Who should be more visibly muscularly Wonder Woman or PG?

There been much debate on how much muscle these two super heroine should have and there overall physical physique (muscle and fitness wise only here please). But the questions has not been asked. Who should be more visibly muscularly Wonder Woman OR Power Girl?

Wonder Woman. Makes way more sence.

Power Girl should be if just to differentiate her from all the other female heroes

I like Diana having the body of a woman that's active (works out, eats healthy, etc). Not a fan of muscles, really.

@gwhh: Doesn't make much difference. Muscle size alone can't account for their strength, and that's part of both of their power sets in any case. WW's is magic, PG's is super-science---they could both be waifs and still be as strong as they are.

That said, WW is supposed to be the warrior, which would mean bigger muscles. While PG is just plain big, at least since the Connor depictions, and Sears before her. Not a body-builder, just tall and built accordingly.

I like this one a LOT for the body but the face needs a lot of work!

Actually PB is due to biology. Captain America would be due to super-science. I would think Wonder Woman looking like a UFC fighter would make sense, and have PG look like a body builder.

I always think of Power Girl as the buffer one.

Diana. She actually works out. The Kryptos dont.

@bjchitWell, PG's biologically that way, sure, but again, muscle size can't account for her strength. And plenty of Kryptonian females aren't shown as muscular.

@achilles100:

That still doesn't change the point I made.

@superguy1591:

Why would they need to? I've seen PG workout more than Wonder Woman anyway.

@bjchit: Which was what? That she can work out? That she needs to in order to do what she does?

Well, the first has been shown, though now it's sort of silly, since there's really nothing she can lift as a Kryptonian that would build her muscles. The examples I've seen date from her powered down Atlantean era. The second---again, why?

Kryptonians get their power from the sun, (so far), and all she needs to do to get stronger than say Superman is to take a nice long sun dip inside the sun while he's not. Her muscles wouldn't get bigger, (to judge from various artistic impressions over the years). She'd just get stronger and more powerful.

As far as WW goes, there seem to be various magic methods for her to get stronger. And she doesn't seem to get more muscular either.

Essentially, it's a matter of artistic impression, which changes as fashions vary.

@achilles100:

That her powers are biological. How are you not getting this?

@bjchit: So? It's a biology based on nothing we've ever encountered. So might as well classify it as super-science, to distinguish it from Diana's magically based powers. After all, PG is nominally a sci-fi character, or at least she's presented that way, even though technically she's impossible and therefore would be more a fantasy character.

@achilles100:

It's still biological. As I had before, Steve Rogers would be super science.

@bjchit said:

It also doesnt change that your point is wrong. Her super strength is based on the different gravity of earth vs Krypton, she'd have a higher upper power level on Mars even, due to the gravity.

Neither girl needs to have muscles. They, like Superman, should be extremly obese, lazy, gross slobs. They dont need, nor should any of those 3, have muscles.

Er, no, not even close. Not for many years now. She, like any other Kryptonian, has been established since her retcon back to Kryptonian origins as powered by the sun. Nothing has ever yet since been mentioned that Krypton, at least her Krypton, had high gravity. Or that she'd have any superpowers at all after an extended period out of the sun or under a red sun.

I like powergirl to be a little more muscular. But in actuality they both should be muscular.

Muscular? eh. Fit is better. Defined, even.

@cobramorph:

That's just ignorant.

Isn't Wonder Woman suppose to be the most beautiful woman in the world. I don't think that would be the case if she was so muscular.

So is PG...cited on numerous occasions.

@achilles100: so none of them should be muscular because I don't know a single guy who's into muscular women. I know I'm not for sure.

Sure there are guys into muscular women. Just not the vast majority. Perhaps the fitness queen types, but not the female bodybuilders. So who do you go for? The majority audience? And the most popular depictions of PG are typically big women, but not steroid abusers. Take Connor for example, or Lupacinno or Hughes for example.

@achilles100: women shaped like scarlet johansson are what guys are going for nowadays.