Ian Churchill Forum

Ian Churchill is a comic book creator

Good art or bad art?

Topic started by Nighthunter on May 24, 2008. Last post by IcePrince_X 3 months ago.
Post by Nighthunter (17,164 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

I've heard in some forums that Churchill's art sucks

Personally I like it, ok it's not the best but it is still good art in my opinion

what do you think?


I've heard in some forums that Churchill's art sucks

Personally I like it, ok it's not the best but it is still good art in my opinion

what do you think?


Post by BatgirlBabs (10,088 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

Anything looks good with the right colorist/inker


Anything looks good with the right colorist/inker


Post by Vlad Tepes Dracula (1,622 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

Art is not defineable, good or bad, its in the point of view, and the artists point of view.


Art is not defineable, good or bad, its in the point of view, and the artists point of view.


Post by BatgirlBabs (10,088 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

Vlad Tepes Dracula says:

"Art is not defineable, good or bad, its in the point of view, and the artists point of view."

I disagree. Greg Land's work is terrible.


Vlad Tepes Dracula says:

"Art is not defineable, good or bad, its in the point of view, and the artists point of view."

I disagree. Greg Land's work is terrible.


Post by Platinumwarrior (1,855 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

I dunno why they say he sucks. He drew some of the best supergirl covers ive ever seen


I dunno why they say he sucks. He drew some of the best supergirl covers ive ever seen


Post by Gloom (1,614 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

BatgirlBabs says:

"Vlad Tepes Dracula says:
"Art is not defineable, good or bad, its in the point of view, and the artists point of view."

I disagree. Greg Land's work is terrible."

HIGH-FIVE!!!


BatgirlBabs says:

"Vlad Tepes Dracula says:
"Art is not defineable, good or bad, its in the point of view, and the artists point of view."

I disagree. Greg Land's work is terrible."

HIGH-FIVE!!!


Post by BatgirlBabs (10,088 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

High five's her back

Art is good when you're not CHEATING


High five's her back

Art is good when you're not CHEATING


Post by Gloom (1,614 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

BatgirlBabs says:

"*High five's her back*Art is good when you're not **CHEATING**"

Ugh, totally!

He makes me want to puke a little. =X


BatgirlBabs says:

"*High five's her back*Art is good when you're not **CHEATING**"

Ugh, totally!

He makes me want to puke a little. =X


Post by Supreme Marvel (2,651 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

image-caption

I like it. It reminds me of Michael Turner's style.

Had to put my two favourite heroes up. :D


image-caption

I like it. It reminds me of Michael Turner's style.

Had to put my two favourite heroes up. :D


Post by BatgirlBabs (10,088 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

Gloom says:

"BatgirlBabs says:
"*High five's her back*Art is good when you're not **CHEATING**"

Ugh, totally!

He makes me want to puke a little. =X"

Or a lot LOL


Gloom says:

"BatgirlBabs says:
"*High five's her back*Art is good when you're not **CHEATING**"

Ugh, totally!

He makes me want to puke a little. =X"

Or a lot LOL


Post by Satyrquaze (3,175 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

Supreme Marvel says:

"http://image.comicvine.com/uploads/item/4000/3760/171948-ian-churchill_400.jpg I like it. It reminds me of Michael Turner's style. Had to put my two favourite heroes up. :D"

He's not a bad artist... but...

I read those issues looking forward to a great cross-over with Captain Marvel and Superman and walked away disappointed not only in the story, but the way he seems to have a love affair with facial muscles... not only that but Cap and Supes may as well be twins here. I mean I know they look similar, but this is just laziness.


Supreme Marvel says:

"http://image.comicvine.com/uploads/item/4000/3760/171948-ian-churchill_400.jpg I like it. It reminds me of Michael Turner's style. Had to put my two favourite heroes up. :D"

He's not a bad artist... but...

I read those issues looking forward to a great cross-over with Captain Marvel and Superman and walked away disappointed not only in the story, but the way he seems to have a love affair with facial muscles... not only that but Cap and Supes may as well be twins here. I mean I know they look similar, but this is just laziness.


Post by Supreme Marvel (2,651 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

Satyrquaze says:

"Supreme Marvel says:
"http://image.comicvine.com/uploads/item/4000/3760/171948-ian-churchill_400.jpg I like it. It reminds me of Michael Turner's style. Had to put my two favourite heroes up. :D"

He's not a bad artist... but...

I read those issues looking forward to a great cross-over with Captain Marvel and Superman and walked away disappointed not only in the story, but the way he seems to have a love affair with facial muscles... not only that but Cap and Supes may as well be twins here. I mean I know they look similar, but this is just laziness."

