roxanne_starr's Holmes Inc. #3 - Night of the living; Hologram Holmes; The Watson Files; The Terror of the Penitence House; Analysis Paralysis; Special Guest; Artie is Dead; Full Time Voyeur; Flight Lessons; Heroic Deeds; Little Trey in Slumberland; Drinking Buddies; Finally Peace and Qu review

My head is exploding!

Anthologies have always been a dicey commodity in the comic book industry. They rarely sell well and seldom garner critical acclaim. The reason for this is that each individual contribution to an anthology has very little “meat” to it. A short story of one to eight pages, if it is any good, just leaves the reader frustrated, asking, “O.K., and then what?”

A story of eight pages in regular text can easily become a classic, because of the infinite amount of visualizing that the reader can engage in. This is not the case with comics, where the visuals are mapped out for the reader right there on the page. A comic page reads lightening fast compared to a page of text and before the reader knows it…it’s on to the next page.

Anthologies are usually compiled in one of three formats. The first is totally random, where each contributor presents their unique characters and vision that is unlike any of the other entries in that book. The second revolves around a common theme, like love or war, and all the stories contained in it deal with that unifying topic. The third is the type that uses as its unifier a certain well known character or team of characters.

However, reading Holmes, Inc. I ran into an entirely different dynamic than I had ever encountered in a comic anthology before. It revolves around a team that the vast majority of people have never heard of. O.K., I can accept that…let me read on and figure out what each of these characters is all about.

I read one story after another and at one point said to myself, “I’m not really finding out anything about ANY of these characters.” Any given character in one story was a completely different person in the next. One story would have that given character expressing opinions of a clearly political or intellectual bent and in the next story that same person was running amuck chopping off the heads of monsters willy-nilly. The whole thing made very little sense.

Understand that I do not blame any of the contributors for the dreadful confusing nature of the book. If an artist isn’t told, “NO! This particular character would never do OR THINK this,” that creator will just continue on his merry way and never learn anything.

This book is supposed to be Ty Templeton’s teaching tool for students aspiring to create comics. The students can’t be held to account if they don’t receive any discipline. It’s the teacher here who doesn’t receive high marks from me.

3 Comments
Posted by Silkcuts

THANKS FOR THE REVIEW. 
CHEERS.

Posted by Roxanne Starr

"Vanity Press" will never get a good review from me, Silk. And vanity press is ALL that Mr. Templeton presented with this book, in my opinion. This type of publication exists for one purpose only...to amuse and entertain the contributors and their friends and family. It was never even intended to be read by the general public and make money on the open market.

Work is work and a person should get PAID for doing work. If one's work doesn't generate a paycheck, either immediately or in good time...that work is counter-productive.

Posted by Roxanne Starr

Let me emphasize...this is only my opinion. I am first and foremost a proponent of Capitalism after all. :-)

Other reviews for Holmes Inc. #3 - Night of the living; Hologram Holmes; The Watson Files; The Terror of the Penitence House; Analysis Paralysis; Special Guest; Artie is Dead; Full Time Voyeur; Flight Lessons; Heroic Deeds; Little Trey in Slumberland; Drinking Buddies; Finally Peace and Qu

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.