green_tea_light's Green Lantern: New Guardians Annual #1 - The Show Must Go On review

Green Lantern: New Guardians Annual #1

Summary

This annual deviates from the regular New Guardians storyline to give a side story of Carol, Saint Walker and Arkillo going on a mission for the Zamarons. Carol must track down the Lady Styx and ask for her assistance in the war against the Third Army. Aided by a renegade undercover Lantern, Carol and company infiltrate a planet which glorifies hunting criminals for entertainment in order to locate the Lady Styx.

Alternate Summary

Green_Tea_Light, the diehard Green Lantern fan, just got mugged off again.

What I liked

· The sort of stories I would like to see: My main complaint with Green Lantern New Guardians, under Bedard’s writing, is rushed and inconsistent (but at least it is fun). While I have much to say about what I didn’t like about this title – at least it was methodically planned and had a structure which I didn’t feel was going to come crashing down at any moment.

What I didn’t like

· Dialogue: The dialogue in this issue was stilted at best and incomprehensible at worst. Giffen has tried adding his own brand of alien slang which comes across as generic and stereotypically sci-fi. It made the “story” hard to follow and never bore any sense of emotion or humour (although I believe both were attempted).

· Poor Characterisation: I won’t complain too much about there being inconsistencies between the annual and the main series in terms of the already established characters. I mean, who does Arkillo like or dislike at this point? I can only fathom.

However the introduction of a new character, Jediah Caul (Threshold #1 hitting shelves next week) was the most unremarkable character to enter the Green Lantern universe in a long time. For a character to be likeable to the audience he or she must be somewhat relatable or at least understood. What we were given in this issue was a bland stereotype of the “renegade” with no likeable features and nothing remarkable about himself to latch onto.

Do you remember that early issue of Green Lantern Corps years back now, where Guy Gardner went on a mission with a black ops Lantern who had to give up his identity and loved ones to do his job. This bit part character managed to leave more of an impression and have more worth than Jediah Caul.

· Poor attention to detail: I may be nitpicking here, but I believe if you are to writing Green Lantern, you need to know the basic concepts. Therefore, when the ship teleports into “Sector 9001”, you have a right to be a little annoyed at the writing. To add insult to injury a character also comments how close they are to Zamaron (aka Sector 1416). It is simply bad research and begs the question of who is editing this thing.

· Boring: This issue was so dull. This was not helped by the drab colours this issue seemed to be drawn in; as Green Lantern issues should be bright and vibrant, it’s sort of key to the series. The story, which exciting in premise seemed to be a slog and by the end of the issue I was positively fatigued. An annual should be a side story, but it should also be worth the money and be in keeping with the universe it is set in. This issue was not either.

· This issue gave me a headache: True story.

· Was this just a glorified advert for Threshold #1 (hitting shelves next week)? Yes.

Verdict

I really want adventures in Green Lantern: New Guardians which are well paced and sturdily structured. Although I felt this issue was paced well (possibly due to the excess amount of pages it was given) it was for the most part drab, boring and even at point unintelligible. This in many ways felt less like a Green Lantern title than normal. Even if you are a massive Green Lantern fan, this issue can be put right on top of Red Lanterns in the pile of Green-Lantern-Stuff-Not-Worth-Buying

2/10

5 Comments
Posted by Hablerie

This is it!

Posted by zackattack529

Was this at least a GOOD setup to Threshold. and if so do you think Threshold will be a good series worth buying???

Posted by tomlikesfries

Nice review. I've being reading NG since the very first issue, but after reading the reviews for the annual I decided to skip it. Do you think I can read ish #16 without having bought this one? Will I still understand what's going on?

Posted by Green_Tea_Light

Was this at least a GOOD setup to Threshold. and if so do you think Threshold will be a good series worth buying???

If this issue is anything to go by, then certainly not. The character is not interesting and the stories will be similar to this one, ie dull.

Nice review. I've being reading NG since the very first issue, but after reading the reviews for the annual I decided to skip it. Do you think I can read ish #16 without having bought this one? Will I still understand what's going on?

Not at all. Kyle stays behind on Zamaron to learn the last of the Lantern abilities - so does not feature in this issue. They will probably try to convince you in the next issue that this annual was important, but I don't see how that can be true. Nothing of worth happened in the annual. However, if you do find you are lacking information when issue 16 rolls around, just PM me and I'll fill you in lol.,

Posted by tomlikesfries

@Green_Tea_Light: Alright, thanks very much! :)

Other reviews for Green Lantern: New Guardians Annual #1 - The Show Must Go On

    A Better 'Glorified Promo' Than Most 0

    So there's a reason this doesn't have the Rise of the Third Army banner, and that's because it has nothing to do with Rise of the Third Army. This isn't a completely bad thing, but the timing causes this to be the issue's biggest flaw. It's hard to buy that the characters really have the time for a crazy side story like this, granted they didn't choose for things to go wrong, but still. Rise of the Third Army is such a huge thing that I feel like no Green Lantern title can afford NOT to be a par...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Green Lantern: New Guardians Annual #1 Review 0

    Cover & Solicit - 2/5Would I pick-up or buy the comic based on the solicit or cover alone?Are the alternate covers appealing?Does the solicit and cover portray what happens in the issue?Do I like the artist's style on the cover?Art, Colors & Inking - 2/5- Weighted DoubleDo I personally like this artist's style?Does the artist stay true to the characters appearance?If there are multiple artists do they blend well and not disturb the reading experience?Does the coloring/inking blend well w...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.