@saren: Well, as much as I don't like Lobdell, it's foolish to compare Lobdell to Snyder--Lobdell has great respect for Superman. As far as helplessness, Superman was never helpless under Lobdell. Superman handled his business under Lobdell by himself, just not in a fun or interesting manner.
As far as Johns, never mention Snyder's name in the same breath as Johns when it comes to Superman. Johns phoned in his run and did nothing inspiring, but he at least showed he understood Superman with his last issue.
Snyder's Superman was, according to Lex, was a dog chasing a car. He doesn't really know what he's doing, he has no real motives or philosophy. He just works on trial and error.
As far as Wraith is concerned, Superman didn't beat him--he inconvenienced him slightly since Wraith was the one who saved the day in end. Superman didn't really think his way out either. Superman limited Wraith's energy consumption and then basically fought dirty like Batman would to get Wraith to the ground.
Like I said, Superman didn't beat Wraith, he didn't beat Lane, he didn't stop the alien invasion...he didn't really do anything worth speaking of.
As far as Snyder's taunting, sommeone asked Snyder a question about Superman in a Q&A and his response was something about Batman beating him up when the question had nothing to do with Batman. Plus, Superman and Batman throwing jabs at one and other in a team up book is fine if they're self-aware and both participating in it. Unchained was not that! It was one sided. Superman came asking for help and Batman decided to make him say "uncle" because he's Batman.
I don't care about a villain beating up Batman. Every villain that's a threat to Superman should beat Batman. As far as why I have a problem with Batman's presence in Unchained is simply because I didn't buy Batman and Superman, I bought a Superman book that was supposed to be his 75th year book. I wanted to see him handle his own issues. Has Superman shown up in Eternal yet? 52 books, but no Superman in Batman's anny book.
Azzerello refused to feature it because he didn't like it, but at least he went with a closed universe. Only essential characters were used in Azz's story. Secondly, don't remind me of Lobdell's abomination. I already said Lobdell was disrespectful to Diana his whole run so I don't know why you're highlighting him.
Greg Pak wasn't allowed to touch much of Superman when he started. I think Wonder Woman was reserved for SM/WW exclusively. And Pak was joking about Superman and Batman, not to mention that all Pak said was Superman loved Batman more than Lois, not Diana. Diana wasnt an option for Batman to use as bait since she's Wonder Woman.
As far as Johns, Diana was never going to be featured. Johns already said his chapter was supposed to feature the Daily Planet and getting Clark back to that. BATMAN featured because Romita has been saying how much he wanted to draw Batman since he got on the book. According to what I've been told, he came to DC for Batman, not Superman. Geoff also probably used him for a sales boost to get the new power featured to a larger audience.
Finally, of course I wouldn't mind if Snyder wrote a story featuring either Wonder Woman, Superman or any of the JL if Batman didn't show, but can he help it? Probably not. I don't think I've ever called him a bad writer, I just think he would realize we don't all think Batman is Bat-God.
Log in to comment