'Marvel Knights: Inhumans' DVD Review

Posted by Undeadpool (206 posts) - - Show Bio

In 1998, Gus Van Sant directed a shot-for-shot remake of Alfred Hitchcock’s brilliant suspense/horror film Psycho. This wasn’t a remake, as we traditionally use the word nowadays, because next to nothing was changed from the original besides it being in color and featuring an, at the time, modern, all-star cast. While the film was, most agreed, very well made, well shot and well acted, the prevailing question was “Why was it made in the first place?” I found myself asking that very same question while watching The Inhumans motion comic DVD. It’s not a bad piece of entertainment, the story (originally by Paul Jenkins) is a fascinating look into an updated, vastly more politically charged, Inhumans' origin with the Marvel Universe.

Pictured: An excellent use of an artists' strengths

For those unfamiliar: motion comics are like cartoons, but instead of being straight animation, they’re taken from actual comics panels and given a short of rudimentary motion and herein lies the first problem: Jae Lee’s art. Jae Lee’s art is gorgeous to look at, an absolute sight to behold at the best of times, each panel and page almost looking like a piece from classically painted pictures, but one thing they are not is particularly fluid. Lee’s art is much better suited for stories such as this, which are dominated by regal figures pontificating, talking, and scheming, but trying to lend motion to them, particularly the mouth movements, is distracting at best and extremely hokey and unnerving at worst.

Like this, but with fewer words. And more off-putting lips flapping.

The motion comic is broken up into several discrete episodes, a move that I’m unsure of the need for as they follow a very linear path from one directly into the next. At least the DVD could have included a “marathon” mode that stripped the opening and closing credits from each episode. We begin establishing who Black Bolt is and what he’s all about, of course mostly through voiceover as Blackagar can’t speak due to his sonic powers having the ability to level mountains, and here’s where things take a turn for the positive: the voice acting is actually very good. I don’t immediately recognize any of the names (and I’m an enthusiast of both cartoons AND videogames, the two places voice actors have flourished), but, with a few accented exceptions, they do good work. The opening scenes convey the day-to-day pain that Black Bolt lives with and the difficulty of governing despite being unable to speak, it’s unfortunately the animation that struggles to keep up. Again: this is not a critique of Jae Lee’s art, but much more the medium’s inability to use it effectively. We’re also introduced to the idea that Attilan, the city the Inhumans call home, may, in fact, be a splinter colony of Atlantis that is on the surface of Earth under an impenetrable dome. The actual time that this story takes place during is somewhat nebulous, but apparently things like unaccounted for nukes in Eastern European countries are still cause for concern in America, and thus a city full of living gods that is vastly technologically superior to all the countries of Earth is ALSO a cause for great alarm, but so far, beyond Namor trying to claim sovereignty over it, the nation has remained neutral and harmless. We also meet Black Bolt’s family and court, including the imprisoned brother Maximus the Mad, under close lock and key after a failed coup attempt.

Something closer to this style may have been more appropriate for the medium

Next we’re introduced to some of the citizens, it’s youngest citizens in fact, where we see children coming of age and about to be exposed to the Terrigen Mists, the catalyst that will transform them from relative normalcy and unlock their powers, but when something goes terribly wrong with one of their friends, we’re introduced to the working underclass of Attilan: the Alpha-Primitives. Similar to the Epsilon class of the Aldous Huxley novel Brave New World: the Alphas are relegated to simple manual labor, but are basically the slave labor that allows Attilan to exist as it does, and it’s here that some genuine intrigue begins: Attilan is essentially a peaceful utopia, existing not only fully independently and harmoniously with other nations, but also completely non-aggressively. That entire foundation, however, is built upon the backs of an underclass of citizens with few to no rights that major parts of the government don't even think twice of breaking an agreement with, so how much of a moral high-ground can the ruling class really have? And when Maximus touches the mind of the recently ostracized Inhuman, who turns out to have an unexpected and unnoticed power, to institute a coup, is he entirely in the wrong?

At this point, a few factions of the nations of Earth get involved, and it involves some of the absolute WORST Russian accents this side of Natasha Fatale, human forces are mobilized against the Inhumans. We're also treated to some genuine humor as we see Reed Richards appear on a talkshow to discuss the Attilan threat, as well as the impact such beings' existence has on everyday life from Jerry Springer to the Tonight Show. Maximus’ plan is actually quite brilliant, relying both on the avarice of humanity and the arrogance of the Inhumans, as well as intimate knowledge of his brothers’ weaknesses AND his own perceived helplessness culminates in a plot that actually passes a great deal of muster upon critical examination. No henchmen to be knocked out and replaced, no doomsday device to be disarmed after lengthy countdown, just good ol’ fashioned espionage, exploitation, and cleverness. To go much further would be to spoil the culmination of the show, but it’d be worth a very solid recommendation if there weren't already a superior way to experience it: the Inhumans volume collected.

