It was posted 4 months ago but I just saw it tonight.
https://www.reddit.com/r/whowouldwin/comments/37si0r/comicvine_vs_whowouldwin
Your thoughts?
It was posted 4 months ago but I just saw it tonight.
https://www.reddit.com/r/whowouldwin/comments/37si0r/comicvine_vs_whowouldwin
Your thoughts?
Comicvine is probably a more credible community, but fanboys spoil everything.
So they both fail
I agree with you.
Jeez, they seem to really dislike Comic Vine...
I don't know why.... They say this site has more idiots but I have to disagree. We have our share but nothing like what Reddit has....
Reddit has a far more substantial base of users.......
They would stomp us..........
It'd be like Helm's Deep..........
We'd be fighting a losing battle against forces that far outnumber us........
Until our one Lord and saviour Wenjun Chew rode in on his white horse, leading a massive army of Jimmy Rustlers to turn the tide..........
Comicvine stomps.
The first time I saw debates on whowouldwin a week ago I lost count of how many times I shook my head and facepalmed.
Comicvine stomps.
The first time I saw debates on whowouldwin a week ago I lost count of how many times I shook my head and facepalmed.
I visit it once in awhile and I facepalmed a lot still. They don't show facts or even scans when they debate unlike they do here.
I honestly feel like Comicvine, for all the faults it can have, is a more credible place to have a debate. I mean, the search bar is right at the top of any given page.
I agree.
Comicvine stomps.
The first time I saw debates on whowouldwin a week ago I lost count of how many times I shook my head and facepalmed.
I visit it once in awhile and I facepalmed a lot still. They don't show facts or even scans when they debate unlike they do here.
I honestly feel like Comicvine, for all the faults it can have, is a more credible place to have a debate. I mean, the search bar is right at the top of any given page.
I agree.
One of the first posts I saw on that thread...
–]Mister_Alucard 10 points 4 months ago
Every time I look up a fight on Comicvine everyone seems to be like "Well I'm pretty sure this is what happened..." With no scans or evidence or anything.
Meanwhile here we seem to like sources and well reasoned arguments.
Comicvine stomps.
The first time I saw debates on whowouldwin a week ago I lost count of how many times I shook my head and facepalmed.
I visit it once in awhile and I facepalmed a lot still. They don't show facts or even scans when they debate unlike they do here.
I honestly feel like Comicvine, for all the faults it can have, is a more credible place to have a debate. I mean, the search bar is right at the top of any given page.
I agree.
One of the first posts I saw on that thread...
–]Mister_Alucard 10 points 4 months ago
Every time I look up a fight on Comicvine everyone seems to be like "Well I'm pretty sure this is what happened..." With no scans or evidence or anything.
Meanwhile here we seem to like sources and well reasoned arguments.
I saw that post too. I mean you'd think they'd say at least mention something else, given that Comicvine has a reputation for "feats," and no one takes things like character statements too seriously here. The fact that they made that claim already shows me they don't know what they're talking about; either that or they're intentionally reaching just to make their site seem better.
Some users there have a point. There are too many fanboys on this site and the battle forums are a total mess. Too many cases of "X stomps" or "X solos" in good fights that end up looking like a one-sided mismatch or spite. There's not enough proper debating nor the proper users to execute such tasks but just a competition of who gets more votes or posts and only idiots would use the majority decision as a means to determine who would win and apply ABC logic without proper acknowledgement for any real arguments actually made plus they are more respectful to one another over there regardless of differences in opinion and not as divided as we are over here.
That being said. They themselves are not perfect either.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment