce ever approached him asking him to be one of his "Batmen" he would reply, "Fuck off". "

Red Hood's become something that's at conflict with Batman's morality. He wouldn't be accepted unless he changed, and if he changed he wouldn't be what readers love him for. Wasn't the whole reason Jason was originally killed off in the comics because nobody liked that Dick Grayson got replaced? People obviously had no interest in Jason before he became the Red Hood.

I really don't see Jason coming back,  after he's constantly said his way is better,to anyone who would listen, they'd not let him fight crime either, as he'd be far more likely to slip and kill someone if in a tough situation.

"Not until he burns that pill head suit "

Considering that Jason has been too violent and crossed the line by killing the bad guys while fighting crime, I doubt it'll happen. If there's only one way he can come back, it's to get his black hair with the white stripe back.

" @Unwritten Duck said:

"I would prefer if Jason ever took the Hero route again that he start over elsewhere, and if Bruce ever approached him asking him to be one of his "Batmen" he would reply, "Fuck off". "

What makes you think bruce would approach him,people need to stop living in fantasies. "

"@entropy_aegis said:

" @Unwritten Duck said:

"I would prefer if Jason ever took the Hero route again that he start over elsewhere, and if Bruce ever approached him asking him to be one of his "Batmen" he would reply, "Fuck off". "

What makes you think bruce would approach him,people need to stop living in fantasies. "

 @entropy_aegis To be honest I have no idea why Bruce would approach him, other than maybe to try and reach out to him again, but being logical I think Bruce would rather have Jason off the streets completely. Oh and as far as that little bit on the end about "people need to stop living in fantasies." If people didn't think about these so called fantasies or to take it further, if we didn't have them, we wouldn't have comics in the first place. Also keep in mind that I realized you said "living in fantasies" not thinking about them. I have just as much right to daydream about what I would like to happen and post my opinion in a discussion as you have a right to rebuke my opinion; however, you would find that people are easier to get along with if you try not to instigate a problem. So would you kindly, add to the discussion rather than making inferences about people based on their opinion. "

" @Unwritten Duck:  You aren't gonna win with him I promise you. He is too air headed to give two shits and a f#@k about what anyone says. You can't argue with someone that "knows" they're right. Its a losing battle. "

" @Unwritten Duck said:

"@entropy_aegis said:

" @Unwritten Duck said:

"I would prefer if Jason ever took the Hero route again that he start over elsewhere, and if Bruce ever approached him asking him to be one of his "Batmen" he would reply, "Fuck off". "

What makes you think bruce would approach him,people need to stop living in fantasies. "

 @entropy_aegis To be honest I have no idea why Bruce would approach him, other than maybe to try and reach out to him again, but being logical I think Bruce would rather have Jason off the streets completely. Oh and as far as that little bit on the end about "people need to stop living in fantasies." If people didn't think about these so called fantasies or to take it further, if we didn't have them, we wouldn't have comics in the first place. Also keep in mind that I realized you said "living in fantasies" not thinking about them. I have just as much right to daydream about what I would like to happen and post my opinion in a discussion as you have a right to rebuke my opinion; however, you would find that people are easier to get along with if you try not to instigate a problem. So would you kindly, add to the discussion rather than making inferences about people based on their opinion. "

 
The title of this thread is'nt should bruce invite jason,its should jason rejoin. 
so it should be jason coming to dick who tells him to fuck off.like i said we can stop living in our fanfic fantasies.
@RedHoodJT said:

" @Unwritten Duck:  You aren't gonna win with him I promise you. He is too air headed to give two shits and a f#@k about what anyone says. You can't argue with someone that "knows" they're right. Its a losing battle. "

I am right.if you think you are then prove me wrong. "

" @entropy_aegis said:

" @Unwritten Duck said:

"@entropy_aegis said:

" @Unwritten Duck said:

"I would prefer if Jason ever took the Hero route again that he start over elsewhere, and if Bruce ever approached him asking him to be one of his "Batmen" he would reply, "Fuck off". "

