Video Game/Movie: Which is worse?

So yeah, generally speaking, game-based movies and movie-based games are not that good. So which of the two is actually worse than the other? Video games based on movies or movies based on video games? Do leave out the exceptions and look at it from a generalist point-of-view.

Well, since I'm a sucker for Tomb Raider movies (HELLLLOOOOO Angelina Jolie) I go with Movie-based games

Movie based games are usually short and have crappy multiplayer.

Actually that is very hard to pick... Probably a video game based on a movie, based on a game like Street Fighter the Movie the Game.

Chronicles of Riddick: Escape from Butcher bay, beats out the movies, so i say movie based on games. Some games don't have enough to transfer to a movie like Mario

*cough*E.T (Atari 2600)*cough*

This post is a win!

Immediately remembered Uwe Boll and all Bloodrayne movies, Far Cry and Postal… I’ll go with game-based movies being worse.

There is more movie based games than video game based movies so going with movie based games

Game-based movies are much worse (curse you Uwe Boll!), there have been some really great movie-based games.

game based movies..

resident evil / tekken / doom

Both are usually terrible, but ill go with game based movies due to Uwe Boll.

Ehm, it's kind of half and half for me. The Cap game made a few years back was fun as heck! Thor was the complete opposite. Spider-Man 2 and TASM were pretty fantastic, R.I.P.D. was not.

yea both suck tho game's based on movies i feel is more consistently suckish.

i did like that wolverine game from a couple yrs back.

also i did get some enjoyment out of the mortal kombat movies.

I actually liked Green Lantern Rise of the Manhunters, Home Alone for the SNES, Aladdin for the Genesis, etc.

Movies based on videogames are fail after fail.

Game based movies, if only because they have more potential.