Sorry if this has been done before, I'm just curious. 5 point system:
1: Very Bad, seems to use profanity and personal attacks with little to no logic, the worst.
2: Needs Help, while not the worst, fanboyism is evident in their posts to an extent.
3: Average, not bad, not good, just lukewarm.
4: Great: these people can move an argument along very well and while logic is prevalent in their posts, sometimes they aren't exactly backed up by evidence.
5: Elite: the elite have it all, they got the logic and the evidence and they rarely (if ever) lose a debate. best of the best.
Also, who do you think is the best and worst debater?