What makes you think bruce would approach him,people need to stop living in fantasies. "

 @entropy_aegis To be honest I have no idea why Bruce would approach him, other than maybe to try and reach out to him again, but being logical I think Bruce would rather have Jason off the streets completely. Oh and as far as that little bit on the end about "people need to stop living in fantasies." If people didn't think about these so called fantasies or to take it further, if we didn't have them, we wouldn't have comics in the first place. Also keep in mind that I realized you said "living in fantasies" not thinking about them. I have just as much right to daydream about what I would like to happen and post my opinion in a discussion as you have a right to rebuke my opinion; however, you would find that people are easier to get along with if you try not to instigate a problem. So would you kindly, add to the discussion rather than making inferences about people based on their opinion. "

 
The title of this thread is'nt should bruce invite jason,its should jason rejoin. 
so it should be jason coming to dick who tells him to fuck off.like i said we can stop living in our fanfic fantasies.
@RedHoodJT said:

" @Unwritten Duck:  You aren't gonna win with him I promise you. He is too air headed to give two shits and a f#@k about what anyone says. You can't argue with someone that "knows" they're right. Its a losing battle. "

I am right.if you think you are then prove me wrong. "

@entropy_aegis:  Now you're arguing semantics on the discussion topic. This really isn't worth my time, but aren't you, as you say, living a fanfic fantasy by saying this:  "it should be jason coming to dick who tells him to fuck off." 
It hasn't happened, so you evidently came up with that out of your own head, am I right?  
 
This arguing is going to take us nowhere and add nothing to this discussion. I viewed your profile and examined your lists. It's evident you don't like Judd Winick (most hated characters) but judging from your Anti-batfamily list I don't think you hold any particular animosity toward the Jason Todd character himself. I do think you prefer to see him remain a villain as I assumed from this earlier comment:  
 

@entropy_aegis said: 
 " @Primmaster64 said: 

"I don't think that's going to happen, at least not now. "

If it does then he becomes another generic dick grayson clone/ripoff. "  

 My point with this is why don't you share with us all what you rather see happen, or is this:   "it should be jason coming to dick who tells him to fuck off." , all you want to see happen? Not to sound offensive, but surely you can come up with something better than that?  "

" @entropy_aegis:  @entropy_aegis said:

" @Unwritten Duck said:

" @entropy_aegis said:

" @Unwritten Duck said:

"@entropy_aegis said:

" @Unwritten Duck said:

"I would prefer if Jason ever took the Hero route again that he start over elsewhere, and if Bruce ever approached him asking him to be one of his "Batmen" he would reply, "Fuck off". "

What makes you think bruce would approach him,people need to stop living in fantasies. "

 @entropy_aegis To be honest I have no idea why Bruce would approach him, other than maybe to try and reach out to him again, but being logical I think Bruce would rather have Jason off the streets completely. Oh and as far as that little bit on the end about "people need to stop living in fantasies." If people didn't think about these so called fantasies or to take it further, if we didn't have them, we wouldn't have comics in the first place. Also keep in mind that I realized you said "living in fantasies" not thinking about them. I have just as much right to daydream about what I would like to happen and post my opinion in a discussion as you have a right to rebuke my opinion; however, you would find that people are easier to get along with if you try not to instigate a problem. So would you kindly, add to the discussion rather than making inferences about people based on their opinion. "

 
The title of this thread is'nt should bruce invite jason,its should jason rejoin. 
so it should be jason coming to dick who tells him to fuck off.like i said we can stop living in our fanfic fantasies.
@RedHoodJT said:

" @Unwritten Duck:  You aren't gonna win with him I promise you. He is too air headed to give two shits and a f#@k about what anyone says. You can't argue with someone that "knows" they're right. Its a losing battle. "

I am right.if you think you are then prove me wrong. "

@entropy_aegis:  Now you're arguing semantics on the discussion topic. This really isn't worth my time, but aren't you, as you say, living a fanfic fantasy by saying this:  "it should be jason coming to dick who tells him to fuck off." 
It hasn't happened, so you evidently came up with that out of your own head, am I right?  
 
