@time: okay, top 10 X-men writers..
1. Chris Claremont, of course. Despite probably writing more mediocre X-men comics than any other writer, he's still the king for his classic '80-'86 run. Besides stories like the Dark Phoenix Saga, Days of Future Past, and God Loves, Man Kills which basically redefined both the X-men and the genre, Claremont was really the first mainstream comic writer to pen female and POC characters as more than one dimensional archetypes or plot points, and really I don't think anyone has surpassed him for characterization in general. In his original X-men run, his work on Excalibur, and his wonderful back-up stories in Classic X-Men, this was the guy who made the X-men great in the first place.
2. Joss Whedon. Though he only wrote 25 issues of Astonishing X-Men, those 25 issues are still some of the most solid and entertaining X-men stories that have ever been printed. Easily criticized for not being the most original stories in the X-men's cannon, having been both an homage to Claremont's classic run and a significant nod to Morrison's, his run was still the most well executed and consistent run the X-men have ever had. The definitive X-men of the contemporary age.
3. Grant Morrison. While I don't think Morrison is as good of a writer as Whedon, his run on New X-Men probably had just as many good issues and was far more original overall. E is for Extinction through to Riot at Xavier's are contemporary X-men classics if there are any. If he'd stopped before he got to Planet X I might have even ranked him as #2, but for the year and a half that he turned the X-men into an awful self parody he'll have to settle for #3.
4. Peter David. The only reason I don't rank David higher is that he's never actually written X-men, but I feel like his work on various versions of X-Factor over the years have proved him to be one of the best writers to ever contribute to the X-men's characters and mythos.
5. Stan Lee. Despite not seeming to be able to write women, teenagers, or anyone who wasn't criminally insane realistically, Lee still wrote good stories with amazingly creative characters. X-men may not have been his best example of this, but I still have to admire his creativity in establishing so much of the X-men's world. It's hard to compare him to any other writer, really, since he really established how all Marvel comics were supposed to be written (which was for a much younger audience) until Claremont came along, but I still think he's one of the best.
6. Scott Lobdell. his stuff from the 90's still stands out as some of the better written X-men stories of that era, especially his arc running through Legacies, Fatal Attractions, Phalanx Covenant, and the beginning of Generation X.
7. Brian Bendis. Probably the most polarizing X-men writer since Morrison, arguably also one of the best X-men writers in the same time. As I said above, While I have no great love for his All-New X-Men, especially BotA, I still think his Uncanny X-Men is one of if not the best X-men books to come out in years. And while I consider it more of an Avengers story than an X-men story, House of M was a wonderful series that had a lot of impact on the X-men stories that came after it, and illustrated a great understanding of many of the central X-men characters and themes.
8. Fabian Nicieza. Though he's not a writer that's written the most memorable or classic X-men stories, his character work and plots in the early 90's are still a large part of what I liked about the era. He did for Gambit and Psylocke what Lobdell did for Bishop and Jubilee; he made me like and care about characters I thought were stupid, and for that he gets a spot on the list.
9. Joe Casey. While I wasn't a big fan of Casey's work on Uncanny X-men, he makes this list for his X-men: Children of the Atom mini-series, which was just wonderful.
10. Ed Brubaker. Brubaker makes it onto the list for being able to write like Claremont but with less words. I still think his Divided arc was just perfect.
Log in to comment