The Chocolate Factory Movie: 1971 vs 2005

I find the 2005 version better overral.

The 1971 version. I find it more magical. :)

why?

@ganon15: The musics are more appealing,the scenario is is more colorful(wich i like) and the plot is,well... better!

I barely remember the 1971 version.

The 1971 version because it felt magical, Gene Wilder, better ending and was better overall. But the 2005 version was funnier, especially the fat kid always eating.

nothing beats the original.

1971 or gtfo

1971

1971. Although I did actually enjoy the remake.

Tie

Gene Wilder ftw.

Always Gene, and also the director of the 1971 version was respectful, unlike films by Tim Boofhead Burton who giggles like a halfwit simp at the thought of "deconstructing" things.

I like both but I'd have to go with the 1971 version.

I don't particularly like either movie all that much. I grew up with the 2005 version, so I'm inclined to choose that one, but the 1971 version is better overall, I think.

didn't care for the remake that much

Never watched the original, but the Angry Video Game Nerd said it was better.