Again: it’s not that this is a bad piece of media, it’s merely an unnecessary one. Between the lip flapping (seriously, just having their faces still with word balloons would have been a more elegant way to show who’s talking) and the very, VERY awkward scene transitions (that are clearly where one issue stopped and another started, or were simply the turn of a page on paper), there’s very little to recommend here unless you are an absolute die-hard Inhumans fan, and even then, this exists more as a strange curio than a thing that is totally worthwhile and must-have. Although one unexpected side-effect of the whole thing was it DID make me want to reread the book it's based on, so it does function as a reminder that the book is excellently written and drawn.

'Marvel Knights: Inhumans' is on sale April 23, 2013 from Shout! Factory.

#2 Edited by Mandrewgora (299 posts) - - Show Bio

Not crazy about motion comics, but I do like The Inhumans.

#3 Posted by MrShway88 (679 posts) - - Show Bio

Love motion comics. Don't get why most people don't.

#4 Edited by wmwadeii (3254 posts) - - Show Bio

Its probably a Netflix watch for me. Currently watching Joss Whedon's Astonishing X-Men that they turned into a motion comic, not bad but not my cup of tea either. Only really watching because I never got to read it.

#5 Edited by Donovan Montgomery (5494 posts) - - Show Bio

Will probably check this out since I missed the series.

#6 Posted by theTimeStreamer (2841 posts) - - Show Bio

hey if 400-500 page books are read to us why not comic books? ..... i cant wait for the auto wipe toilet paper.

#7 Edited by JamDamage (1118 posts) - - Show Bio

this was GREAT graphic that I bought. Jae Lee's art is excellent and the story was very good. I always thought that the Inhumans would make a good live action t.v. show because of this book. It shows life as Inhuman outside the Royal Family a bit and with all the freaky deaky characters I thought it could make for an interesting show.

#8 Posted by SavageDragon (2252 posts) - - Show Bio

@mrshway88: Yeah man totally agree. Both the Black Panther motion and Astonishing X-men were fantastic. I dont get it I love them.

#9 Posted by Renchamp (3020 posts) - - Show Bio

I may skip this and just get the book. Jae Lee is amazing and I would want nothing to distract from his masterful panels.

#10 Posted by leokearon (1785 posts) - - Show Bio

Motion Comics were geat back in the 60's but not now

#11 Posted by FadeToBlackBolt (23238 posts) - - Show Bio

The series is absolutely fantastic. Probably the best Marvel has ever put out. But Motion Comics are pointless.

#12 Edited by Teerack (7459 posts) - - Show Bio

Damn i thought it was out :(

#13 Posted by The Stegman (26102 posts) - - Show Bio

Yeah, motion comics aren't my thing.

#14 Posted by AWeekInGeekdom (230 posts) - - Show Bio

I think Motion Comics should be done with original stories instead of weirdly adapting acclaimed storylines.

#15 Posted by fables87 (1086 posts) - - Show Bio

Not a fan of Motion Comics, but this is a must for Fantastic Four/Marvel Knights/Inhuman fans.

#16 Posted by Gonzo33 (111 posts) - - Show Bio

I think the TPB of this is being reprinted in Augest, I might wait til then. I'd love to know more about The Inhumans after reading FF and New Avengers.

#17 Edited by SolthesunGod (278 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm suprised this didn't work. I really enjoyed Alex Maleev's Spiderwoman motion comic and I thought that was too stylized to work. I would have thought Jae Lee would have been an easier option for this kind of a project.

#18 Posted by RedheadedAtrocitus (6836 posts) - - Show Bio

I have the Watchmen motion comic and I rather enjoy it, and while I think that motion comics are need I think I agree with you, just wholly unnecessary. Plus, the voices may be off for what you think of them as. I know I was with the Watchmen motion comic.

#19 Posted by Perfect 10 (1243 posts) - - Show Bio

it comes out the 23 how did you get it??? i want to get it early too :(

loved the astonishing x-men motion comics so cant wait for this. one of my favorite stories ever. own in print, trade and digital now going to get the motion comic as well. LOVE the inhumans especially my girl Crystal

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.