drreneninja's Green Arrow #17 - The Kill Machine, Part 1 review

    Avatar image for drreneninja

    Green Arrow #17 Review

    ***SPOILER FREE REVIEW***

    I can easily say that was the best issue of I've read of the New52 Green Arrow. Admittedly, the competition before this issue was rather mediocre, but it cannot hide one simple fact: The new creative team of Lemire and Sorrentino is something to get very excited about.

    This comic reminds me alot of Nightwing #16, which is great, as I greatly enjoyed that issue as well. In the first issue penned by Jeff Lemire, we see Green Arrow's world being drastically altered, creating a magnificent amount of tension and drama in the comic. Lemire does a great job of balancing action, exposition and plot progression, while leaving us with a litany of questions going forward. Luckily, it looks by the solicits of future issues that these questions will be answered, and I can't wait to continue reading. Lemire also does a great job with the dialogue, carefully balancing Green Arrow as being both awesome, as well as emotional and understanding. While the New52 Green Arrow may be more of a blend of Bruce Wayne and Tony Stark than ever before, we also get a more mortal Green Arrow in this issue, which has always been one of the hallmarks of the Green Arrow character.

    Some questioned on whether Andrea Sorrentino would be a good fit for a title like Green Arrow. He's been really delivering back when he drew I, Vampire, and his dark, gloomy art with all too-handsome protagonists fit the tone of that comic perfectly. Luckily for us, Sorrentino does a great job here, handling penciling, inking AND coloring duties! Since the tone of this comic is quite dark and morbid, Sorrentino's art fits perfect. Luckily for us, he is fully capable of drawing art that does a great job in telling Lemire's story, as well as bringing energy to the action scenes. My only complaint with this comic, is that a few of the characters look too pretty, much like the characters he drew over in I, Vampire. While it works well for immortal vampires, a few of these characters in this issue look to youthful and handsome/beautiful, similar to characters from I, Vampire. Maybe he should use a different model for reference, lol. I would normally subtract a 1/2 star for that. However, I also add a 1/2 star, as Sorrentino does an huge amount of the work on this issue by handling all the art duties of this issue himself.

    Overall, I highly recommend this issue to anyone who is a fan of Green Arrow, wants to read a good Green Arrow story, or is just curious to pick up a new comic. As a fan of Green Arrow myself, it made my day that much more enjoyable knowing that I can fully jump on board and back a Green Arrow comic book again!

    Other reviews for Green Arrow #17 - The Kill Machine, Part 1

      Finally a Serious Series 0

      I've been a fan of Green Arrow for a few years now, and quite enjoyed the pre-New 52 series. I have read the first few issues of this series written by J. T. Krul, but didn't feel like catching up after reading the negative comments about Ann Nocenti's run, and after reading her Catwoman run so far I can truly believe it. So when I heard that a new creative team was joining I was hoping for good things, and after hearing good things about Jeff Lemire's previous work I though I'd give it a try, a...

      13 out of 13 found this review helpful.

      An Arrow Darkly 0

      Yes. Thank you so much, DC. This is.... this is beyond what I ever would have expected from Green Arrow. This instantly surpasses every other Green Arrow story I've ever read; though to be fair I haven't read a whole lot. Jeff Lemire has done a phenomenal job at making this a true 'Issue #17' that launches off what's come before without truly tying itself down to it. You don't need to have read the first 16 issues, which is good because they suck hard, but it doesn't negate their existence. This...

      7 out of 7 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.