@VercingetorixTheGreat said:
@AtPhantom: "Remember, democracy never lasts long. It soon wastes, exhausts, and murders itself."
-John Adams
"Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch. Liberty is a well-armed lamb contesting the vote!"
Benjamin Franklin
True Democracy= Mobocracy
But to answer the question the only thing a government should do is PROTECT PERSONAL FREEDOM, something our government has long since abandoned
The funny thing is, 200 hundred years later western democracy is still going strong.
So again I say learn what democracy means.
Democracy means rule of the people. Not mob, not majority, people. That means that every citizen has equal political rights. Every single citizen is allowed by law to engage in the political processes of the country, to be nominated for a political office and cast his vote in matters which concern the whole country, either by voting for a representative or in a referendum. It means that no single group, by law, is afforded greater political rights than the rest based on their family, wealth, ethnicity, skill or social status. That's the point of democracy. Your only other choices are either Autocracy (Rule of one) or Oligarchy (Rule of few). You'll notice Republic is not on that list because Republic is a completely different freaking thing entirely. Republic means your head of state is an electable position, meaning you are not a monarchy. That's why countries like PRC and USSR could call themselves republics while generally not being democratic.
Obviously democracy is an incredibly broad concept with numerous sub-concepts. The American founding fathers criticized democracy because 250 years ago that only meant Athenian-style direct democracy because representative democracy had not been invented yet (And just to be clear, John Adams was stupidly dead wrong. The Athenian democracy was by far the most politically resilient system Ancient Greece ever produced and its hallmarks held even long after Greece lost all independence and Athens itself became just a part of the Roman empire).
America is a representative democracy. Every western nation is a representative democracy. Many of them are also republics, many are not. Of course America has a lot of quirks in its system due to its confederative nature, states rights, electoral college, all those sorts of things, and there's a movement now to even out all those things and bring elections to a uniform federal level (Which it should, it's been centuries since the USA was anything other than a single nation), but that has nothing to do with the questions "Is US a democracy?" and "Is US a republic?", and the answer to both of those questions is YES!
Log in to comment