#1 Edited by tasir (303 posts) - - Show Bio

which show is better over all and why

i personally say Sherlock because it has better characters and better character relationships

what do you say

#2 Posted by ssejllenrad (12847 posts) - - Show Bio

Sherlock is one of the best renditions of the character. Not accurate to the smallest detail but authentic to the character. It had intelligent plots and the fact that it has minimal number of episodes (like most UK shows) makes the writers concentrate on good script.

Elementary is dumbsh*t ripoff that was most likely conceived by the writers while watching Sherlock. I just watched as much episodes as that BBC series (ummm.. like 6?) and quit on the series altogether. It's not smart. It's not interesting. It's bullsh*t. How that show was renewed for a second season is beyond me.

#3 Posted by feebadger (1405 posts) - - Show Bio

Sherlock is one of the best renditions of the character. Not accurate to the smallest detail but authentic to the character. It had intelligent plots and the fact that it has minimal number of episodes (like most UK shows) makes the writers concentrate on good script.

Elementary is dumbsh*t ripoff that was most likely conceived by the writers while watching Sherlock. I just watched as much episodes as that BBC series (ummm.. like 6?) and quit on the series altogether. It's not smart. It's not interesting. It's bullsh*t. How that show was renewed for a second season is beyond me.

Don't think i could add another syllable :)

#4 Edited by judasnixon (6085 posts) - - Show Bio

Sherlock is better, but Elementry isn't bad.......

#5 Posted by ssejllenrad (12847 posts) - - Show Bio

Want an interesting American-made "Sherlock-based" character? Don't go the Elementary route. Go and watch Psych or Monk or the Mentalist or House. All of them are better than Elementary.

#6 Posted by tasir (303 posts) - - Show Bio

speaking of sherlock when are new episodes coming out

#7 Posted by ssejllenrad (12847 posts) - - Show Bio

@tasir: They're still in pre-production of season 3.