I did also notice that. Cap has a rounder face and not chisel jawed like sups.


Satyrquaze says:

"Supreme Marvel says:
"http://image.comicvine.com/uploads/item/4000/3760/171948-ian-churchill_400.jpg I like it. It reminds me of Michael Turner's style. Had to put my two favourite heroes up. :D"

He's not a bad artist... but...

I read those issues looking forward to a great cross-over with Captain Marvel and Superman and walked away disappointed not only in the story, but the way he seems to have a love affair with facial muscles... not only that but Cap and Supes may as well be twins here. I mean I know they look similar, but this is just laziness."

I did also notice that. Cap has a rounder face and not chisel jawed like sups.


Post by Crimson Orchid (4,673 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

BatgirlBabs says:

"Anything looks good with the right colorist/inker"

I'd argue this... in the words of my perspective instructor "inking/colouring a bad drawing is like sprinkling glitter on sh!t" If the original drawing isn't good, no matter how much time you put into coloring and inking, it still won't look right.

But on topic, after looking over some of this guys work, I do like it. It doesn't feel off to me.


BatgirlBabs says:

"Anything looks good with the right colorist/inker"

I'd argue this... in the words of my perspective instructor "inking/colouring a bad drawing is like sprinkling glitter on sh!t" If the original drawing isn't good, no matter how much time you put into coloring and inking, it still won't look right.

But on topic, after looking over some of this guys work, I do like it. It doesn't feel off to me.


Post by zero edge (3,354 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

I like his work, since his run on the Covens. But sometimes his art does look a bit odd.


I like his work, since his run on the Covens. But sometimes his art does look a bit odd.


Post by Platinumwarrior (1,855 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

BatgirlBabs says:

"Vlad Tepes Dracula says:
"Art is not defineable, good or bad, its in the point of view, and the artists point of view."
Greg Land's work is terrible."

I disagree Greg Land has great work

image-caption

image-caption


BatgirlBabs says:

"Vlad Tepes Dracula says:
"Art is not defineable, good or bad, its in the point of view, and the artists point of view."
Greg Land's work is terrible."

I disagree Greg Land has great work

image-caption

image-caption


Post by Platinumwarrior (1,855 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

Post Deleted.


Post Deleted.


Post by danhimself (886 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

i really like churchill i'm kind of pissed off he's not doing titans anymore the new guy sucks and i really like greg land too it's to bad he reuses stuff all the time


i really like churchill i'm kind of pissed off he's not doing titans anymore the new guy sucks and i really like greg land too it's to bad he reuses stuff all the time


Post by Soldier-Boy (857 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

danhimself says:

"i really like churchill i'm kind of pissed off he's not doing titans anymore the new guy sucks and i really like greg land too it's to bad he reuses stuff all the time"

same here


danhimself says:

"i really like churchill i'm kind of pissed off he's not doing titans anymore the new guy sucks and i really like greg land too it's to bad he reuses stuff all the time"

same here


Post by Nighthunter (17,164 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

danhimself says:

"i really like churchill i'm kind of pissed off he's not doing titans anymore the new guy sucks and i really like greg land too it's to bad he reuses stuff all the time"

he'll probably be back

he left the book because of a surgery, but in the solicits of september the cover is made by churchill


danhimself says:

"i really like churchill i'm kind of pissed off he's not doing titans anymore the new guy sucks and i really like greg land too it's to bad he reuses stuff all the time"

he'll probably be back

he left the book because of a surgery, but in the solicits of september the cover is made by churchill


Post by IcePrince_X (617 posts) See mini bio
Rating 0 |

Loading...

Ian Churchill:

He did Excalibur (marvel) for a time and had seen his work from pencils to the actual finish product. There are angles that are a bit ugly for me but that is just subjective view. Objectively speaking and seeing his current works, he is as good as the other artist but not really striking or noteworthy like the other ones.

Other ones like Travis Charest, Marc Sylvestri, Jim Lee, Mcfarlane, Joe Mudereira who defined comics illustration during their time.


Ian Churchill:

He did Excalibur (marvel) for a time and had seen his work from pencils to the actual finish product. There are angles that are a bit ugly for me but that is just subjective view. Objectively speaking and seeing his current works, he is as good as the other artist but not really striking or noteworthy like the other ones.

Other ones like Travis Charest, Marc Sylvestri, Jim Lee, Mcfarlane, Joe Mudereira who defined comics illustration during their time.