This arguing is going to take us nowhere and add nothing to this discussion. I viewed your profile and examined your lists. It's evident you don't like Judd Winick (most hated characters) but judging from your Anti-batfamily list I don't think you hold any particular animosity toward the Jason Todd character himself. I do think you prefer to see him remain a villain as I assumed from this earlier comment:  
 

@entropy_aegis said: 
 " @Primmaster64 said: 

"I don't think that's going to happen, at least not now. "

If it does then he becomes another generic dick grayson clone/ripoff. "  

 My point with this is why don't you share with us all what you rather see happen, or is this:   "it should be jason coming to dick who tells him to fuck off." , all you want to see happen? Not to sound offensive, but surely you can come up with something better than that?  "

A) my comment on dick telling jason to fuck off was to show you how retarded your orignal statement was,last time i checked you're the one who started this.i'm not living in my fantasy cause i never made such a statement. B) i can hate winick all i want. C) since you have enough time to go through my lists,i would advise you to take another look cause some characters in the antibat family list happen to be pretty high on my favourites list,talia(second favourite female),Ra's and bane happen to be in my top 5 villians while deathstroke in my top 20.SHEESH. D) jason todd fans have agreed that he becomes a dick grayson clone if something like him joining the family happens,if you cant see the obviousness,then thats your loss. "

Why you mad? "

* sigh*

Jason Todd should never have been brought back.He should be kept as a villain until someone in the Bat-Family (preferrably Steph\Batgirl) accidentally kills him.

" @entropy_aegis:  @Unwritten Duck: Lets play a game called reading the site rules, paying close attention to the no swearing part... lets see who can find it first.... 
 
 
@Vance Astro: Totally agree, Jason should never have been touched, his death was a symbolic part of the Batman history, effecting more then just Bruce. Brining him back just weakened everything they achieved by killing him in the first place.  "

Jason Todd shouldn't go back to the Batman family at all I rather see him on his own

" @entropy_aegis: It does not matter if you used them to insult him or not, the rules are no swearing, also you did insult him non the less, which yet again against the rules. If you can not talk to someone without insulting them then don't talk to them. If a user is acting in a trollish way PM myself or another mod to deal with it. "

@Vance Astro: Totally agree, Jason should never have been touched, his death was a symbolic part of the Batman history, effecting more then just Bruce. Brining him back just weakened everything they achieved by killing him in the first place.  "

" I don't see the big deal with characters coming back,its hard to find characters that haven't been beought back theses days "

" @daredevil21134 said:

" I don't see the big deal with characters coming back,its hard to find characters that haven't been beought back theses days "

The big deal is that it's unoriginal.It's been done so many times and the way most characters come back is unimaginative and just awkward.It's like one more day.It had to happen for Spider-Man to get better but it was one of the worst Spider-Man arcs of all time.That's kind of how everyone's "coming back to life story is" people punching realities,Secret alien invasions,being stuck in a time warp and not really being dead in the first place,just reappearing and the publisher pretending the character was never killed off,alternate reality versions taking spots,exploiting magical items and beings etc. etc. Maybe if one of these stories were done right and a valid explanation for bringing the character back was given then people would be fine with it.When you make a characters death a pivotal moment in the companies history and then just randomly bring them back with some convoluted, bullsh#t storyline.It gets annoying after a while.Look at all of the characters that have come back just during your life time.Can you say that the way any of them returned was justified? "

" @Vance Astro said:

" @daredevil21134 said:

" I don't see the big deal with characters coming back,its hard to find characters that haven't been beought back theses days "

