I'm sure this topic has been beaten to death on here one way or another, and I'm sorry... I'm just curious
I can't really gauge the consensus here... Is it a good movie, or a bad movie?
I hear good things, I hear bad things... Superman killing Zod doesn't seem like a big deal to me, but a lot of people seem to hate it...
The darker tone it takes was clearly influenced by the Dark Knight movies, but it gave the movie a "Year One" kinda feel IMO... And at least they didn't shroud the action in darkness, you saw everything in broad daylight
So what in your opinions did the movie fail on, and what did it do right (specifically the stuff that wasn't right out of the comics)?