sinestro_gl's Green Lantern #23.3 - The New Black review

Is this Black Hand? Or The Rot?

This week's Green Lantern Villain's Month issue features Black Hand - wielder of the Black Power Ring - as its main focus. As with all reviews, the following review may (or may not) contain spoilers. Be warned.

New Powers, or a mischaracterization?

One thing about this issue that I've been heavily thinking about is a possible new power introduced to Black Hand. During a scene where Black Hand's zombie army meets resistance from the Coast City Police, William Hand was able to feel a virus present in one of the police officers, and then was able to amplify it, killing the police officer in the process. While this power does fit in with the overall theme of Black Hand, it's not something we've seen him do before. In fact, such an ability has really only been seen with avatars of the Rot - Anton and Abigail Arcane from the Swamp Thing series. So has Charles Soule upgraded William Hands abilities to make him a more fearsome villain, or has the writer, who is the author for quite a number of books this week, including Swamp Thing #23.1, perhaps confused the power sets of two villains associated with death? Well, whatever the case, the powers do fit in with Black Hand's overall theme.

As for the rest of the story, there are some issues with how exactly Black Hand was able to get back to Earth since his last appearance in Geoff John's Green Lantern #20. Did the Indigo tribe show famed compassion for William Hand, and allow his remains to be sent back to his native planet to rest? Surely not. Were there more Black Rings on Earth after the one used by Hal Jordan, of which was originally Black Hand's, was destroyed? Perhaps. There are several continuity questions that need to be clarified - though they shouldn't be the centre of too much attention.

I must say, however, that I wondered how the new creative teams of the Green Lantern title would handle the villains after Geoff Johns conclusion. I was happy to see that William Hand has made his vendetta against Hal a lot more personal.


Initially, I wasn't a fan of Alberto Ponticelli's pencils, but after taking it in for a little while, I soon realized that it fit in with the overall deathly feel of the book, and now have come to like it in this issue. The same can be said of Landini's inking job.

To Summarize

Overall, I was satisfied with this issue. I didn't really want an origin story here, and was happy to see the issue tie-in somewhat to what's going on with Forever Evil. Some setbacks with this issue, but nothing too major for now.

Solid book, but nothing too outstanding.


Posted by DecoyElite

Well Black Hand is an avatar of death so maybe he's also sort of an avatar of rot. Either way his powers here do at least make sense thematically.

Nice review.

Edited by johnkmccubbin91

I've not read this issue but he's bound to have some connection to the Rot.

Edited by sinestro_GL

@johnkmccubbin91: @decoyelite: Well guys, I'm not so sure. The Black Power Rings aren't of Earthly origin, being from Ryut, whereas the Rot, like the Green and Red, is confined to Earth. Perhaps this is a new development, then? Maybe Black Hand's influence on Earth over the years has been noticed by the Rot, or has been seeping in?

In any case, thanks for the recommendations!

Posted by DecoyElite

@sinestro_gl: Well since according to Blackest Night all life began on Earth that would mean all death started there as well so the ring could actually be of Earthly origin, it just ended up seeming alien due to circumstances.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@sinestro_gl: Fair enough, but I would have thought that seems they both centre round death that they'd have a connection that way. Also due to the light spectrum's being there before the rings there may be a chance of a connection. Having not read the issue I can't put much of a view besides that though.

Other reviews for Green Lantern #23.3 - The New Black


    This is another issue from the Villains Month and I can easily say that this is probably one of the most disappointing issues so far for me.I thought Soule was a good writer but in this issue it doesn't seem like it.The whole issue seems to have no exact point and it is just Black Hand wandering around.While it is interesting to see how his powers actually work it seems like he is just another guy that can't die permanently and writers don't know what exactly to do with him rather than raising ...

    5 out of 5 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.