@king_saturn said :
Okay, let's try this One More Time...
This is the actual verse being referenced :
Quran 16:93 "And if Allah had willed, He could have made you all one religion, but he causes to stray whom he wills and he guides whom he wills. And you will surely be questioned about what you used to do"
Now you had me read that one piece of the passage at hand that's not even the fullness of the passage we are talking about... I said in specific that Allah guides whom he wills and he rejects whom he wills ( paraphrasing ) as Allah chooses whom he will save and whom he will not. How exactly is this passage NOT clear of this ? It even says, If Allah had willed, he could have made you all one religion in the beginning of the passage... meaning Allah did not will for this to be. In other words, Allah saves whom he will and rejects or turns away whom he wills. It's clear here... and YES, it is you who have twisted the passage as you are too afraid to even quote the verse correctly.
You are no different from Christians... You Quote Mine your Holy Book and Condemn People just like The Christians do... Same Sh!t, Different Toilet.
This Teacher Analogy again... we already been over this. There is no reason for the Teacher to give a Test if he already knows what the results of the Test will be... as a matter of fact the Teacher should create conditions for the students where they could pass the test knowing they would not under the current conditions... or not have the students for the test at all. This goes directly with Allah's Omniscience and Omnipotence... as the Teacher has none of the components of Allah's Divinity making the Analogy "Completely Stupid"
I didn't change the passage... as a matter of fact I am the only one here who even gave the full extent of the passage and elaborated on it... you took a clip of the passage and tried to use it for your own benefit in this discussion. You twisted the passage in other words.
If GOD knows where you will end up before you exist... then he has predetermined your fate beforehand... he may not directly choose every choice for you... but what does that matter if he knows what you will do before you do it ? It's like saying a Computer Programmer knows that he will create a Program that will do nothing but create Viruses for Computers before Crashing the System... but the Programmer still creates the Software because he wants to give it a chance to exist ? See how stupid that sh!t sounds ?
Yeah, and I just killed your argument like 4 or 5 times already in the last 2 posts I replied to you with.
GOD doesn't care where a Man goes... just as long as there is some in Heaven and some in Hell... GOD is straight with that. If GOD did care where all humans go... he would guide all of us. GOD would not care about Tests... as he would have to see the greater picture here... which is, guiding someone to an Eternal Life of Positive Existence is better than to purposely save some and lead other astray as what is said in Quran 16:93 ( The Passage You So Willfully Quote Mined )
Sorry, I am getting tired of this mess because you are losing on all fronts...
Ok this is the actual verse : Quran 16:93 "And if Allah had willed, He could have made you all one religion, but he causes to stray whom he wills and He guides whom he wills. And you will surely be questioned about what you used to do"
In your previous post you changed the verse and posted : "Allah chooses whom he will guide and whom he will not" See ?? YOU changed the verse .
You are paraphrasing wrong . You have not even understood the meaning of this verse and so you can't paraphrase it . And did you even read my previous post?? It looks like you completely ignored my post . You are again stating that Allah chooses whom he will save and whom he will not. I already explained that guiding is different than saving . And you are making it sound like we don't have a free will . You are making it sound like that God is like a baby who doesn't know anything and wanders the world and whoever he sees , he guides or rejects him without any reason . You have misunderstood this verse . God does everything for a reason . And he does not randomly guide or rejects someone . He guides everyone who wants to be guided and is striving to find Him . He rejects everyone who is not a good man , does not strive to find his God and is evil . He does not guide these kind of people and hence, he rejects them .
Yes , Allah could have made us of one religion by taking our free will , making us like robots , putting devils and beasts behind who ever doesn't follow him etc etc . There are a number of ways in which He could have made us of one religion and in all of these ways , we won't have a free will or won't be able to use it . So God could have made us of one religion , but he has decided to give us a free will .
LOL , it is I ?? I who have twisted the verse?? The above portion clearly shows that you are the one who has twisted the verse .
Muslims and Christians are different.
Man , it is pointless , just pointless , to be debating with you , you ignore everything I say and repeat the same thing over and over again . Do you even think about something before replying to it??
I clearly said that if the teacher knew that the student will fail and he fails him before giving him the test , the student won't accept the decision of the teacher and therefore , it is necessary to give the test . And what's the point of the test if the teacher creates conditions for the student in which he is sure that the student will pass? That's like saying that the teacher cuts all the wrong answers in all the MCQs in a test and marks the right one and then gives it to the student . Would that be a test?? No , it won't be . A test is something which we have to pass by our own hardwork . This analogy is nowhere near stupid .
You did change the passage . Yes , you gave the full extent of the passage but before , you only took a clip of the passage and tried to twist it . And now you are accusing me of using a clip of the verse to get to it to my advantage ?? Wow , just wow . You truly are a troll . You are the one who took the clip of the passage first and twisted it . I only used the clip of the verse because we were just arguing about that clip at that time which was that whether Allah predetermines our fate or not . The rest of the verse was irrelevant that's why there was no point in using it .
Can you understand things like a normal man ?? Why do you not understand anything and why do you ignore everything and repeat the same things over and over again?? God has not predetermined anything except our birth and death . He doesn't choose what you do , you choose what you do . Now you are being pathetic . Why are you comparing a computer program with a human being . A computer program doesn't have any free will . We have a free will . We decide where we will end up . God has created everyone equal . It is upto us to follow him or not . If we end up in Hell , it is our fault . God has given us a free will and His book and guidance . If we don't even bother to go to his path , then how is God responsible for our fate?
You never killed my argument . All you have done is ignore my arguments . You are only killing my arguments in your head .
God cares where a man goes . God already has given you the guidance ( his word , the Quran ) . It is upto us whether we use that guidance or not . And God guides everyone who wants to be guided . He wants that everyone take His guidance and go to Heaven but god doesn't guide those people who do not want to be guided .
"…He causes not to stray, except those who forsake (the path)," (Quran 2:26)
This verse clearly shows that God only misguides who don't want to be guided .
and this :
"And those who strive in Our (cause),- We will certainly guide them to our Paths: For verily Allah is with those who do right." (Quran 29:69)
God guides who want to be guided .
What's the point of this cheap comment at the end of your post?? What is this supposed to do?? Scare me?? You are not winning by anyway . If anyone's losing , that's you .
And , if you are further going to ignore what I say and keep repeating the same thing over and over again , then there is no point in arguing anymore .
Log in to comment