For me, it would be:

Rhino (War)

Rogue (Pestilence)

Ghost Rider (Famine)

Silver Surfer (Death)

nightcrawler dont really care which one.

http://www.comicvine.com/myvine/Warlock360/blog/&blogId=27772

I think he should choose some C-List villains so that he has a chance to keep them for a while. Anyone else seems to break free in under an hour.

Elixir war or death

War: Juggernaut Pestilence: Rogue or Omega Red Famine: Iceman Death: Sabretooth

War:Hulk,Famine:Storm,Pestilence:Human Torch,Death:Iceman

WAR Iron Man

FAMINE Iceman

PESTILENCE Black Bolt

DEATH Elixir

I like the Four Hourseman of the Apocalypse in X-Men Evolution carttons: Prof X, Magneto, Storm and Mystique.

IcePrince_X says:

"I like the Four Hourseman of the Apocalypse in X-Men Evolution carttons: Prof X, Magneto, Storm and Mystique."

Whoa, that's ridiculous. Did the series end with the dawn of the Age of Apocalypse?

M

War- A-Bomb
Death- Wonder Man
Pestilence- Omega Red
Famine- Storm

 Fantastic Four Horsemen of Apocalypse  
War Thing
Invisible Woman Famine, put's force fields on peoples mouths and they cant' feed 
Torch Pestilence, a plague of fire
Mr. Fantastic Mr. Death,  he can stretch out and reach anyone and every one

" Fantastic Four Horsemen of Apocalypse  War ThingInvisible Woman Famine, put's force fields on peoples mouths and they cant' feed Torch Pestilence, a plague of fireMr. Fantastic Mr. Death,  he can stretch out and reach anyone and every one "

" 1st choice:     Pestilence: Omega Red War: Deathbird Famine: Wither Death: Grim Reaper     2nd choice:  Pestilence: Puff AdderWar: Red She HulkFamine: The MelterDeath: Brimstone Love   3rd choice:  Pestilence:  Radioactive Man War: Luke CageFamine: HolocaustDeath: Nekra "

Wither as Pestilence. 

War : World War Hulk
Death : Sentry/Void
Famine : X-Man (Phoenix Force)
Pestilence : Rune King Thor

War:  Multiple Man (Amped powers makes him a literal army.)

Pestelince: zombie squirrel girl

War:Mojo

Famine: the original Kraven as a zombie

Death: Number None

Are we only allowed to use marvel characters?

gabriel summers vulcan -death rogue - famine empath- pestilance rockslide- war

Punisher as War (don't care if he's not a mutant, he'd make a killer War), Nightcrawler as Death, Omega Red as Pestilence, Venom as Famine. Yeeeeeeeeeeeeah.

War: Bishop

Death: Elixir

Pestilence: Omega Red

Famine: Rouge

War -Toxin

Famine -Sue Storm

Pestilence -Sandman

Death - The Gorgon

I'd stick to mutants (the acolytes from xmen:evo)

War - Colossus

Famine - Pyro

Pestilence - Gambit

Death - Sabretooth

Ares-War

Deadpool-Death

Not sure about the others...................

Pestilence - Leader

War - Onslaught

Famine - Carnage

Death - Annihilus

war: Vision. (his body has been infused with Celestial tech amplifying his already considerable powers!)

Death: Loki (uses his magic plus celestial tech to kill people)

Pestilence: Viper (already uses poison, just has her stats upgraded!)

Famine- Deadpool (just because.)

this would be legit

War - Abomination

Famine - Selene

Pestilence - Omega Red

Death - Uriel Worthington (he gets Archangel's old TO wings)

@joygirl: there's never been a "mutant only" requirement for Horsemen so Punisher is fine.

@avenging_x_bolt: HOLY THREE YEAR LATE REPLY BATMAN.

@joygirl: in the words of the immortal Fred Jones

"You know the concept of time confuses me."