The big deal is that it's unoriginal.It's been done so many times and the way most characters come back is unimaginative and just awkward.It's like one more day.It had to happen for Spider-Man to get better but it was one of the worst Spider-Man arcs of all time.That's kind of how everyone's "coming back to life story is" people punching realities,Secret alien invasions,being stuck in a time warp and not really being dead in the first place,just reappearing and the publisher pretending the character was never killed off,alternate reality versions taking spots,exploiting magical items and beings etc. etc. Maybe if one of these stories were done right and a valid explanation for bringing the character back was given then people would be fine with it.When you make a characters death a pivotal moment in the companies history and then just randomly bring them back with some convoluted, bullsh#t storyline.It gets annoying after a while.Look at all of the characters that have come back just during your life time.Can you say that the way any of them returned was justified? "

 You have a point but my point as you stated it happens with alot of characters/stories not just Jason Todd thats why I personally don't care or understand why that keeps being used against him,the problem seems to be with companies not the character "

I like Jason Todd and I for one am glad that he came back. I mean if Norman and Harry Osborne can get brought back for Spider-man to be a major villain once again, why can't Jason come back. It doesn't make it any less of a great failure for Batman. The fact is that Jason still died and it was still Batmans greatest failure. Jason kills the rest of the Bat family won't. That right there is an example of how Batman failed Jason. He tried to teach him how to take a criminal down without killing them. But Jason always felt that some criminals were just too bad to let live. So even though Jason is back it doesn't make him any less of a failure of Batman. I personally like the way Jason is. I think that he is how they should be. And I also think that he should be the one they send in when the job needs it. Because everyone knows that Batman won't kill but Jason does. Its just like X-Force. Everyone knew that the X-men will not kill under any circumstance. X-force will. But when the rest of the x-men found out that Cyclops had put this team together they were too pissed and wouldn't listen to reason so Cyclops, much to his dismay, disbanded X-force. It no different. 
 
Now you wanna talk about a lame story arc. Batman Inc. Nuff said.

"I like Jason Todd and I for one am glad that he came back. I mean if Norman and Harry Osborne can get brought back for Spider-man to be a major villain once again, why can't Jason come back. It doesn't make it any less of a great failure for Batman. The fact is that Jason still died and it was still Batmans greatest failure. Jason kills the rest of the Bat family won't. That right there is an example of how Batman failed Jason. He tried to teach him how to take a criminal down without killing them. But Jason always felt that some criminals were just too bad to let live. So even though Jason is back it doesn't make him any less of a failure of Batman. I personally like the way Jason is. I think that he is how they should be. And I also think that he should be the one they send in when the job needs it. Because everyone knows that Batman won't kill but Jason does. Its just like X-Force. Everyone knew that the X-men will not kill under any circumstance. X-force will. But when the rest of the x-men found out that Cyclops had put this team together they were too pissed and wouldn't listen to reason so Cyclops, much to his dismay, disbanded X-force. It no different.   Now you wanna talk about a lame story arc. Batman Inc. Nuff said. "

I never looked at it as he left the family, unless you mean actually working with them as a team member, and I don't see the point of that.  He is a great character as developed.

"I never looked at it as he left the family, unless you mean actually working with them as a team member, and I don't see the point of that.  He is a great character as developed. "

" @daredevil21134:  Its true bro. So Batman gets sent back in time. Goes through a bunch of different time periods to come back to actual reality. Then decides hey you know what would be a good idea, for me to go all around the world and find the best fighters around and train them to be the batman for that city or country. Get the hell outta here with that lame ass story. Why the hell does there need to be multiple Batmen? Oh that's right because the original Batman has too big of an ego and it shadows all of Gotham so why not put it over the world too. "

" @daredevil21134:  Its true bro. So Batman gets sent back in time. Goes through a bunch of different time periods to come back to actual reality. Then decides hey you know what would be a good idea, for me to go all around the world and find the best fighters around and train them to be the batman for that city or country. Get the hell outta here with that lame ass story. Why the hell does there need to be multiple Batmen? Oh that's right because the original Batman has too big of an ego and it shadows all of Gotham so why not put it over the world too. "

Oh ok yea I've read that I thought that's what you were talking about but I wasn't sure. Lol.