Dexter vs Sherlock

#1 Posted by The Stegman (12895 posts) - 8 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

Scenario- 
 
Miami Metro Homicide decided to reopen the ''Bay Harbor Butcher'' case,realizing that the killer is still out there, and possibly in Miami. Unbeknownst to them, the killer is right under their noses, the Blood Splatter Analyst, Dexter Morgan. However, realizing the Butcher, whoever he is, is too clever to be caught, they enlist help.  They call in Sherlock Holmes, consulting detective. They give him all the information they have on the Butcher. His apparent M.O, known victims, etc. Meanwhile Dexter watches from his lab, eyes narrowed, wondering what he will have to do to outsmart the detective. 
 
RULES- 
-Morals on, Dexter's Code of Harry applies 
-Dexter knows who Sherlock is, and his case history, but not how intelligent he is. 
-Sherlock meets Dexter, and looks him over, but that's all the contact they have during the initial meeting. 
-Dexter has access to his usually Miami Metro Police database. 
 
Can Sherlock figure out that Dear Demented Dexter is our Dastardly Demon? And more importantly, can he survive the physical altercation if he does crack the case? 
 

vs 
Online
#2 Posted by utotheg38 (18883 posts) - 8 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

Sherlock

#3 Posted by YourNeighborhoodComicGeek (13821 posts) - 8 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio
  1. I think Sherlock may be able to figure out who Dexter is, especially if he has a description on his appearance.
  2. He probably dies if PIS is off. If not, then he somehow survives miraculously/conveniently.
#4 Posted by Kid_Juggernaut (24 posts) - 8 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

Open up a can of Baritsu!

#5 Posted by Selinaky (666 posts) - 8 months, 3 days ago - Show Bio

I think Sherlock would find out. I mean, by his code, Dexter can't kill him just because he's a detective... he hasn't killed Quinn or Batista. If Sherlock started getting close, he's still an innocent, right? Doakes was killed indirectly by Dexter, but Dex kidnapped him.

Please Log In

Use your keyboard!

  • ESC