Independence Day vs War of the Worlds

Independence Day aliens and battle ships vs War of the World aliens and battle ships

Who was a bigger threat to earth? Who would win out of these 2 different alien races?

Bump!! Come on this could be a really good battle so which one do you think wins?

The ID4 aliens showed more firepower and, considering the ending, I'd say better defenses, too.

Also, this isn't between comic book characters, so I'll move to off-topic.

ID4 imo

I agree with this.

The Aline's form Independence Day almost won if it wasnt for one brave human who uttered the words "hello boys I'm back!"

@_gaff_:

what the heck is that?

League of Extraordinary Gentlemen vol.2

Mr. Hyde taking down a tripod by crippling one of its legs.

ID easily the ships were sizes of cities

The mothership was like a Country size and I mean Russia

The beam would destroy tripods

Butchu kno tht Covenant....

@_gaff_:

ah okay

Independence Day gets this in a stomp those shields tanked a nuke with ease war of the worlds just became stomp of the worlds

This

War of the Worlds aliens were crap. This is a major stomp in favor to ID aliens.

Indepence Day. I was mesmerized by this film as a youngster.

War of the World invented modern sci-fi,

It'd cause a paradox if Indepence Day tried to destroy it.

Didn't the WOTW aliens get killed by our pathogens?

Independence Day.

@texasdingo: yes sir.

Will Smith. All I gotta say.

Someone put this on off topic even though there was comics of ID4 and some of War of the Worlds, so now that they did this I do not know how to bring this thread back to the battle forms, and I wish someone would have checked to see if they had comics of these 2 movies before moving my thread, but I will make another thread of these 2 movies/comics, and hopefully no one moves it.... I am going to make a poll to see which one gets more votes...

@darklord_apoc:

you could ask the Mods

but I would not as this is a stomp if not a unintentional spite