Rate the NFL player above you

Simple, rate 1-5. I mainly am talking about CURRENT players, but I reckon you could post past players as well.

1 - Horrible, why is this guy even a pro?

2 - He sucks, expect him to be traded a lot.

3 - Good player, he helps with the teams success. Not quite a HOF contender.

4 - Great player, he could be a MVP, and help take his team to the Super Bowl, possibly a HOF contender.

5 - Amazing player. His number will be retired and he is headed to the HOF without a doubt.

I'm going to start off with my teams top dawg:

Aaron Rodgers, QB for Green Bay Packers

5,He is Aaron Rodgers......he is Aaron f*cking Rodgers

Tom Brady.

5. Without a doubt. 2000-2010 will always be remembered as the Patriots era.

Clay Matthews

4. For me.

Troy Polamalu

4. He is def. going to the HOF and Steelers HOF.

Matt Ryan

3 - Matt has a lot of potential but considering the position he plays he got to do a lot more before he rates above a three.

How about . . J.J. Watt?

Hmmm I would rate Watt a 4 for now but he certinly has potential to be a 5 and maybe even the G.O.A.T Defensive End.

Ray Lewis

Lewis is a 5 no doubt about that

Adrian Peterson

5 - I think he's an A-hole but there is absolutely no question he's one of the all-time greats.

How about . . . Ndamukong Suh?

Hmm I'm gonna say 3 Suh has to put in more years to be considered an 5 or 4 imo,not to mention last year was not a good year for a player of his caliber

Drew Brees

4 or 5 - Brees has already had a great career and, barring injury, will continue to have a great career.

How about . . . Rob Gronkowski?

3

Adrian Peterson

4

Andrew Luck

3 for now,although by time his career ends he will probably be a 4 or 5

3 for Tony Romo

Calvin Johnson WR Lions

4 - Calvin Johnson might end up a 5 but to do so he would have to do even more for the Lions and I don't know if that's even possible.

How about . . . Jared Allen?

Hmmm 4

@dccomicsrule2011 said:

Hmmm 4

2.5. He's one of the worst players on that squad, but that's not saying much

My man Josh Freeman...GO BUCS!!

3 - Flacco has proven calm under pressure and does have one Super Bowl win but he's going to have to do a lot more to become a HoF candidate.

How about . . . Ely Manning?

Hmm I going to say a 4 Eli is a 2 time Superbowl champion and MVP,not to mention he held the title "4th Quarter King"

3 - Newton could climb to 4 or maybe 5 if he stays healthy and gets some help. He's got all the tools.

How about . . . Charles Woodson?

3

Aaron hernandez?

@cybrilious4:

Aaron hernandez?

Your trying to be funny aren't you? =O Anyway when he played he was probably a 3

Darrel Revis

4 - He's pretty close to being a shut-down CB.

How about . . . Justin Smith?

@dccomicsrule2011: There were too many 3-4 on here and somebody had to post a (1) player

Darrel Revis (3)

Justin Smith (2)

Greg Jennings?

Just barely a 3. I'm not so sure that his success didn't come from being on the Packers with Rodgers throwing to him. If he is more than a 3 he will prove it being on the Vikings having Ponder throw to him

Matt Forte

Matt Forte is like a 3.5 essentially...

Ed Reed

MY BOY TAZ.

I'm sorry, I don't actually watch NFL. I just wanted to put some humor in here. Tell me when there's an NBA thread like this though.

5.5...Best saftey to ever live.

Ronde Barber

Is Tebow Time!. And i give Barber a 4

@perethorn said:

Is Tebow Time!. And i give Barber a 4

1. People only like him because of his college success.

Eric Berry

4

Troy Polamalu

@banestrokelobogrundybatarrow said:

Troy Polamalu

3.5. A little overrated but still a damn good player.

Brian Dawkins. I hate the goddamn Philadelphia Eagles with a mighty passion, but Brian Dawkins is one of my all-time favorite players

4,Dawkins was a pure beast in his prime.

@dccomicsrule2011 said:

4,Dawkins was a pure beast in his prime.

4.2. Almost positive he'll be a HOFer someday.

Brian Orakpo

3

Peyton Manning

5 - Peyton Mannning is without question or doubt a 5.

How about . . . Dwight Freeney?